Table of contents for issue 5, volume 21, Superconductor Science and Technology

Volume 21

Number 5, May 2008

Previous issueNext issue

SPECIAL ISSUE CONTAINING PAPERS FROM MEM07: THE 5TH ANNUAL WORKSHOP ON MECHANICAL AND ELECTROMAGNETIC PROPERTIES OF COMPOSITE SUPERCONDUCTORS (PRINCETON, NJ, USA, 21–24 AUGUST 2007)

Buy this issue in print

    PREFACE

  • 050301
    The following article is Free article

    , and

    MEM07 was the 5th international workshop concentrating on the mechanical and electrical properties of composite superconductors, which are the technological conductor forms from which practical superconducting devices are made. Such superconducting conductors respond to important challenges we currently face, especially those concerned with the proper management of the world's energy resources. Superconductivity provides a means to address the challenges in the generation, transmission and distribution, and use of energy.

    For energy generation, the ITER Fusion Tokomak (now underway in France) provides exciting new challenges for the whole superconductivity community, due to the enormous size and strong fields of the plasma confinement superconducting magnets that will form the largest and most powerful superconducting machine yet built. Significant attention was paid at MEM07 to the modeling, characterization, testing and validation of the high-amperage Nb3Sn cable-in-conduit conductors needed for ITER.

    As for electric energy industry uses, there was much discussion of both first generation (Bi,Pb)2Sr2Ca2Cu3Ox conductors and the rapidly emerging second generation coated conductors made from YBa2Cu37-x. High-performing, affordable conductors of these materials are vital for large capacity transmission cables, energy storage systems, fault current limiters, generators and motors—many prototypes of which are being pursued in technologically advanced countries.

    There is a broad consensus that the prototype stage for high-current–high-field superconducting applications is nearing its end and that large scale applications are technologically feasible. However full industrialization of large-scale superconducting technologies in electric utility applications will benefit from continuous improvement in critical current, lower ac loss, higher strength and other vital conductor properties. The establishment of optimal procedures for the system design accompanying scale-up is a second vital task. As system design is dependent on material development, there is a critical need to study the key issues in developing high performance superconducting materials.

    The emphases of MEM07 were

    • The mechanical properties of superconductors including the influence of stress and strain on the critical current of practical conductors including YBCO and ReBCO coated conductors, BSCCO tapes, MgB2 wires and Nb3Sn filamentary conductors.

    • The intrinsic strain effects on critical current density in Nb3Sn, YBCO, BSCCO and MgB2.

    • Recent advances in critical current, the mechanical properties and the reduction in ac losses of HTS tapes and wires.

    • The compositional and microstructural dependence of E–J characteristics and explanations based on flux pinning, grain boundary weak-links and other mechanisms.

    • Standardized test-methods: international cooperative research work to establish test methods for assessing the mechano-electromagnetic properties of superconductors based on the activities of IEC/TC90 and VAMAS/TWA-16.

    More than 60 researchers from more than 12 countries attended the MEM07 workshop, and about 40 presentations were made. A small selection of papers (15) from the workshop are included in this special issue of Superconductor Science and Technology. Taken together with papers published at earlier MEM meetings, this issue provides an updated view of some of the current state-of-the-art research in the mechano-electromagnetic properties of composite superconductors.

    The workshop was organized under the activities of the NEDO Grant Project (Applied Superconductivity, 2004EA004) and VAMAS/TWA-16. The meeting was organized by a committee composed of David Larbalestier (Conference Chair) aided by MEM05 and MEM06 Conference Chairs Kozo Osamura (Research Institute for Applied Sciences, Kyoto, Japan), Damian Hampshire (Durham University, UK) and Arman Nyilas (CEME). The Program Committee was composed of Ettore Salpietro (European Fusion Development Agreement), Neil Mitchell (ITER), Kozo Osamura, Damian Hampshire and Arman Nyilas.

    We express our great thanks to all those whose efforts were key in organizing the meeting, with very special thanks to our Meeting Planner Kate Liu who organized matters large and small with discretion and great efficiency.

  • SPECIAL PAPERS

  • 054001

    , and

    The relevance of short sample measurements in SULTAN for the prediction of the performance of the coils of the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) is assessed using the case of the Nb3Sn high-field central solenoid model coil (CSMC) conductor, for which both coil performance and short sample SULTAN results (Good Joint (GJ) sample) are available. A least-squares fit procedure, based on a uniform current distribution among the strands and the Durham scaling relations for the field, temperature and strain dependences of the strand Jc provides a thermal strain of −0.294% and a degradation factor of approximately 60% for the GJ sample. In the calculation of the voltage along Layer 1A of the CSMC the hoop stress and the variation of the magnetic field in the conductor cross-section were taken into account. The temperature profile, used in the calculations, is based on published temperature profiles and empirical relations between helium inlet and outlet temperatures. A comparison with the GJ results indicates that short sample measurements in SULTAN provide a conservative estimate of the coil performance.

  • 054002

    , , , , , , , and

    A modeling study was carried out to provide a description of the critical current distribution of bent multifilamentary Bi2223/Ag/Ag alloy superconducting composite tape samples. In the modeling, the difference between the tensile fracture strain of the Bi2223 filaments along the sample length under no residual strain and residual strain was used as a unifying parameter for the description of the damage evolution. The unifying parameter was treated to be different from sample to sample and also from position to position in each sample. The statistics of the unifying parameter were combined with the shape of the core and exerted tensile strain of the Bi2223 filaments, from which the relation of the heterogeneous damage evolution to the distribution of the critical current was formulated. The proposed model was applied to the reported data of 33 samples of the round robin test of VAMAS (Versailles project on advanced materials and standard)/TWA16 (Technical working area 16, superconducting materials) in 2000–2001. The reported distributions of the critical current of the bent-damaged samples were described well by the present model.

  • 054003

    and

    EAST is a full superconducting Tokamak with superconducting toroidal field (TF) and poloidal field (PF) magnets designed with NbTi cable-in-conduit conductors. Superconducting joints have been used due to the limitations of conductor piece length and connections between magnets. The overlap joint twin box type is developed for the TF coil outer joints to connect 16 D shape TF magnets. The 17 TF coil outer joints constitute a loop parallel to the PF coil systems, so the rapid variation of magnetic field will induce high AC losses in the TF coil outer joints. In this paper, AC losses and Joule heating of these joints during a plasma scenario are analyzed and calculated, and the temperature rise of helium in joints is also estimated by a simple heat balance.

  • 054004

    The observed strain dependence of the critical current of Nb3Sn composite superconductors is described by strain scaling laws in which the strain dependence of the effective upper critical field plays a prominent role. The strain dependence of the effective upper critical field is in turn given by a strain scaling function, or simply strain function. Recently, a general invariant strain function was suggested by a detailed analysis of the physical basis of strain dependence in Nb3Sn. The invariant strain function is viewed as giving a general formulation of strain dependence for all configurations of applied strain. In order to gain familiarity with the invariant strain function and to explore its range of validity, the invariant strain function is compared with previous empirical strain functions including the power law, the deviatoric description, the polynomial form, and the deviatoric power law. The invariant strain function is found to give a unified representation of strain dependence, including the characteristics that are observed for longitudinal applied strain to wires, and the observations that were made for tapes under multidimensional strain that led to the deviatoric description.

  • 054005

    Nb3Sn cable in conduit type conductors (CICC) are a popular choice for high current conductors operating in steady or slowly changing current/field conditions. They provide a low cost way of bundling strands together to achieve large conductor currents at high field (up to 13 T), allowing a reduction in coil voltage requirements. The extensive strand contact, although giving relatively high AC losses, gives resilience against current non-uniformity and local strand damage, and there is good stability to electromagnetic disturbances due to the extensive helium contact area with the strands.

    In the last 5–6 years there has been clear evidence of Nb3Sn CICC performance degradation compared to expectations based on strand measurements. Investigations have linked this to filament bending and fracture under the mechanical loads, and particularly their accumulation from top to bottom of a cable. These effects were not widely expected to occur in small cables, and even in large ones their extent was expected to be limited. However, in 2006 testing of a small 15 kA conductor intended for a dipole showed severe degradation that continuously increased with cycling and some large 70 kA CICC have also shown a higher than expected performance drop. Experimental evidence strongly suggests that the degradation is dependent not only on the cable pattern but also on the sensitivity of different types of Nb3Sn strands to bending and pinching. The variability of results, with some strand–cable combinations giving a satisfactory performance, has provided an incentive to improve the modelling of the degradation to provide better predictions at the strand level of the characteristics needed for successful cable performance.

    Modelling was being developed as early as 2005 with an analytic cable mechanical model but a simplified and non-physical procedure to then derive the superconducting performance. The mechanical model was successfully benchmarked against overall mechanical property measurements on cables. This paper continues the development towards a complete predictive cable degradation model, this time covering the link between filament bending and damage (available from the earlier mechanical model and also increasingly from more sophisticated numerical simulations) and the overall superconducting performance, benchmarked using data from strand tests.

  • 054006

    , , , , and

    Tensile fatigue tests were carried out at 77 K for YBCO-coated conductors fabricated by metal–organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD). The S–N relationship, variation of critical current (Ic) during cyclic loading and microscopic fatigue damage were investigated. Fatigue strength at 106 cycles was evaluated to be σmax = 1300 MPa and 890 MPa under the stress ratios of 0.5 and 0.1. Two different mechanisms of fatigue damage, depending on the number of stress cycles to failure, were observed. In one of the fracture mechanisms, fatigue behavior is characterized by overall fracture which occurs at 104–105 cycles. For these specimens, Ic after unloading does not degrade before overall fracture. Although only shallow slip bands were found at the Ag surface, fatigue cracks were found on the Hastelloy C-276 surface of the fractured specimen. These results suggest that overall fracture due to cyclic stress was caused by fatigue of the Hastelloy substrate. In the other fracture mechanism, even though overall fracture did not occur at 106 cycles, a slight decrease of Ic was detected after 105 cycles. No fatigue crack was found on the Hastelloy surface, while deep slip bands corresponding to the initial stage of fatigue crack were observed on the Ag surface. From these results, we concluded that Ic degradation at a high cycle number is attributed to the fatigue of the Ag stabilizing layer.

  • 054007

    , , , , , and

    Heretofore, an accurate residual stress in Ag-sheathed superconducting composite tape could not be obtained from a measurement using conventional low energy x-rays due to the large x-ray absorption in Ag phase. Therefore, we developed a method for evaluating the residual strain in the filaments using neutron diffraction and finite element method (FEM) analysis, measuring the mechanical curvature. As for the residual strain of the Ag phase and Bi phase in a high strength type specimen, the Bi phase has a compressive longitudinal strain, and the Ag phase has a tensile strain; these are thermally balanced residual stresses at room temperature that depend on the mismatch of the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE). On the other hand, there was very little thermally induced stress at the room temperature in the high Ic specimen. The numerical residual strain obtained by the FEM analysis agrees with experimental neutron method results. In a high critical current (Ic) type specimen, the existence of a stress relaxation mechanism during the heat treatment is suggested.

  • 054008

    , , and

    Coated conductors are becoming more and more applicable. The temperature range below the critical value (Tc) or below the critical current (Ic) is well characterized. But for applications such as fault current limiters, which take advantage of the superconducting-to-normal transition, characterization beyond the superconducting regime is mandatory. Therefore, this work studies the thermodynamic behaviour of a coated conductor immersed in boiling liquid nitrogen which is driven by a sinusoidal over-current of up to more than five times Ic. The temperature of the coated conductor exceeds 720 K without any significant degradation. To validate this current-induced high-temperature region, the resistance of the composite tape is measured from Tc to 600 K. A thermodynamic and electrical model is conceptualized for calculating the temperature, developing as a function of time during over-currents. The calculated temperature fits well with the measured temperature.

  • 054009

    , , , , , , , , and

    Controlled overpressure (CT-OP) processing eliminates pores and heals cracks, which densifies the Bi2223 filaments and increases the critical current of Ag-sheathed Bi2223 wire. High current capacity wires with critical current values around 210 A at 77 K and self-field have been achieved. The enhancement of the current capacity seems to be due to reducing the weak links between Bi2223 grains and improving the flux pinning. In order to understand the mechanisms for transport critical current in Bi2223 wires, the dependence of the critical current on magnetic field and temperature has been investigated. The critical current is measured as a function of the perpendicular and parallel magnetic fields, up to 12 T, at temperatures ranging from 4.2 to 90 K. These results indicate that higher critical current is associated with highly textured and well connected Bi2223 grains. To further improve a critical current of Bi2223 wires, it is necessary to decrease the misalignment angle and reduce the fraction of Bi2212 and secondary phases.

  • 054010

    , , , , , , and

    In order to clarify the mechanical properties and their influence on the critical current of DI-BSCCO tapes with and without lamination, mechanical tests and critical current measurements were performed, and the corresponding residual strain exerted on the BSCCO component was measured by a neutron diffraction technique. Also the residual strain analysis was calculated using the rule of mixtures. The measured modulus of elasticity, the second slope, and the stress corresponding to the force free strain were self-consistently explained on the basis of this analytical model. The calculated residual strain in the BSCCO component was found to be nearly identical with that determined by neutron diffraction for all DI-BSCCO tapes except for the case of the low strength insert tape. The difference between the strain corresponding to 95% Ic retention and the force free strain was explained by the fracture strain of BSCCO filaments. An approximate expression to evaluate the residual strain in the BSCCO filaments is also presented along with a procedure for estimating the initial temperature T0 at which the residual strain starts to accumulate during cooling after the fabrication heat treatment.

  • 054011

    We present the latest results of the novel model for transverse electromagnetic load optimization (TEMLOP) especially developed for the ITER type of cable-in-conduit conductors (CICCs). The Nb3Sn CICCs for the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) showed a substantial degradation in their performance correlated with increasing electromagnetic load. Not only do the differences in the thermal contraction of the composite materials affect the critical current (Ic) and temperature margin, but electromagnetic forces cause a significant transverse strand contact and bending strain in the Nb3Sn layers, resulting in localized filament cracking and permanent degradation.

    The most essential feature of the a priori TEMLOP predictions presented in May 2006 is that the severe degradation in CICCs can be improved greatly and straightforwardly by increasing the pitch length in subsequent cabling stages and by reducing the void fraction. These corrective measures give more support to the strands, sufficiently reduce the strain, and therefore avoid filament damage at the strand crossover points in the cables. It was the first time that an increase of the cable twist pitches has been proposed and no experimental evidence was available at that time. A full-size European prototype TF conductor sample (TFPRO-2), manufactured in autumn 2006, was adapted according to this new insight and tested in April 2007 in SULTAN for experimental validation of the predictions. The results were outstanding: for the first time an Nb3Sn CICC conductor achieved the performance that can be expected based on the single-strand properties, with high n value and no sign of degradation.

    As input, besides the cable properties, the model directly uses the measured data from single strands under uni-axial stress and strain, periodic bending and contact loads. The recent test results of the ITER OST strands used for the manufacture of the TFPRO-2 obtained with the TARSIS set-up are presented. With these most recent strand results, the model substantiates that not only strand bending is causing degradation but, depending on the strand and cable layout, the strand contact stress can also play a critical role. TEMLOP demonstrates that the twist pitch scheme and void fraction, of the proposed ITER reference TF conductor layout with a first-stage triplet twist pitch of 45 mm, turns out to be practically a worst-case scenario. It is also shown that shorter pitches can lead to an improvement but this requires more Nb3Sn material per metre composite conductor. However, it has been experimentally proven now that the proposed changes recover the ITER TF conductor operational margin up to the expected strand performance. The ITER TF conductor specification is being adapted now and it becomes possible to gain significant savings on the strand design, as degradation no longer needs to be compensated for.

  • 054012

    , , , , , and

    A superconducting multilayer coil using CuNb/Nb3Sn wire was fabricated by the pre-bent react-and-wind (R&W) method. The pre-bent R&W method is a combination of the pre-bending treatment and the conventional R&W process. A 0.8% pre-bending strain was applied by ten fixed pulleys. The coil was tested in magnetic fields of 14, 12, 11 and 10 T at 4.2 K. The coil quench current achieved 100% load ratio of the short sample critical current in the 14 T back-up field. The quench current of the outer section coil achieved 100% of the short sample critical current in the 12 T back-up field. The coil quench currents in various magnetic fields are discussed from a hoop stress and mechanical disturbance point of view.

  • 054013

    Qualification of the ITER conductor is absolutely necessary. Testing large scale conductors is expensive and time-consuming. To test 3–4 m long straight samples in a bore of a split solenoid is a relatively economical way in comparison with the fabrication of a coil to be tested in a bore of a background field solenoid. However, testing short samples may give ambiguous results due to different constraints in current redistribution in the cable or other end effects which are not present in the large magnet. This paper discusses the processes taking place in the ITER conductor, conditions when conductor performance could be distorted and possible signal processing to deduce the behaviour of ITER conductors in ITER magnets from the test data.

  • 054014

    , , , , and

    The effect of heavy ion irradiation on ISD (inclined substrate deposition)-processed DyBCO coated conductors was investigated to understand the strong flux pinning property of columnar defects. It was found the critical current density increased at high fields parallel to the defects nucleated by the irradiation. The obtained results were analyzed using the flux creep–flow model, and the most probable value of the virtual critical current density in the ideal creep-free case was shown to be increased due to the introduction of columnar defects. This result was compared with the statistical summation theory of flux pinning of columnar defects and it was found that the theoretical results explain the experimental results well. The theoretical result predicts that the introduction of columnar defects with larger radius of higher density is desirable for further enhancement of the flux pinning strength.

  • 054015

    , , , , and

    The critical current density in industrial Nb3Sn and MgB2 wires is currently optimized by introducing various kinds of additives, either Ta and/or Ti for Nb3Sn wires or SiC or C for MgB2 wires. In the following, several problems linked to the presence of additives in the two classes of compounds are discussed.

    A reinvestigation of the site occupancy of Ta and Ti additives in Nb3Sn wires shows that the Ta atoms occupy the 6c chain sites, while the Ti atoms are located on the cubic 2a sites. It follows that in perfectly ordered A15 compounds A1−βBβ, the relation ρo versus β exhibits a ‘universal’ behavior: the effect of the chemical nature of the constituents on ρo is negligible. The slopes of ρ0 versus the Ti, Ga and Ni contents in the A15 layer coincide and are much steeper than for the Ta additive, corresponding to the three times higher number of 6c sites with respect to 2a A15 lattice sites.

    The presence of two grain morphologies, e.g. equiaxial and columnar, is observed in Nb3Sn wires produced by the bronze route only. The nonlinearity of the Kramer plot in multifilamentary Nb3Sn bronze route wires is explained by the presence of these two different grain types, which have distinctly different Sn contents and sizes. For these wires, the total pinning force can be represented as the superposition of two contributions with different scaling fields.

    Simultaneous addition of different additives on ‘in situ’ Fe/MgB2 wires is presented as an attempt to combine different possible mechanisms influencing Jc. The substitution of boron by carbon is known to enhance the value of ρo and thus of the critical field. In addition, the pinning behavior is expected to be improved by grain boundary effects or nanosize precipitations, caused by the presence of appropriate additives during the MgB2 phase formation. Since the two mechanisms are independent, their effect on Jc is expected to be cumulative. In the present paper, the results on the additive combination B4C+LaB6 in monofilamentary Fe sheathed MgB2 wires are reported. The data are compared with the additives B4C+SiC and show that simultaneous additives could be promising in view of applications at 20 K.