Table of contents

The Edoardo Amaldi Conference on Gravitational Waves is the premier forum for the fields of gravitational wave science and gravitational wave detection. Held biannually, the Amaldi meetings are organized under the auspices of the Gravitational Wave International Committee (GWIC), which oversees the scientific program for the meeting.

Amaldi 12 was held at the Hilton Hotel in Pasadena, CA from July 9-14, 2017. This was the first Amaldi conference since LIGO and Virgo announced the detection of gravitational waves from the merger of two black holes into a single black hole. Unlike previous Amaldi Conferences that focused on anticipated gravitational wave science and detector development, this was the first Amaldi conference to examine the science arising from the LIGO-Virgo detections and the successful LISA Pathfinder mission, the precursor to LISA.

During the conference, the full range of gravitational wave science was represented, including plans for the further development of terrestrial and space based detectors, as well as progress in pulsar timing arrays. Emphasis was placed on the connection between gravitational wave science and the fields of observational astrophysics and multi-messenger astronomy, as well as in progress in modeling the waveforms for gravitational waves arising from various astrophysical sources, highlighting the stronger connection between experimental advances, numerical relativity simulations, and astrophysics theory.

Guest editor

Dr. Sydney Meshkov

Caltech, LIGO 100 – 36, Pasadena, CA 91125 (syd@ligo.caltech.edu)

All papers published in this volume of Journal of Physics: Conference Series have been peer reviewed through processes administered by the proceedings Editors. Reviews were conducted by expert referees to the professional and scientific standards expected of a proceedings journal published by IOP Publishing.

The first four LIGO detections have confirmed the existence of massive black holes (BHs), with mass 30–40 M_⊙. Such BHs might originate from massive metal-poor stars (Z < 0:3 Z_⊙) or from gravitational instabilities in the early Universe. The formation channels of merging BHs are still poorly constrained. The measure of mass, spin and redshift distribution of merging BHs will give us fundamental clues to distinguish between different models. In parallel, a better understanding of several astrophysical processes (e.g. common envelope, core-collapse SNe, and dynamical evolution of BHs) is decisive, to shed light on the formation channels of merging BHs.

The development and integration of new detector payloads has been an important part of the Advanced Virgo (AdV) project, the major upgrade of the Virgo interferometric detector of Gravitational Waves, aiming to increase the detector sensitivity by one order of magnitude. During the integration phase of the new AdV payloads with monolithic suspension of mirrors we experienced systematic suspension failures later identified as caused by dust contamination of the vacuum system. In order to not postpone the detector commissioning, making possible to join the LIGO O2 observation run, the Collaboration decided to proceed with the integration of the payloads relying on steel wire suspensions for all the mirrors. In this proceeding the status of the currently integrated payloads is reported, including their angular control characterization and the Q-factor measurements for test mass steel wire suspensions. The payload upgrade for the re-integration of monolithic suspensions after the O2 run is reported in the last section.

Next generation radio telescopes, namely the Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical Telescope (FAST) and the Square Kilometer Array (SKA), will revolutionize the pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) based gravitational wave (GW) searches. We review some of the characteristics of FAST and SKA, and the resulting PTAs, that are pertinent to the detection of gravitational wave signals from individual supermassive black hole binaries.

In order to increase the reach of the astrophysical searches, various sources of instrumental and environmental noise must be identified and ameliorated. Here we discuss efforts to understand the origin of noise manifested as short-duration bursts (glitches) and/or range-impacting features at LIGO Hanford. Several examples found at LIGO Hanford Observatory in O1 and O2 were identified including glitches due to an air compressor, ringing phone, airplanes, and an incorrect servo setting, and a decrease in detector sensitivity due to truck traffic.

With the recent claim that gravitational waves were finally detected and with other efforts around the world for GWs detection, its is reasonable to imagine that the relic gravitational wave background could be detected in some time in the future and with such information gather some hints about the origin of the universe. But, it's also be considered that gravity has self-interaction, with such assumption it's reasonable to expect that these gravitational wave will interact with the relic or nonrelic GW background by scattering, for example. Such interaction should decrease the distance which such propagating waves could be detected The propagation of gravitational waves (GWs) is analyzed in an asymptotically de Sitter space by the perturbation expansion around Minkowski space using a scalar component. Using the case of de Sitter inflationary phase scenario, the perturbation propagates through a FRW background. The GW, using the actual value for the Hubble scale (H_o), has a damping factor with a very small valor for the size of the observational universe; the stochastic relic GW background is given by a dimensionless function of the frequency. In this work we analyze this same damping including the gravitational wave background due to astrophysical sources such background is 3 orders of magnitude bigger in some frequencies and produces a higher damping factor.

We report on the optical, mechanical and structural characterization of the sputtered coating materials of Advanced LIGO, Advanced Virgo and KAGRA gravitational- waves detectors. We present the latest results of our research program aiming at decreasing coating thermal noise through doping, optimization of deposition parameters and post- deposition annealing. Finally, we propose sputtered Si₃N₄ as a candidate material for the mirrors of future detectors.

Gravitational wave (GW) detection with pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) requires accurate noise characterization. The noise of our Galactic-scale GW detector has been systematically evaluated by the Noise Budget and Interstellar Medium Mitigation working groups within the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) collaboration. Intrinsically, individual radio millisecond pulsars (MSPs) used by NANOGrav can have some degree of achromatic red spin noise, as well as white noise due to pulse phase jitter. Along any given line-of-sight, the ionized interstellar medium contributes chromatic noise through dispersion measure (DM) variations, interstellar scintillation, and scattering. These effects contain both red and white components. In the future, with wideband receivers, the effects of frequency-dependent DM will become important. Having anticipated and measured these diverse sources of detector noise, the NANOGrav PTA remains well-poised to detect low-frequency GWs.

Two structured doctoral programmes that we have in Hannover, the IMPRS on Gravitational Wave Astronomy and SFB on relativistic geodesy and gravimetry with quantum sensors geo-Q, have not only become major resources for education in each field but have also started to provide substantial synergy to members of both programmes. Our strong crossdisciplinary approach to create a joint programme has received excellent feedback not only from researchers inside the programme but also from various external committee. Building on experience that we have acquired over the last decade, we propose to set up a common doctoral programme within the international gravitational wave astronomy and physics. We envisage that with a common doctoral programme we will create a strong team of young researchers who will carry on building a strong network of third generation gravitational wave detectors and observatories.

KAGRA is a Japanese large scale, underground, cryogenic gravitational telescope which is under construction in the Kamioka mine. For using cryogenic test masses, the sensitivity of KAGRA is limited mainly by quantum noise. In order to reduce quantum noise, KAGRA employs an output mode-cleaner (OMC) at the output port that filters out junk light but allows the gravitational wave signal to go through. The requirement of the KAGRA OMC is even more challenging than other telescopes in the world since KAGRA plans to tune the signal readout phase so that the signal-to-noise ratio for our primary target source can be maximized. A proper selection of optical parameters and anti-vibration devices is required for the robust operation of the OMC. In this proceeding, we show our final results of modal-model simulations, in which we downselected the cavity length, the round-trip Gouy phase shift, the finesse, and the seismic isolation ratio for the suspended optics.

Photographs of the LIGO Gravitational Wave detector mirrors illuminated by the standing beam were analyzed with an astronomical software tool designed to identify stars within images, which extracted hundreds of thousands of point-like scatterers uniformly distributed across the mirror surface, likely distributed through the depth of the coating layers. The sheer number of the observed scatterers implies a fundamental, thermodynamic origin during deposition or processing. If identified as crystallites, these scatterers would be a possible source of the mirror dissipation and thermal noise, which limit the sensitivity of observatories to Gravitational Waves. In order to learn more about the composition and location of the detected scatterers, a feasibility study is underway to develop a method that determines the location of the scatterers by producing a complete mapping of scatterers within test samples, including their depth distribution, optical amplitude distribution, and lateral distribution. Also, research is underway to accurately identify future materials and/or coating methods that possess the largest possible mechanical quality factor (Q). Current efforts propose a new experimental approach that will more precisely measure the Q of coatings by depositing them onto 100 nm Silicon Nitride membranes.

We present the Extended Folded Pendulum Model (EFPM), a model developed for a quantitative description of the dynamical behavior of a folded pendulum generically oriented in space. This model, based on the Tait-Bryan angular reference system, highlights the relationship between the folded pendulum orientation in the gravitational field and its natural resonance frequency. Tis model validated by tests performed with a monolithic UNISA Folded Pendulum, highlights a new technique of implementation of folded pendulum based tiltmeters.

Successfully implemented in GEO and Virgo+, the monolithic suspensions are one of the most important upgrades in the second generation of gravitational wave interferometric detectors, including Advanced LIGO (aLIGO) and Advanced Virgo (AdV). Characterized by a very low thermal noise, monolithic suspensions are essential for improving the interferometers sensitivity at low frequencies (10-100Hz). In Advanced Virgo their installation was delayed because of a contamination problem in the vacuum system: dust produced by scroll pumps was injected in the main vacuum chambers during the venting processes, damaging the fibers and ultimately causing their repeated failure. The effort to explain and resolve this issue was useful to further confirm the suspensions' reliability and our control on the production process. Moreover, we developed and implemented new tools and procedures to certify each part of the monolithic suspensions. In the meanwhile, in order to join aLIGO during its second Observation Run (O2), a temporary steel suspension was implemented, based on the initial Virgo design. That solution allowed us to contribute to the first three-detector observation of a gravitational wave (GW) ([1]), and to the first observation of a coalescing neutron star binary ([2]) In the near future the monolithic suspensions will be reinstalled along with additional upgrades of Virgo.

SCHENBERG is a resonant-mass gravitational wave detector with a frequency about 3.2 kHz. Its spherical antenna, weighing 1.15 metric ton, is connected to the external world by a system which must attenuate seismic noise. When a gravitational wave passes the antenna vibrates, its motion is monitored by transducers. These parametric transducers uses microwaves carried by coaxial cables that are also connected to the external world, they also carry seismic noise. In this analysis the system was modeled using finite element method. This work shows that the addition of masses along these cables can decrease this noise, so that this noise is below the thermal noise of the detector when operating at 50 mK.

Measurements of black-hole spins are of crucial importance to fulfill the promise of gravitational-wave astronomy. On the astrophysics side, spins are perhaps the cleanest indicator of black-hole evolutionary processes, thus providing a preferred way to discriminate how LIGO's black holes form. On the relativity side, spins are responsible for peculiar dynamical phenomena (from precessional modulations in the long inspiral to gravitational-wave recoils at merger) which encode precious information on the underlying astrophysical processes. I present some examples to explore this deep and fascinating interplay between spin dynamics (relativity) and environmental effects (astrophysics). Black-hole spins indeed hide remarkable surprises on both fronts: morphologies, resonances, constraints on supernova kicks, multiple merger generations and more...

These findings were presented at 12^th Edoardo Amaldi Conference on Gravitational Waves, held on July 9-14, 2017 in Pasadena, CA, USA.