Simulation of Particle Incorporation during Electrodeposition Process: Primary and Secondary Current Distributions

and

Published 25 August 2005 • © 2005 ECS - The Electrochemical Society
, , Citation Jaesung Lee and Jan B. Talbot 2005 J. Electrochem. Soc. 152 C706DOI 10.1149/1.2032429

1945-7111/152/10/C706

Abstract

The primary and secondary current distributions for the particle incorporation process during electrocodeposition of a metal film were numerically studied. The growth of an electrodeposited film along the electrode is governed by the local current density that is affected by the presence of a nonconducting particle. It was assumed that the effect of lateral displacement of the fluid between a particle and an electrode is negligible. The level set method was used to track the moving interface as it grows around the particle, and the Laplace equation for the electrical potential was solved by a finite-element method. For a primary current distribution, voids beneath the particle are generated due to the characteristics of the potential distribution, so that the metallic film does not grow along the particle surface. The resistance increment due to the presence of the particle was compared for the cases of stationary and growing metallic films. A small void on top of the particle when incorporated by metal is observed with a secondary current distribution.

Export citation and abstractBibTeXRIS

Metallic matrix composite films are produced by occlusion of particles during electroplating. This process for making composite films has many advantages in industrial applications due to the uniformity of deposition, even for complex shapes, and the avoidance of high-temperature and high-pressure processing.1 Electrocodeposition is a function of many process variables, such as bath composition, hydrodynamics, current density, particle characteristics, and so on. Bath composition encompasses the concentration and type of electrolyte, particle loading in suspension, pH, temperature, and additives. Our experimental research to date has been primarily focused on electrocodeposition under controlled hydrodynamics using a rotating cylinder electrode2 or impinging jet as a function of process variables, such as current density and bath composition, for copper-alumina composites. However, the physical phenomenon of electrocodeposition is not well understood.3

The general mechanism of electrocodeposition is as follows: (i) a particle suspended in bulk solution is transported to the neighborhood of the electrode surface by the forced convection of the electrolyte, (ii) particles come into contact with the electrode surface, (iii) particles either stay adsorbed or detach from the surface, and (iv) particles adsorbed on the surface are captured by the growing metal film. The hydrodynamics in electrocodeposition play a significant role for the transport of ions and particles. Various mechanisms can contribute to the transport of particles to the electrode: Brownian diffusion, hydrodynamic convection, electromigration, and diffusiomigration.

Guglielmi proposed the first model for electrocodeposition which was a two-adsorption step process in 1972.4 The proposed steps were (i) to produce a layer of loosely adsorbed particles and then (ii) a strong adsorption of the particles onto the electrode. Celis et al.5 assumed that a particle will only be incorporated into the metal film when a certain amount of the adsorbed ions on the particle surface is reduced. A statistical approach was taken to give a quantitative description of the incorporation of an inert particle into a growing metallic matrix. Valdes6 developed a model for the deposition of colloidal particles onto a rotating disk electrode (RDE). An equation of continuity was derived for the particle number concentration where the particle flux consists of a diffusion term governed by Brownian motion and a convection term governed by the convective velocity driven by the hydrodynamic convective velocity, electromigration, diffusiomigration, and any specific forces of interaction. The convective diffusion equation was solved with a boundary condition in which an electrochemical reduction of electroactive ions adsorbed on the particle provided the essential surface binding interaction that was responsible for particle deposition. The model predicted that the rate of particle incorporation increased with increasing current density, reached a maximum value, and decreased for larger current densities. Fransaer et al. ,7 using an RDE, explained the electrolytic codeposition of non-Brownian particles based on a trajectory analysis coupled to a surface immobilization reaction. They assumed creeping flow motion for the fluid and decomposed the local flow into an axisymmetrical stagnation flow, two linear shear flows, one parabolic shear flow, and a local rotation. Taking a force balance on the sphere, the trajectory equations were derived for a particle near an RDE in terms of forces acting on a particle. Here the external forces were derived by considering long-range forces, dispersion forces, double-layer forces, and concentration and potential fields. As a boundary condition, the behavior of particles in the vicinity of the disk was formulated by two reaction terms for the particle immobilization and the removal rate, respectively. Using this concept, they avoided the usually applied perfect sink condition. To obtain the flux of particles to the disk, the instantaneous probability was introduced in which a particle remains on the electrode in terms of the forces immobilizing the particle and the removal force. However, the trajectory model did not consider the growth behavior of the metal deposit. Adamczyk and co-workers8, 9 examined the kinetics of localized adsorption of colloidal particles at collectors having a flow stagnation point such as a rotating disk, impinging jet, and a sphere or cylinder in uniform flow. The filtration-type model was developed based on two approaches.10 The first one was the Lagrangian method which considered the trajectories of individual particles in the flowing fluid using Newton’s Second Law. Usually this approach is applied for non-Brownian particles. The second was the Eulerian method, which was a statistical approach for Brownian particles. It described the particles collectively in terms of their distribution function. However, there has not been a study to show the entire entrapment process, even with only a primary current distribution. The objective of this study is to simulate the incorporation of a particle by the growing metal film for primary and secondary current distributions in a stationary fluid.

Newman11 and West and Newman12 gave the fundamental principles for developing the primary and secondary current distributions with the Laplace equation. They presented the various techniques such as coordinate or similarity transformations, potential theory, boundary integral technique, and perturbation theory. Dukovic13 reviewed the computation of current distributions in electrodeposition, particularly focused on the electronics industry, giving many references for numerical methods such as the finite-difference method (FDM), the finite-element method (FEM), and the boundary element method (BEM). The current distribution studies were classified into four size scales: workpiece, pattern, feature, and roughness scales. An integral equation approach was utilized to analyze the current density distribution at a disk-shaped microelectrode at steady state,14 where the result was compared with an asymptotic approximation. An electrochemical system governed by diffusion, convection, and migration was studied by Qiu et al.15 using the boundary element method, where examples were shown for parallel plate electrodes with a laminar flow. However, the studies have concentrated on current density distributions on electrodes and in the electrolyte without a particle. To the authors’ knowledge, there is no study related to the moving electrodeposited film occluding a particle.

With primary and secondary current distributions, the electrical potential is governed by the Laplace equation. To study the primary current distribution around an insulating sphere above a plane, the bispherical coordinate is a good choice. The general solution procedure for the Laplace equation using bispherical coordinates for two spheres was studied in detail by Stoy for parallel16 and perpendicular17 orientations in a uniform external field. The potential field around an insulating sphere normal to a conducting plane was obtained by Morrison and Stukel.18 They also considered the axisymmetric viscous flow with an assumption of Stokes flow and derived the correction of the electrophoretic velocity in the presence of a conducting wall.

The tangent sphere coordinate has been used to obtain a solution for the electrical potential around a particle contacted on a plane. Sides and Tobias19 obtained the analytical solution for the potential field around a bubble on a plane electrode, where a bubble can be regarded as an insulating sphere. The potential was composed of two contributions: one was the linear term which satisfied the field in the absence of the bubble, and the other was the disturbance term which was perturbed by the presence of the bubble. The potential was obtained by matching the insulating boundary condition on the bubble surface and then the primary current distribution on the electrode was given by the normal derivative of the potential on the plane. They reported the resistance increment caused by the bubble, and extended the solution to the resistance increment of surface layers of ordered dielectric spheres and the increment given by spheres dispersed in bulk electrolyte.20 Fransaer et al.21, 22 considered the Laplace equation for a conducting or an insulating sphere on either a conducting or an insulating surface, where the complete solutions were expressed in terms of series expansions instead of integral solutions. They showed the resistance increment of ordered and random arrays of particles from a net effect of a single particle and compared the resistance variation on a conducting plane of a conducting particle with that of a nonconducting particle by Sides and Tobias.19 Finally, they also investigated the Laplace equation around a spherical ridge or trough in a plane in toroidal coordinates.23

For multiphase flow simulation, an interface can be considered as a boundary that divides the phases. The immersed boundary method which uses a finite-difference mesh in which the boundary evolves following the equation of motion, has been used to simulate a moving interface.24 Two numerical approaches to deal with the interface are the front-tracking method and the front-capturing method.

The front-tracking method discretizes the moving front into a set of marker points. The positions of the marker points are updated in time. The advantage is that the interface is explicitly tracked. This method can be accurate in a small deformation motion. However, for large and complex motion, it is not an appropriate approach, because there is an instability of the marker points. Marker particles representing the interface can come together or oscillates in local regions, where regridding and smoothing techniques are needed to avoid this instability. When two interfaces also merge together to form a single one, another technique is needed to eliminate parts of the boundary and to connect two boundaries into a new single one. Consequently, the computational cost is high to resolve these problems. The front tracking method was used to study the effects of surfactants on the deformation of drops and bubbles.25

The second approach is based on the front-capturing method. In a level set formulation defined on the entire domain, the boundary is modeled as the zero set of a smooth function. The boundary is then updated by solving a nonlinear equation of the Hamilton-Jacobi type on the whole domain and tracked implicitly. The advantages are that regridding and smoothing techniques are not needed and highly complicated boundaries can be represented easily. Therefore, the moving interface can develop sharp corners or edges in two- and three-dimensional problems.

If the time-dependent moving boundary by the zero level set Equation or symbol description not availableψ(x(t),t)=0 is in general considered,26, 27 the motion of the interface is represented by the chain rule

Equation (1)∂ψ∂t+u∙∇ψ=∂ψ∂t+Fn∣∇ψ∣=0

where Equation or symbol description not availableu=∂x∕∂t is the interface velocity, Equation or symbol description not availableFn=(∂x∕∂t)∙nl is the speed in the normal direction on the interface, and Equation or symbol description not availablenl=∇ψ∕∣∇ψ∣ is a unit normal vector. Here, Equation or symbol description not availableFn∣∇ψ∣ is the Hamiltonian. Since Eq. 1 is a hyperbolic equation, the characteristic direction depending on ψ is considered. Therefore, the main numerical idea of the level set equation is related to the numerical method of the hyperbolic equation and Hamilton-Jacobi equations.

Osher26 and Sethian27 introduced the level set formulation for the moving interface and formulated the evolution equation of an interface as a type of Hamilton-Jacobi equation. The key idea in a level set formulation is to represent the moving boundary as a particular level set implicitly in a way that sharp gradients and corners are easily expressed. The application for fluid interfaces was recently summarized by Sethian and Smereka.28 Adalsteinsson and Sethian29, 30 applied the level set approach to etching, deposition, and lithography processes in two- and three-dimensional simulations, where they used the fast level set method, considering only points close to the interface at every time step.31 Wheeler et al.32 used the level set method to investigate the superconformal electrodeposition for the void-free filling of a high aspect ratio geometry. Their contribution was to set up the surface coverage model for electroplating bath additive accumulation and conservation on a moving metallic interface with the level set method.

In this paper, the particle incorporation process in electrocodeposition is numerically considered with an assumption of no lateral displacement of the fluid between the particle and the electrode. The growth of an electrodeposited film along the electrode is controlled by the local current density affected by the presence of an insulating particle. One of the goals is to investigate the resistance variation in the presence of an inert particle. The electrical potential is obtained by solution of the Laplace equation with boundary conditions for both the primary and secondary current distributions. Then, the current density is computed from the normal potential gradient on the metallic interface. For the secondary current distribution, the surface overpotential is given by the Butler-Volmer equation and is used as a boundary condition on the metallic surface to obtain the potential field.

Formulation of a Particle Incorporation Model

Governing equations and boundary conditions

We consider the particle incorporation process during electrocodeposition for primary and secondary current distributions, where the concentration gradients in the electrolyte are negligible. The conductivity of the electrode is assumed to be infinite compared to that of the solution.33 Then, the metallic interface between an electrode and an electrolyte is an equipotential surface. The metallic interface is initially flat and grows proportional to the normal gradients of electrical potential fields that are affected by the presence of an insulating particle of radius Equation or symbol description not availablea, as illustrated in Fig. 1, in which the physical configuration is defined on Cartesian coordinates, Equation or symbol description not availablex and Equation or symbol description not availabley.

Figure 1. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 1. Physical configuration.

The molar flux of the Equation or symbol description not availableith species in the absence of a concentration gradient is given by

Equation (2)Ji=−viziFci∇Φ,

where Equation or symbol description not availablevi is the mobility, Equation or symbol description not availablezi is the charge number, Equation or symbol description not availableF is Faraday’s constant, Equation or symbol description not availableR is the gas constant, Equation or symbol description not availableT is the absolute temperature, and Φ is the electrical potential.33 We consider only the contribution of the flux due to migration in an electric field. The current density Equation or symbol description not availableI=(Ix,Iy) due to the movement of charged species is given by

Equation (3)I=F∑ziJi=−σ∇ϕ

where Equation or symbol description not availableσ(=F2∑zi2vici) is the electrical conductivity of the solution and ∑ denotes the summation over Equation or symbol description not availablei. Taking the divergence of Eq. 3 gives the Laplace equation for the electrical potential

Equation (4)∇∙I=∇2Φ=0

Periodic boundary conditions are applied on Equation or symbol description not availableΓ3 and Equation or symbol description not availableΓ4, i.e., Equation or symbol description not availableΦ(x=−L)=Φ(x=L), as shown in Fig. 1, and on the top boundary Equation or symbol description not availableΓ2

Equation (5)Iav=−σ∇Φ∙n

where Equation or symbol description not availableIav[≡(1∕2L)∫−LLIndx] is the average current density, Equation or symbol description not availablen is the unit normal vector pointing into an electrolyte solution, Equation or symbol description not availableIn(≡I∙n) is the current density normal to the electrode surface, while on the surface of an uncharged particle Equation or symbol description not availableΓ1

Equation (6)∇Φ∙n=0

The evolution of the metal film on Equation or symbol description not availableΓ5 is governed by the growth rate Equation or symbol description not availableVn that is defined by the local current density normal to the surface

Equation (7)Vn=dhdt*=−MzMρMFI∙n=MσzMρMF∂Φ∂n

where Equation or symbol description not availableh is deposited film thickness, Equation or symbol description not availableM is the molecular weight of the depositing species, and Equation or symbol description not availableρM is the density of the cathodic deposit. Since the current at the cathode is negative, the metal film grows toward the electrolyte solution. For a primary current distribution, the electrical potential on the electrode surface Equation or symbol description not availableΓ5 is assumed to be zero

Equation (8)VE=Φ=0

where Equation or symbol description not availableVE is the potential at the cathode surface. For a secondary current distribution, the total potential Equation or symbol description not availableVE is given by

Equation (9)VE=ηs+Φ

where Equation or symbol description not availableηs is the surface overpotential. The current density normal to the electrode is represented by the Butler-Volmer equation

Equation (10)In=i0(eαaηsF∕RT−e−αcηsF∕RT)

where Equation or symbol description not availablei0 is the exchange current density and Equation or symbol description not availableαa and Equation or symbol description not availableαc are the anodic and cathodic transfer coefficients, respectively. Since Equation or symbol description not availableVE is set to zero and Equation or symbol description not availableIn=−σ∇Φ∙n, the nonlinear boundary condition for the electrical potential Φ is derived as

Equation (11)−σ∂Φ∂n=i0(e−αaΦF∕RT−eαcΦF∕RT)

By nondimensionalization of the variables [all lengths by the particle radius Equation or symbol description not availablea, time by Equation or symbol description not availableτ(=a2zMρMF2∕MRTσ), growth rate by Equation or symbol description not availablea∕τ, current density by Equation or symbol description not availableRTσ∕Fa, and potential by Equation or symbol description not availableRT∕F], two controlling parameters, Equation or symbol description not availableiav and Equation or symbol description not availableJ, are obtained, where Equation or symbol description not availableiav and Equation or symbol description not availableJ are the nondimensionalized average current density and exchange current density, respectively. Therefore, the nondimensionalized boundary condition on Equation or symbol description not availableΓ2 is

Equation (12)∂ϕ∂n=−iav

where ϕ is the dimensionless electrical potential, and on the surface of an uncharged particle Equation or symbol description not availableΓ1

Equation (13)∂ϕ∂n=0

On the electrode surface Equation or symbol description not availableΓ5, for the primary current distribution

Equation (14)ϕ=0

while for the secondary current distribution

Equation (15)∂ϕ∂n=−J(e−αaϕ−eαcϕ)

where the dimensionless exchange current density Equation or symbol description not availableJ=i0Fa∕RTσ. The evolution of the metal film thickness is obtained from Eq. 7, which in dimensionless form is

Equation (16)vn=∂ϕ∂n

where Equation or symbol description not availablevn is the dimensionless growth speed, and equals the speed function Equation or symbol description not availableFn in Eq. 1. The time scale τ will be used for the computation of the level set function ψ.

Motion of an insulating particle

The motion of an uncharged particle with a velocity Equation or symbol description not availablev=(vx,vy) at steady state is given by

Equation (17)−βv+FA+FB=0

where Equation or symbol description not availableβ(=6πμa) is the friction coefficient. The first term on the left-hand side of Eq. 17 is the frictional force, where β is the resistance of a single particle in Stokes flow and decreases to zero in the neighborhood of the wall by Brenner’s correction.34 The Equation or symbol description not availableFA and Equation or symbol description not availableFB terms represent the attractive van der Waals force and other external forces such as the gravity, buoyancy, or convectional motions, respectively. In this study, the force field Equation or symbol description not availableFA is expressed in terms of the attractive van der Waals force between a sphere and a plane solid surface

Equation (18)FA=23AHa3h02(h0+2a)2ey

where Equation or symbol description not availableey is the unit vector in the Equation or symbol description not availabley direction, Equation or symbol description not availableAH is the Hamaker constant, and Equation or symbol description not availableh0 is the minimum distance between the particle and the flat electrode.35

When the particle is far away from the electrode, that is, Equation or symbol description not availableh0a, the effect of the van der Waals force is negligible. Then, in a stationary fluid, the particle moves toward the electrode in the direction of negative Equation or symbol description not availabley with a terminal velocity Equation or symbol description not availablev=FB∕β due to the external forces Equation or symbol description not availableFB. Even if the particle is accelerated because of the van der Waals force as the particle approaches the wall, it is assumed that the accelerated time is short enough that the particle moves with a constant velocity when it contacts the wall. On contacting the electrode, the rigid particle is strongly attached to the electrode due to the van der Waals force. Here, we neglect the lateral displacement of fluid induced by the particle motion toward the electrode.

Computational method

In electrocodeposition, there exist three phases: the particle, the deposited film, and the electrolyte, and interfaces between these phases. Additionally, the interface between the deposited metallic film and the electrolytic solution is a moving boundary by reduction of metallic ions. An efficient numerical method is then needed to track the growing surface. In this section, the level set method is introduced as a computational method to calculate the evolution of a growing metallic interface using Cartesian coordinates Equation or symbol description not available(x,y) shown in Fig. 1.

For instance, Fig. 2 shows the level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ(x,y) defined by Equation or symbol description not availablex2+y2−0.5. Each level set indicates an isocontour line. A zero level set represents a circle of radius 0.5. Two regions are separated at a zero isocontour line: Equation or symbol description not availableψ0 or Equation or symbol description not availableψ<0. When Equation or symbol description not availableFn in Eq. 1 is constant, each level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ(x,y) propagates toward the outward normal direction with the same speed.

Figure 2. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 2. Level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ(x,y)=x2+y2−0.5.

In this study, three level set functions normalized by the particle radius Equation or symbol description not availablea are introduced: Equation or symbol description not availableψ1(x,y) for a particle, Equation or symbol description not availableψ2(x,y) for the electrode interface, and Equation or symbol description not availableψ3(x,y) for a combination of Equation or symbol description not availableψ1(x,y) and Equation or symbol description not availableψ2(x,y)

Equation (19)ψ1(x,y)=[(x−xc)2+(y−yc)2−a]∕a

Equation (20)ψ2(x,y)=(y−yplane)∕a

Equation (21)ψ3(x,y)=max(−ψ1,ψ2)

where Equation or symbol description not available(xc,yc) is the particle center position, Equation or symbol description not availableyplane is the initial position of the electrode, and Equation or symbol description not availablex and Equation or symbol description not availabley are components of the position vector Equation or symbol description not availablex=(x,y). The initial metallic interface is represented by a line of Equation or symbol description not availableψ2=0, and a line of Equation or symbol description not availableψ3=0 represents a moving metallic interface at each time step. As time goes on, the level set function is computed by Eq. 1, and the moving interface is tracked as follows

Equation (22)∂ψ3∂t+∂ϕ∂n∣∇ψ3∣=0

where Equation or symbol description not availableFn is substituted by Equation or symbol description not availablevn defined by Eq. 16 and Equation or symbol description not availablet is normalized by τ. Because the speed Equation or symbol description not availableFn is defined only on the interface and the level set function is defined on the finite-difference mesh of the whole domain, the extension of the speed function Equation or symbol description not availableFn to the entire domain of a finite-difference mesh must be considered. The values of Equation or symbol description not availableFn enclosed by boundaries Γ are easily computed on the computational domain. The problematic regions are inside the particle and beneath the moving metallic surface, because Equation or symbol description not availableFn in the regions are not specified. In this study, the technique called impainting, which is used for restoration of degraded images in image processing, was used to extend Equation or symbol description not availableFn.26 Accordingly, the values of Equation or symbol description not availableFn inside the particle are found by solving the Laplace equation Equation or symbol description not available(∇2Fn=0) with the fixed values near boundary mesh points. For values of Equation or symbol description not availableFn at the finite-difference mesh right beneath the metallic interface, Equation or symbol description not availableFn=γ1+γ2x+γ3y is assumed; the coefficients Equation or symbol description not availableγ1, Equation or symbol description not availableγ2, and Equation or symbol description not availableγ3 are determined by solving the linear equations based on three known points above the metallic interface. The values right beneath the interface are then interpolated using the coefficients, and the same values are used for the finite-difference nodes to the bottom boundary in a vertical direction.

To improve the computational speed, fast level set techniques were introduced.36 The central idea of a fast level set implementation is to let the level set function ψ consider a signed distance function Equation or symbol description not availableds(x) 26

Equation (23)ds(x)=min(∣x−xI∣)

where Equation or symbol description not availablexI is an interface position vector and a condition of Equation or symbol description not available∣∇ds(x)∣=1 is imposed. Note that Equation or symbol description not availableds(x)=0 on the boundary and its gradient is unity. The sign is plus and minus in regions where the level set function values are larger and smaller than zero, respectively. The fast sweeping method37, 38 is a nonlinear upwind difference and uses Gauss-Seidel iterations with alternating sweeping ordering in order to extend the signed distance function. The advantage is a simple numerical implementation. The accuracy is the same as other methods which solve the same system of discretized equations.37 The moving metallic interface is then tracked implicitly by the level set approach, which enables the simulation of the entrapment process around the nonconducting particle.

The PLTMG (Piecewise Linear Triangle Multi Grid Package) was used to solve the Laplace equation for the potential fields.39 This package is a finite-element solver for solving elliptic partial differential equations in a two-dimensional space and provided the continuous piecewise linear triangular finite elements and adaptive local mesh refinement. In this study, the coarse grids are first produced in the whole computational domain, and the fine meshes are created by the adaptive refinement algorithm by the error estimate.

The computation procedure is as follows: (a) finite-element grids are generated subject to boundary positions, (b) the potential ϕ at the finite-element nodes was obtained by PLTMG with corresponding boundary conditions, (c) the potential and the gradient of potential at each node in a finite-difference mesh were interpolated in the computational domain enclosed by boundaries Γ, (d) the normal components of the unit vector Equation or symbol description not availablenl at finite-difference nodes were computed by the level set function, (e) the speed function Equation or symbol description not availableFn encompassed by Γ was obtained by the inner product of the vector and the gradient of potential at each node using previously computed solutions in (c) and (d), (f) the speed function Equation or symbol description not availableFn inside the particle and beneath the electrode surface was impainted by values of Equation or symbol description not availableFn close to Equation or symbol description not availableΓ1 and Equation or symbol description not availableΓ5, (g) the moving interface was tracked implicitly by Eq. 22, (h) the level set function was recalculated by the fast sweeping technique, (i) using the basic property of the distance function, the interface position was interpolated and used for the boundary positions for PLTMG, and (j) the simulation was iterated until the process was completed. In this study, the finite-difference mesh size Equation or symbol description not availableΔx(=Δy) and time step Equation or symbol description not availableΔt were used (0.05 and 0.00625, respectively). The maximum number of refined triangles generated by PLTMG used was up to 1500. The maximum computational time using a Dell Precision 620 (1.0G Memory) computer was Equation or symbol description not available2h. The computational domain is defined on a grid size of Equation or symbol description not availablex∕a by Equation or symbol description not availabley∕a, where Equation or symbol description not available−3<x∕a<3 and Equation or symbol description not available0<y∕a<6, and the initial height of the metallic surface Equation or symbol description not availableh is set to 1.

Primary Current Distribution

The primary current density distribution depends only on the geometry of the system because the influence of overpotential is zero. Due to the infinite conductivity of a metallic electrode, the resistance of the electrolyte (ohmic drop) is comparatively much larger than the kinetic resistance due to the surface overpotential, therefore a primary current distribution is the limiting condition of negligible kinetic resistance. Thus, the potential is constant at the metallic interface. When we consider an insulating particle in contact with a conducting wall, the contact angle between the particle and the electrode causes a change of current density around the contact point; the current density will be infinite when the angle is obtuse and zero when the angle is acute. West and Newman40 investigated the current distribution near an electrode edge using a singular perturbation analysis and showed that the current density at the intersection point approaches extreme values as the primary distribution is approached. A change in current density affects the shape of the evolving surface, which may change the microstructure of the electrodeposited film.

Sides and Tobias19 calculated the resistance increment caused by bubbles attached to an electrode. Fransaer21, 22 investigated the resistance increment of insulating particles on a disk electrode to develop algorithms to determine the position of particles on the electrode. The analytical solution for electrical potential was obtained by a series expansion. In the region without the particle, all current density vectors are parallel to each other. However, the nonconducting particle acts as an obstacle that prevents the current from flowing to the electrode. Additional voltage is needed for the current density around the obstacle and this induces a resistance increment, Equation or symbol description not availableΔV∕∣iav∣, which is the net voltage change divided by the average current density. In the absence of the particle, the potential field with a flat fixed metallic interface is analytically given by Equation or symbol description not availableϕ0(x∕a,y∕a)=−iav(y−yplane)∕a. The case with a growing metallic film will be discussed later. The potential field depends only on the Equation or symbol description not availabley direction normal to the metallic substrate. The voltage difference is obtained by subtracting Equation or symbol description not availableϕ0(x∕a,H∕a) from the computed average potential in the presence of the particle on the top boundary Equation or symbol description not availableΓ2. The resistance increment as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabled, which is the minimum distance between the electrode and the particle and is normalized by the particle radius Equation or symbol description not availablea, is represented in Fig. 3. After one radius distance away from the interface, the voltage increment stays constant. This means that the current flow is not affected by the presence of the electrode. As the particle approaches the electrode, the resistance increment decreases and converges to a nonzero value. When the particle is incorporated completely by the growing metallic film, the resistance increment will be reduced to zero because of no further voltage increment due to the presence of the particle. As Equation or symbol description not availableL∕a increases, the effect of the particle becomes less because the area ratio of the particle in the domain is reduced. The resistance increment changes noticeably as the spacing between particles becomes smaller.41 The results by Sides and Tobias19 for a single bubble on an electrode are also shown in Fig. 3.

Figure 3. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 3. The resistance increment as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabled, the minimum distance from the electrode to the particle, for various Equation or symbol description not availableL∕a values.

The presence of an inert particle significantly affects the current density along a flat electrode as a particle moves in the vicinity of the electrode, which in turn affects the evolution of the growing metallic interface. When a particle is far enough away that there is no variation of potential field in the neighborhood of the electrode, the normalized current densities along the flat interface remain constant. As the distance between the particle and the electrode decreases, the normalized current density at the particle centerline Equation or symbol description not available(x=0) decreases to zero as the particle contacts the electrode. Obviously, current cannot pass through the nonconducting particle and goes around the particle. Figure 4 shows the variation of current density on the electrode with the particle’s vertical position, where the effect of the interparticle spacing is considered. The maximum value of the current density in the case of an attached particle Equation or symbol description not available(d=0) is approximated to be at the two radius distances,19, 41 whereas the maximum value is at the boundary for other cases Equation or symbol description not available(d≠0). Hence, we can expect the metallic deposited film away from the particle radius to grow faster than that near the particle.

Figure 4. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 4. The primary current distribution along the flat electrode as a function of Equation or symbol description not availabled for Equation or symbol description not availableL∕a=3.

Figure 5a shows the evolution with time of a growing metallic film thickness for the particle entrapment process with a primary current distribution, where a flat interface is assumed as the initial condition. The moving speed of the metallic interface varies with the lateral coordinate, which depends on the normal derivative of potential field at the surface. The normalized current density with particle entrapment process is presented in Fig. 5b. The point of the maximum value of the normalized current density shifts from the edge of the boundary to near the particle radius, while within the distance Equation or symbol description not availablex∕a<1, the growing velocity reduces to zero in a way that the interface shape deforms largely around the particle and a void beneath the particle is formed, as illustrated in Fig. 5a.

Figure 5. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 5. The primary current distribution with a growing metallic film (Equation or symbol description not availableiav=−0.1 and Equation or symbol description not availableJ=0.01): (a) temporal evolution of the metallic interface and (b) normalized current density.

The isocontour lines for electrical potential in Fig. 6a are parallel to each other in the regions far away from the particle, while the distribution of the potential near the particle is distorted in order to satisfy the insulating condition. The speed of the metallic interface then slows in the neighborhood of the particle compared with that away from the particle. As time goes on, the normal gradient of the electrical potential near the particle is so negligibly small that the surface appears stationary. However, the metallic surface away from the particle radius moves much faster, as shown in Fig. 6b. This is consistent with the analysis in Fig. 5b. As the surface grows at a distance equal to the particle radius in height, the interval of potential lines becomes smaller, so that the speed of the surface becomes larger, while the metallic interface near the particle does not grow. The metallic surface at Equation or symbol description not availablex∕a≃1 then grows faster and finally touches the particle. Figure 6b shows that voids near the particle are generated by the fast-developed moving metallic film that depends on the characteristics of the potential field. For the primary current distribution, the metallic film does not grow along the nonconducting particle surface.

Figure 6. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 6. Potential distribution with a primary current distribution (Equation or symbol description not availableiav=−0.1 and Equation or symbol description not availableJ=0.01): (a) Equation or symbol description not availablet=1.5 and (b) Equation or symbol description not availablet=7.8.

The level set function Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 corresponding to Fig. 6a and 6b is shown in Fig. 7a and 7b, where the curved thick line represents the zero level set of the metallic interface and the zero level set for a particle is overlapped as a circle. The zero level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 is initially a straight line, however it is deformed by following the speed function Equation or symbol description not availableFn, the potential gradient in the normal direction defined by Eq. 16. Using the fast level set method, the level set function defined over the entire domain is extended by the values near the zero level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ3. The incomplete and complete circular shapes inside the circle and the curved lines on top of the particle in Fig. 6a and 6b result from the extension of the curved shape of the zero level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ3.

Figure 7. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 7. Level set function Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 at (a) Equation or symbol description not availablet=1.5 and (b) Equation or symbol description not availablet=7.8, where the zero level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ1 is overlapped.

Secondary Current Distribution

In general, a more uniformly deposited film can be obtained with a secondary current density distribution.33 The difference from a primary current density distribution for the model is a nonlinear boundary condition at the electrode surface given by the Butler-Volmer equation which introduces a surface overpotential. Because the exchange current density Equation or symbol description not availableJ represents the kinetic speed of the reaction on the electrode, Equation or symbol description not availableJ was used as a parameter in this study to investigate the effect of uniformity and growth of the deposited film.

In 1987, Dukovic and Tobias investigated the voltage increment of bubbles attached to a plane electrode as a function of current density and exchange current density.41 With a flat, fixed electrode, a secondary current density distribution in the presence of a particle was investigated to study the effect of the kinetics of the electrode reaction and to compare to results with a primary current density distribution. Figure 8a shows the normalized current density along the flat electrode for various values of Equation or symbol description not availabled at small dimensionless exchange current density Equation or symbol description not available(J=0.01). When a particle comes into contact with an electrode, Equation or symbol description not availabled=0, the current density even at the contact point is a nonzero value. This makes for a more uniformly deposited film compared with that for a primary current density distribution. However, as Equation or symbol description not availableJ increases to very large values (toward infinity), the pattern is similar to that of the primary current density distribution,41 as illustrated in Fig. 4. The resistance increment as a function of Equation or symbol description not availableJ for a secondary current density distribution is compared to that for a primary current density distribution at the same condition in Fig. 8b. As Equation or symbol description not availableJ increases, the resistance increment decreases and converges to a fixed value of that for a primary current density distribution. However, as the value of Equation or symbol description not availableJ becomes smaller, the kinetic effects of the electrode reaction become important. This is a significant feature as compared with the primary current density distribution. The potential value underneath the particle decreases to compensate for the increased kinetic resistance, which will be discussed further in Fig. 11.

Figure 8. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 8. The secondary current distribution along a flat electrode Equation or symbol description not available(L∕a=3): (a) normalized current density as a function of normalized distance for various Equation or symbol description not availabled and Equation or symbol description not availableJ values and (b) resistance increment as a function of Equation or symbol description not availableJ, where a dashed line is for a primary current distribution.

Figure 11. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 11. Temporal evolution with a secondary current distribution (Equation or symbol description not availableiav=−0.5 and Equation or symbol description not availableJ=0.01). The time step for each contour line is 0.5.

The evolution of the metallic interface with different Equation or symbol description not availableJ is illustrated in Fig. 9 Equation or symbol description not available(iav=−0.1) as the metallic interface is allowed to grow in proportion to current density along the interface. With a small exchange current density Equation or symbol description not available(J=0.01), as shown in Fig. 9a, the height difference along the surface is small as the deposited film grows with time. When a moderate exchange current density Equation or symbol description not available(J=1) is considered, the growth of the metallic film below the particle in Fig. 9b is slower than that farther away from the particle. The corresponding current density along the surface is plotted in Fig. 10a. The current density at Equation or symbol description not availablex∕a<1 decreases as the film grows, while the current density at Equation or symbol description not availablex∕a1 shows an almost constant value before the growing film touches the particle. This figure shows that the small void between the particle and the deposited film can be explained by both a geometrical effect and the potential characteristics. In the case of a large exchange current density Equation or symbol description not available(J=1000), the difference in height with time, as shown in Fig. 9c, increases and a larger void beneath the particle compared to Fig. 9b is generated. The corresponding current density in Fig. 10b is very similar to that plotted in Fig. 5b. In order to show the void, the computation was stopped when the growing metallic film contacts the particle at Equation or symbol description not availablet=6.0 for Equation or symbol description not availableJ=1 and for Equation or symbol description not availableJ=1000. The figures for the evolution of the growing deposited film and the current density distribution show that the primary current density distribution is the limiting case for the secondary current density distribution with a large exchange current density, as expected.

Figure 9. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 9. The temporal evolution of the metallic interface with a secondary current distribution Equation or symbol description not available(iav=−0.1): (a) Equation or symbol description not availableJ=0.01, (b) Equation or symbol description not availableJ=1, and (c) Equation or symbol description not availableJ=1000. The regular time step for each contour line is 1.5.

Figure 10. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 10. The secondary current distribution with a growing metallic film Equation or symbol description not available(iav=−0.1): (a) Equation or symbol description not availableJ=1 and (b) Equation or symbol description not availableJ=1000.

Figure 11 shows the temporal evolution of a growing metallic film for the particle incorporation process with a large current density and a small exchange current density (Equation or symbol description not availableJ=0.01 and Equation or symbol description not availableiav=−0.5). As before, a flat interface is also considered initially. Unlike the primary current distribution in Fig. 5a, a good uniformity is shown, except on top of the particle. In order to explain the nonuniformity, the potential distributions were investigated in Fig. 12. When the particle contacts a growing metallic surface as shown in Fig. 12a, an interesting feature is that there exists distinct potential contour lines beneath the particle. These separated lines are induced by the kinetic resistance on the metallic interface and causes the current density near the particle to have a nonzero value. After the particle contacts the electrode surface, the growing film is uniform, as illustrated in Fig. 12c, where the potential lines are well distributed near the contact point between the particle and the metallic film, and the film’s growth, which is dependent upon potential gradient at the interface, is faster close to the particle. In Fig. 12e, the potential field at the gap between the developing film on both sides of the center line does not change much in the lateral direction; the normal gradient of potential on the metallic interface has nearly vanished. Therefore, the film grows vertically and does not extend into the gap such that a small void is generated on top of the particle. This indicates a possible mechanism for creation of a void even at a small exchange current density with a secondary current distribution. The level set functions Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 corresponding to Fig. 12a, 12c and 12e are shown in Fig. 12b, 12d and 12f, respectively. The potential fields in Fig. 6a and 12a are different, while the level set function Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 in Fig. 12b is similar to Fig. 7a, because the zero level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 at a contact time is similar for both cases. Because the metallic interface grows along the particle surface uniformly, the level set functions inside and outside the particle have a circular shape. The narrowly confined contour lines above the particle are induced by the highly curved zero level set in Fig. 12f.

Figure 12. Refer to the following caption and surrounding text.

Figure 12. Secondary current distribution (Equation or symbol description not availableiav=−0.5 and Equation or symbol description not availableJ=0.01): (a), (c), and (e) potential distributions at Equation or symbol description not availablet=0.6, Equation or symbol description not availablet=2.0, and Equation or symbol description not availablet=4.3 and (b), (d), and (f) level set function Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 corresponding to (a), (b) and (c), respectively, where the zero level set of Equation or symbol description not availableψ1 is overlapped.

Conclusions

The primary and secondary current distributions with a growing metallic interface in the presence of a particle were investigated numerically. The potential field resolved by PLTMG was distorted by the nonconducting particle to satisfy the insulating boundary condition. The particle acted as an obstacle to a growing metallic film. In order to track this developing interface, the level set method was used.

For a primary current distribution, the resistance increment and the local current density distribution along the surface were affected by the presence of an insulating particle, and the influence was maximized when the particle contacted the electrode. The potential characteristics around the particle accelerated the growth speed of a deposited film near the particle radius, caused a large deformation of the metallic interface, and finally, created a void beneath the particle.

The kinetic resistance, which is dependent upon exchange current density, resulted in distinct potential lines underneath the particle with a secondary current distribution. The distinct potential field above the deposited film gave a nonzero current density along the surface and contributed to a more uniformly deposited film. However, a small void on top of the particle was generated even at a small exchange current density. The primary current density distribution was verified as the limiting case for the secondary current density distribution with large exchange current density through the resistance increment, the evolution of the growing metallic film, and the current density distribution along the surface.

This study showed a void generation mechanism with the primary and secondary current distributions induced by the presence of a nonconducting particle. The tertiary current distribution and the effect of a conducting particle in the particle incorporation process will be considered in future work. The lateral migration of the fluid will also be considered which will alter the concentration field, which in turn will cause the current density to change.

List of Symbols

Equation or symbol description not availableAH Hamaker constant, J
Equation or symbol description not availablea particle radius, m
Equation or symbol description not availablec concentration of ions, Equation or symbol description not availablemol∕m3
Equation or symbol description not availabled minimum distance between a particle and an electrode normalized by Equation or symbol description not availablea
Equation or symbol description not availableds signed distance function, m
Equation or symbol description not availableF Faraday’s constant, Equation or symbol description not available96,485C∕equiv
Equation or symbol description not availableFn speed function for a level set method, m/s
Equation or symbol description not availableh deposited film thickness, m
Equation or symbol description not availableh0 minimum distance between a particle and an electrode, m
Equation or symbol description not availableI current density, Equation or symbol description not availableA∕m2
Equation or symbol description not availableIav average current density Equation or symbol description not available(=1∕2L∫−LLIndx), Equation or symbol description not availableA∕m2
Equation or symbol description not availableIn current density normal to the electrode, Equation or symbol description not availableA∕m2
Equation or symbol description not availablei0 exchange current density, Equation or symbol description not availableA∕m2
Equation or symbol description not availablei dimensionless current density
Equation or symbol description not availableiav dimensionless average current density
Equation or symbol description not availableJ dimensionless exchange current density Equation or symbol description not available(=i0Fαca∕RTσ)
Equation or symbol description not availableJ molar flux, Equation or symbol description not availablemol∕m2s
Equation or symbol description not availableL characteristic length scale in the Equation or symbol description not availablex direction, m
Equation or symbol description not availableM molecular weight of the depositing species, kg/mol
Equation or symbol description not availablen unit normal vector pointing out an electrolyte solution
Equation or symbol description not availableR gas constant, J mol/K
Equation or symbol description not availableT absolute temperature, K
Equation or symbol description not availablet dimensionless time normalized by τ
Equation or symbol description not availablet* time, s
Equation or symbol description not availablev velocity vector of a particle Equation or symbol description not available(vx,vy), m/s
Equation or symbol description not availablev mobility of the particle, Equation or symbol description not availablem2mol∕Js
Equation or symbol description not availableVE potential at the cathode surface, V
Equation or symbol description not availableVn growth rate normal to a deposited film, m/s
Equation or symbol description not availablevn dimensionless growing speed normal to a deposited film
Equation or symbol description not availableΔV dimensionless potential difference between the top boundary and the metallic interface
Equation or symbol description not availablex(x,y) position vector in Cartesian coordinate
Equation or symbol description not availablexI interface position vector, m
Equation or symbol description not availablexc Equation or symbol description not availablex component of center position of the particle, m
Equation or symbol description not availableyc Equation or symbol description not availabley component of center position of the particle, m
Equation or symbol description not availableyplane initial position of a metallic interface in the Equation or symbol description not availabley direction, m
Equation or symbol description not availablez charge number
Equation or symbol description not availablezM charge number of the depositing species

Greek

Equation or symbol description not availableαa anodic transfer coefficient
Equation or symbol description not availableαc cathodic transfer coefficient
βfriction coefficient Equation or symbol description not available(=6πμa), kg/s
Equation or symbol description not availableηs surface overpotential, V
Equation or symbol description not availableγ1,γ2,γ3 coefficients of the interpolated function Equation or symbol description not availableFn=γ1+γ2x+γ3y
μviscosity of the electrolyte, Pa s
Φelectrical potential, V
ϕdimensionless electrical potential
ψlevel set function, m
Equation or symbol description not availableψ1 level set function for a particle
Equation or symbol description not availableψ2 level set function for an initial metallic film
Equation or symbol description not availableψ3 level set function for a growing metallic film
Equation or symbol description not availableρM density of the cathodic deposit, Equation or symbol description not availablekg∕m3
σelectrical conductivity of the solution Equation or symbol description not available(=F2∑zi2vici), S/m
τdimensionless time scale Equation or symbol description not available(=a2zMρMF2∕MRTσ)

Acknowledgments

The authors greatly appreciate the discussion with Professor Bank concerning the use of the PLTMG program and Professor Cheng for the level set method in the Department of Mathematics at University of California, San Diego.

The University of California, San Diego assisted in meeting the publication costs of this article.

Please wait… references are loading.
10.1149/1.2032429