I read with interest Philip Anderson's critique of the reductionist tendencies of particle physics (November 2006 pp10–11). Like many physicists of my generation, I grew up with Douglas Hofstadter's book Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid and its attempted synthesis of reductionist and holistic methods of scientific explanation. Furthermore, I am sure most physicists recognize the importance of Anderson's favoured philosophy – emergence – in the context of thermodynamics, whereby temperature, pressure and entropy appear at first to owe little to our understanding of the properties of individual atoms or molecules since no single atom can be said to possess any of these properties.