All papers published in this volume of IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science have been peer reviewed through processes administered by the Editors. Reviews were conducted by expert referees to the professional and scientific standards expected of a proceedings journal published by IOP Publishing.
• Type of peer review : Single-blind
• Describe criteria used by Reviewers when accepting/declining papers. Was there the opportunity to resubmit articles after revisions?
∘ The review was done by considering five (5) aspects :
1) Relevance with topics
2) Novelty and originality
3) Clarity
4) Systematic
5) Analysis techniques and deduction
∘ One reviewer gave points on each aspect between 1-4. Based on total points from those four aspects :
1) Definitely Accept : 16-20
2) Accept : 11-15
3) Possibly Accept : 7-10
4) Rejected : 5-6
∘ There was an opportunity to resubmit articles after revisions.
• Conference submission management system:
The paper is uploaded via EDAS (https://edas.info/)
• Number of submissions received : 70 papers
• Number of submissions sent for review : 60 papers
• Number of submissions accepted : 48 papers
• Acceptance Rate (Number of Submissions Accepted / Number of Submissions Received X 100) : 68.57
• Average number of reviews per paper : 2
• Total number of reviewers involved : 36
• Any additional info on review process (eg Plagiarism check system) :
∘ The similarity score was checked by the editors to find the plagiarism using https://www.turnitin.com/.
∘ The standard similarity score to be accepted is less than 15%.
• Contact person for queries (Full name, affiliation, institutional email address) :
Name : Ayodya Pradhipta Tenggara
Affiliation : Universitas Gadjah Mada
Email address : ayodya.p.t@ugm.ac.id