Theoretical Aspects of Light-Activated Microelectrodes in Redox Electrolytes

, and

Published 16 November 2009 • © 2009 ECS - The Electrochemical Society
, , Citation Huanfeng Zhu et al 2010 Electrochem. Solid-State Lett. 13 P1DOI 10.1149/1.3257616

1944-8775/13/2/P1

Abstract

The behavior of semiconductor-based, light-activated microelectrodes in redox electrolytes has been examined theoretically using commercial software to self-consistently solve the transport equations for solid-state and solution-phase species and the electrostatic potential within the semiconductor phase, subject to the appropriate boundary conditions under steady state. The light-limited currents for such spatially localized microelectrodes, observed for a high voltage bias, Equation or symbol description not availableφbias, under normal irradiation and a strict axisymmetric geometry, were proportional to the photon flux intensity. The results of these simulations afforded strong evidence that under high Equation or symbol description not availableφbias, holes generated by the light on an n-type semiconductor escape beyond the edge of the illuminated disk, leading to a net increase in the predicted current and thus in the effective area of the light-activated microelectrode.

Export citation and abstractBibTeXRIS

Miller and Rosamilia1 described the use of a focused laser impinging at normal incidence on the surface of a semiconductor electrode immersed in an electrolyte containing a redox species to generate spatially localized currents with several possible applications.2 The implementation of this novel concept employing n-InP and n-GaAs disks in solutions of ferrocene (Fc) in well-supported acetonitrile electrolytes at high positive potentials, Equation or symbol description not availableφbias, yielded a behavior closely resembling that of the conventional metallic microelectrodes.2, 3 This article seeks to theoretically examine certain aspects of such light-activated microelectrodes. A particular concern is to establish, under steady-state conditions and large Equation or symbol description not availableφbias, the influence of hole transport within the semiconductor beyond the illuminated area on the measured current, explicitly accounting for interfacial redox processes and mass transport of redox species in the solution phase.4

Theoretical Aspects

The system to be analyzed in this work involves an n-type InP semiconductor disk immersed in a Fc solution in a well-supported (1 M tetrabutylammonium tetrafluoroborate) acetonitrile electrolyte under conditions similar to those reported by Miller and Rosamilia.1 More specifically, we seek steady-state solutions for the transport equations for electrons (n) and holes (p), including both generation and recombination of n–p pairs,5, 6 self-consistently coupled to Poisson’s equation for the electrostatic potential within the semiconductor, φ, and to the transport equations for the donor [red (reduction)] and the acceptor [ox (oxidation)] species in a quiescent solution phase subject to the appropriate boundary conditions. The latter includes second-order kinetics7, 8 to account for the interfacial reactions between p (in the valence band) and red and between n (in the conduction band) and ox, which, for the parameters selected for this study, may be regarded as the dominant contributions to the measured current. A similar problem involving the partial illumination of a semiconductor without taking into account the mass transport from species in the solution phase was reported earlier by Mannheim and co-workers9 within the context of photocorrosion.

For these preliminary calculations, the Gaussian character of the laser intensity normal to the direction of propagation was ignored. Instead, the beam was regarded as a perfectly homogeneous cylinder of a radius, Equation or symbol description not availablerillum=50μm, and thus smaller than that of the semiconductor disk of a radius, Equation or symbol description not availablerD=0.7mm, impinging at normal incidence on the center of the n-InP disk so as to achieve strict axisymmetric conditions. The photon flux intensity of this beam is denoted as Φ. Schematic diagrams of the system in both three-dimensional (3D) (left) and cross-sectional views (right) are given in Fig. 1, where the magnitude of the illuminated area has been greatly enlarged (compared to the size of the semiconductor) for clarity. The overall approach implemented in this study follows rather closely that available in the TOSCA program,10 except that in the present case, the semiconductor was only partially illuminated and mass transport of species within the electrolyte was explicitly accounted for. Not considered in this brief study, however, were processes associated with the possible presence of surface traps, as well as the dependence of carrier mobility on the local electric field within the semiconductor.

Figure 1. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 1. Schematic diagram on a light-activated microelectrode in both 3D (left) and cross-sectional views (right). The thin cylinder represents a homogeneous beam of light traveling through the transparent electrolyte phase (light cylinder above) impinging at normal incidence on the center of the semiconductor (dark cylinder below). The illuminated area has been greatly enlarged (compared to the size of the semiconductor) for clarity.

The governing differential equations within the semiconductor and electrolyte phases, including the boundary conditions, are given in Table I. For these simulations, the values of the relevant physical constants were obtained from either the literature10, 11 or prescribed by the characteristics of the semiconductor. Specifically, for n-InP, the direct recombination coefficient Equation or symbol description not availableCdir=6×10−17m3s−1, the absorption coefficient at Equation or symbol description not availableλ=633nm, Equation or symbol description not availableα1=5.4×106m−1, electron and hole mobilities Equation or symbol description not availableμn=3.6×10−1m2(Vs)−1 and Equation or symbol description not availableμp=1.5×10−2m2(Vs)−1, which can be used to determine the corresponding electron and hole diffusivities from the Einstein relation, the bulk electron and hole concentrations Equation or symbol description not availablen=1020m−3 and Equation or symbol description not availablep=2.25×106m−3, respectively, an intrinsic concentration of carriers Equation or symbol description not availableni=1.5×1013m−3, and a value for the donor density, Equation or symbol description not availableND=1×1020m−3. As in Ref. 1, the bulk concentrations of Fc and Equation or symbol description not availableFc+, Equation or symbol description not availableCred∞ and Equation or symbol description not availableCox∞, were set at 0.1 and 0 M, respectively. The diffusion coefficients of Fc and Equation or symbol description not availableFc+ were assumed to be equal, i.e., Equation or symbol description not availableD=1.2×10−9m2/s. Other parameters, such as the magnitudes of the second-order, potential independent rate constants7 for reactions between n and ox Equation or symbol description not available(ketn) and between p and red Equation or symbol description not available(ketp), were adjusted to obtain values for the currents in line with those in the literature1, 10 (see the caption of Fig. 3). All calculations were performed within the COMSOL platform by meshing the domains with Lagrange triangular quadratic elements. As a means of validation, the global and local mesh sizes were increased until further refinements yielded no appreciable changes in the results (see the Appendix1 for details). The actual reports generated by COMSOL for the most important results presented in this work are available upon request.

Table I. Governing differential equations and boundary conditions associated with the theoretical analysis of light-activated microelectrodes.

SemiconductorElectrolyte solutionEquation
Governing differential equations
Equation or symbol description not available−ε∇2φ=e(Cp−Cn+ND−NA)  I.1
Equation or symbol description not available∇⋅Dn{∇Cn−ekTCn∇φ}=Cdir(CnCp−ni2)−Φαe−αz Equation or symbol description not available∇2Cox=0 I.2
Equation or symbol description not available∇⋅Dp{∇Cp+ekTCp∇φ}=Cdir(CnCp−ni2)−Φαe−αz Equation or symbol description not available∇2Cred=0 I.3
   
Boundary conditions 
Equation or symbol description not availableφ=φf,z=0φ=φb,z=−zmax0<r<rD  I.4
Equation or symbol description not available|∂φ(r,z)∂z|r=0=|∂φ(r,z)∂z|r=rD=0,0<z<−zmax  I.5
Equation or symbol description not availableDn|∂Cn(r,z)∂z|z=0=−ketnCOx(r,0)Cn(r,0)Dp|∂Cp(r,z)∂z|z=0=−ketpCred(r,0)Cp(r,0)0<r<rD Equation or symbol description not availableDo|∂Co(r,z)∂z|z=0=−DR|∂Cred(r,z)∂z|z=0=ketnCox(r,0)Cn(r,0)−ketpCred(r,0)Cp(r,0)0<r<rD I.6
Equation or symbol description not availableDn|∂Cn(r,z)∂z|r=0=Dp|∂Cp(r,z)∂z|r=0=0Dn|∂Cn(r,z)∂z|r=rD=Dp|∂Cp(r,z)∂z|r=rD=00<z<−zmax Equation or symbol description not availableDox|∂Cox(r,z)∂z|r=0=Dred|∂Cred(r,z)∂z|r=0=0 Equation or symbol description not availableDox|∂Cox(r,z)∂z|r=rD=Dred|∂Cred(r,z)∂z|r=rD=0 Equation or symbol description not available0<z<zmax I.7
Equation or symbol description not availableCn=ND2+(ND2)2+ni2Cp=−ND2+(ND2)2+ni2z=−zmax,0<r<rD Equation or symbol description not availableCox∞=0Cred=Cred∞z=zmax,0<r<rD I.8
Figure 3. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 3. (A) Simulated polarization curve for an n-InP electrode in 0.1 M Fc in acetonitrile as a function of the value of the second-order rate constant for the reduction, Equation or symbol description not availableketn=10−29 (curve a), Equation or symbol description not available10−28 (large symbols), and Equation or symbol description not available10−27m4s−1 (curve b), assuming a constant second-order rate constant for oxidation, Equation or symbol description not availableketp, of Equation or symbol description not available10−25m4s−1 under illumination with a photon flux intensity of Equation or symbol description not availableΦ=1.17×1021m−2s−1. The radius of the illuminated disk is Equation or symbol description not availablerillum=50μm. (B) Same as (A) as a function of the values of Equation or symbol description not availableketp=10−24 (curve a), Equation or symbol description not available10−25 (large symbols), and Equation or symbol description not available10−26m4s−1 (curve b), assuming Equation or symbol description not availableketn=10−28m4s−1.

Results and Discussion

Shown in Fig. 2A is a polarization curve, i.e., current vs voltage bias, Equation or symbol description not availableφbias=φb–φf, where Equation or symbol description not availableφf and Equation or symbol description not availableφb represent the potential of the surface of the direct bandgap semiconductor (n-InP) in contact with the electrolyte and that of the ohmically contacted back face, respectively, under illumination (Equation or symbol description not availableΦ=1.17×1021m−2s−1, Equation or symbol description not availableλ=633nm, see Fig. 1) by a homogeneous beam of radius Equation or symbol description not availabler=rillum. As indicated, the current is very small for small Equation or symbol description not availableφbias and becomes larger as Equation or symbol description not availableφbias is increased, reaching a sufficiently high bias, a limiting value independent of Equation or symbol description not availableφbias.

Figure 2. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 2. (A) Simulated polarization curve for an n-InP electrode in 0.1 M Fc in acetonitrile in the dark (open circles) and under illumination with a photon flux intensity of Equation or symbol description not availableΦ=1.17×1021m−2s−1 (solid circles). The radius of the illuminated disk is Equation or symbol description not availablerillum=50μm (see Fig. 1 and text for details). (B) Plot of the total current as a function of the light intensity for Equation or symbol description not availableφbias=+1.0V. The solid line represents the best linear fit to the data (slope: 1.257, standard error Equation or symbol description not available(SE)=7.14×10−4, and intercept: Equation or symbol description not available2.06×10−3, Equation or symbol description not availableSE=2.303×10−4, Equation or symbol description not availableR=1), whereas the dotted line parallel to the abscissa corresponds to the diffusion-limited current for Fc oxidation on a metallic microelectrode with a radius of Equation or symbol description not availabler=rillum, i.e., Equation or symbol description not available2.32μA.

In an analogy with the behavior of a uniformly illuminated semiconductor electrode and confirmed in our laboratory for spatially localized, light-activated n-InP microelectrodes for Fc solutions in acetonitrile electrolytes, the predicted current in this limiting region was proportional to Φ, the photon flux intensity (see Fig. 2B, for Equation or symbol description not availableφbias=+1.0V). Also shown in this figure (see dotted line) is the value of the diffusion-limited current, Equation or symbol description not availableilim, for Fc oxidation on a metallic microelectrode of a radius, Equation or symbol description not availabler=rillum, for which Equation or symbol description not availableilim=2.32μA. Thus, it follows from this plot that for Equation or symbol description not availableΦ1.85×1021m−2s−1, the light-activated electrode yields a current in excess of Equation or symbol description not availableilim for a metallic microelectrode of the same radius. This provides strong evidence that a fraction of the measured current originates from areas of the electrode that are not being illuminated. Even for the highest Φ shown in this figure, i.e., Equation or symbol description not available5.925×1021m−2s−1, the calculated surface concentration of red at the center of the disk, although small (3.3 mM), is not zero. This means that the limiting current from the viewpoint of the diffusion of the solution-phase reactant has not yet been achieved. The data shown in Fig. 3 illustrate the effects of the magnitudes of the second-order rate constants for the oxidation Equation or symbol description not available(ketp) and reduction Equation or symbol description not available(ketn) under otherwise identical conditions as those employed for the results shown in Fig. 2A (which are also given in large symbols in Fig. 3A and 3B). Curves a and b in Fig. 3A were obtained for values of Equation or symbol description not availableketn=10−29 (curve a) and Equation or symbol description not available10−27m4s−1 (curve b) assuming Equation or symbol description not availableketp=10−25m4s−1, whereas those in Fig. 3B correspond to Equation or symbol description not availableketp values of Equation or symbol description not available10−24 (curve a) and Equation or symbol description not available10−26m4s−1 (curve b) for Equation or symbol description not availableketn=10−28m4s−1. As may have been expected, changes in these parameters elicit variations in the shape of the polarization curves for the small bias without affecting the values of the limiting current.

Color graded [panel (A)] and line contour plots [panel (B)] of the concentration of p and red, Equation or symbol description not availableCp(r,z) and Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,z) within the semiconductor and solution phases, respectively, determined for Equation or symbol description not availableφbias=+1.0V, well within the light-limited current range, and Equation or symbol description not availableΦ=1.17×1021m−2s−1, are given in Fig. 4. Panels Equation or symbol description not available(A′) and Equation or symbol description not available(B′) in this figure are expanded views of panels (A) and (B), which highlight the features of dimensions comparable to the illuminated region, where the vertical line has been drawn at Equation or symbol description not availabler=rillum. The corresponding plots of Equation or symbol description not availableCox(r,z) can be simply obtained by subtracting the bulk concentration of Equation or symbol description not availableCred and Equation or symbol description not availableCred∞ from the values of Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,z) shown in the upper subpanels in panels (A) and Equation or symbol description not available(A′). As evidenced above, as the interface is reached from the bulk of the semiconductor, Equation or symbol description not availableCp(r,z) increases, and from the bulk of the solution, Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,z) decreases. The concentration of holes at the interface extends well beyond the edge of the illuminated area, i.e., Equation or symbol description not availablerrillum [see the dotted line in panels Equation or symbol description not available(A′) and Equation or symbol description not available(B′), Fig. 4].

Figure 4. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 4. (A) Color graded and (B) line contour plots of Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,z) (in Equation or symbol description not availablemolm−3, upper subpanels) and Equation or symbol description not availableCp(r,z) (in Equation or symbol description not availablemolm−3, lower subpanels) for Equation or symbol description not availableφbias=+1.0V and Equation or symbol description not availableΦ=1.17×1021m−2s−1. Equation or symbol description not available(A′) and Equation or symbol description not available(B′) are expanded views of Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,z) and Equation or symbol description not availableCp(r,z) based on the lower subpanels in (A) and (B), respectively. The dotted vertical lines represent the edge of the illuminated area.

The local current flowing across the semiconductor/solution interface can be related to the concentrations of n, p, Equation or symbol description not availableCred, and Equation or symbol description not availableCox at the interface through the quantity Equation or symbol description not availableM(r)=ketnCox(r,0)Cn(r,0)−ketpCred(r,0)Cp(r,0), where the first and second terms account for the reduction and oxidation currents at the interface or to the flux of either one of the two redox species in the solution. Shown in Fig. 5 in thin lines (lower abscissa) are plots of Equation or symbol description not availableCp(r,0) (in Equation or symbol description not availableμmolL−1, black curve, left ordinate) and Equation or symbol description not availableCn(r,0) (in nmol Equation or symbol description not availableL−1, gray curve, right ordinate) and of Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,0) (upper curve) and Equation or symbol description not availableCox(r,0) (lower curve, panel B) for n-InP. The thick lines in panel (A) represent the same data in an amplified Equation or symbol description not availablex axis (upper abscissa) for clarity, where the dotted vertical line at Equation or symbol description not availablerillum represents the edge of the illuminated region. In fact, based on the values of the rate constants selected for this preliminary study, the contribution to the total current due to the reduction reaction is indeed negligible. A calculation of the current based on Equation or symbol description not availableM(r) yielded the same values as those evaluated from the flux of red at the interface, Equation or symbol description not availableJred(r,z)∣z=0=−Dred[∂Cred(r,z)/∂r]∣z=0, along the radial direction, given in thin black lines in Fig. 6A (lower abscissa). Also given in this panel in thick lines are the same data over a smaller range in an expanded scale (see upper abscissa). As clearly evidenced from these results, Equation or symbol description not availableJred(r,z)∣z=0 only decays to the negligible values at distances beyond the light illuminated edge, indicating that the contribution to the total current due to the nonilluminated area is indeed significant. This aspect is best illustrated by a plot of the fractional current as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabler, Equation or symbol description not availableγ(r), in Fig. 6B, defined as

Equation (1)γ(r)=∫0rJ(r′,z)∣z=02πr′dr′∫0rDJ(r′,z)∣z=02πr′dr′

which represents the ratio of the current of a disk with radius Equation or symbol description not availabler normalized by the current over the entire n-InP disk, i.e., Equation or symbol description not availabler=rD (thin black line, upper abscissa). The same data in an expanded scale (lower abscissa) are given by the thick black line in the same panel in this figure. On this basis and for the parameters selected for this simulation, the fraction of the current flowing through the illuminated area, Equation or symbol description not availableγL, i.e., Equation or symbol description not availablerillum=0.05mm, amounts to 42%, i.e., less than half the total current. It may be surmised from these considerations that for a semiconductor displaying a smaller absorption coefficient, the light would penetrate deeper into the material generating n-p pairs farther away from the surface, thus allowing for the holes to reach distances longer than those found for n-InP. This was the case for n-Si (see gray curves in Fig. 6A and 6B), an indirect band semiconductor, for which the absorption coefficient at Equation or symbol description not availableλ=633nm is Equation or symbol description not availableα2=2.9×105m−1, Equation or symbol description not availableμn=1.5×10−1m2(Vs)−1, Equation or symbol description not availableμp=4.5×10−2m2(Vs)−1, Equation or symbol description not availablen=1020m−3, and Equation or symbol description not availablep=1.96×1012m−3, and the lifetimes of electrons and holes Equation or symbol description not availableτn and Equation or symbol description not availableτp are equal to Equation or symbol description not available10−3s. For n-Si, the recombination rate was assumed to be given by the Shockley–Read–Hall (SRH) equation,12, 13 Equation or symbol description not availableRSRH=(CnCp−ni2)/[τp(Cn+ni)+τn(Cp+ni)] by regarding the trap level to be located in the middle of the bandgap, meaning that the concentrations of the electrons and holes in the trap level equal Equation or symbol description not availableni. As shown in Fig. 6B, Equation or symbol description not availableγL for n-Si is only 27%.

Figure 5. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 5. A. Plots of Equation or symbol description not availableCp(r,0) (left ordinate, thin black curve) and Equation or symbol description not availableCn(r,0) (right ordinate, thin gray curve) as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabler along the semiconductor–solution interface for otherwise the same system described in Fig. 4. Note the difference between the scales for the two carriers. The thick curves represent the same data in an expanded Equation or symbol description not availabler scale (see upper abscissa). (B) Plots of Equation or symbol description not availableCred(r,0) (gray, upper trace) and Equation or symbol description not availableCox(r,0) (black, lower trace) as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabler along the interface. The dotted vertical line at Equation or symbol description not availablerillum (see upper abscissa, left panel) represents the edge of the illuminated region.

Figure 6. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 6. (A) Plot of the normal flux of Equation or symbol description not availableCred across the Equation or symbol description not availablesolution|semiconductor interface, Equation or symbol description not availableJred(r,z)∣z=0, as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabler for n-InP (thin black line) and n-Si (thin gray line) for otherwise the same system described in Fig. 4. The same data in an expanded Equation or symbol description not availablex-scale (upper abscissa) are shown by the corresponding thick lines. (B) Plots of the radial dependence of the fractional current, γ, for n-InP (thin black line) and n-Si (thin gray lines, see upper abscissa). The same data in an expanded Equation or symbol description not availablex-scale are shown by the corresponding thick lines in this figure (lower abscissa).

List of Symbols

Equation or symbol description not availableCdir direct recombination coefficient
Equation or symbol description not availableCox∞ bulk concentration of ox
Equation or symbol description not availableCred∞ bulk concentration of red
Equation or symbol description not availableDn electron diffusivity
Equation or symbol description not availableDox diffusion coefficient of ox
Equation or symbol description not availableDp hole diffusivity
Equation or symbol description not availableDred diffusion coefficient of red
Equation or symbol description not availableketn second-order rate constant for reduction
Equation or symbol description not availableketp second-order rate constant for oxidation
nbulk electron concentration
Equation or symbol description not availableni intrinsic concentration of carriers
Equation or symbol description not availableNA acceptor dopant density
Equation or symbol description not availableND donor dopant density
pbulk hole concentration

Greek

αabsorption coefficient
Equation or symbol description not availableμn electron mobility
Equation or symbol description not availableμp hole mobility
Equation or symbol description not availableτn lifetime of electrons
Equation or symbol description not availableτp lifetime of holes
Φphoton flux intensity

Acknowledgments

Support for this work was provided by a grant from the NSF. Fruitful discussions with Professor Stanley Bruckenstein are deeply appreciated.

Case Western Reserve University assisted in meeting the publication costs of this article.

:

Appendix

A schematic diagram of the domains defined in the simulations is shown in the left panel, Fig. A-1, where the upper (gray) and lower (white) regions represent, respectively, the solution and semiconductor phases. The global predefined mesh is finer (see right panel). For boundary 4 (the illuminated region at the interface, i.e., Equation or symbol description not availablerillum=50μm), the maximum element size was Equation or symbol description not availableS=10−7 and the element growth rate Equation or symbol description not availableG=1.01; for boundary 6 (nonilluminated interfacial region, Equation or symbol description not available50μm<r<700μm), the maximum Equation or symbol description not availableS=10−6 and Equation or symbol description not availableG=1.01. There are a total of 70,792 elements in the space. To assess the validity of the results, the mesh size was increased until the differences in the calculated results were very small. An example involving the total current is given in Table II.

Figure 7. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 7. Definition of the boundaries, domains (left), and mesh (right) as implemented in COMSOL.

Table II. Integral of the flux along boundaries 4 Equation or symbol description not available(I4) and 6 Equation or symbol description not available(I6) in Equation or symbol description not availableμA for two different global mesh values Equation or symbol description not availableMg for a fixed mesh value for boundary 6 Equation or symbol description not available(M6) using finer mesh values for boundary 4 Equation or symbol description not available(M4), total current Equation or symbol description not available(I4+I6), and difference between the results of the mesh size for Equation or symbol description not availableφbias=+1.0V, Equation or symbol description not availableketp=10−25m4s−1, Equation or symbol description not availableketn=10−28m4s−1, Equation or symbol description not availableCred∞=0.1M, Equation or symbol description not availableCox∞=0, and photon flux intensity Equation or symbol description not availableΦ=1.17×1021m−2s−1. The data in the middle row specify the conditions employed in this article.

  Equation or symbol description not availableI4 Equation or symbol description not available(μA) Equation or symbol description not availableI6 Equation or symbol description not available(μA) Total current Equation or symbol description not availableI4+I6 Equation or symbol description not available(μA) Difference (%)
Equation or symbol description not availableMg=normal 0.625030.838261.463290.37
Equation or symbol description not availableM4=M6=1×10−6
Equation or symbol description not availableMg=normal 0.626380.842411.46879—
Equation or symbol description not availableM4=1×10−7
Equation or symbol description not availableM6=1×10−6
Equation or symbol description not availableMg=finer 0.626380.842221.46860.013
Equation or symbol description not availableM4=1×10−7
Equation or symbol description not availableM6=1×10−6

Please wait… references are loading.
10.1149/1.3257616