Table of contents for issue 4, volume 51, Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion

Volume 51

Number 4, April 2009

Previous issueNext issue

SPECIAL SECTION ON RECENT PROGRESS ON RADIO FREQUENCY HEATING AND CURRENT DRIVE STUDIES IN THE JET TOKAMAK

Buy this issue in print

    EDITORIAL

  • 040201
    The following article is Free article

    , and

    This special cluster of papers summarizes the work accomplished during the last three years in the framework of the Task Force Heating at JET, whose mission it is to study the optimisation of heating systems for plasma heating and current drive, launching and deposition questions and the physics of plasma rotation.

    Good progress and new physics insights have been obtained with the three heating systems available at JET: lower hybrid (LH), ion cyclotron resonance heating (ICRH) and neutral beam injection (NBI). Topics covered in the present issue are the use of edge gas puffing to improve the coupling of LH waves at large distances between the plasma separatrix and the LH launcher. Closely linked with this topic are detailed studies of the changes in LH coupling due to modifications in the scrape-off layer during gas puffing and simultaneous application of ICRH. We revisit the fundamental ICRH heating of D plasmas, include new physics results made possible by recently installed new diagnostic capabilities on JET and point out caveats for ITER when NBI is simultaneously applied. Other topics are the study of the anomalous behaviour of fast ions from NBI, and a study of toroidal rotation induced by ICRH, both again with possible implications for ITER.

    In finalizing this cluster of articles, thanks are due to all colleagues involved in preparing and executing the JET programme under EFDA in recent years. We want to thank the EFDA leadership for the special privilege of appointing us as Leaders or Deputies of Task Force Heating, a wonderful and hardworking group of colleagues. Thanks also to all other European and non-European scientists who contributed to the JET scientific programme, the Operations team of JET and the colleagues of the Close Support Unit (CSU). Thanks are also due to the Editors, Editorial Board and referees of Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion together with the publishing staff of IOP Publishing who have supported and contributed substantially to this initiative.

  • PAPERS

  • 044001

    , , , , , , , , , et al

    Good coupling of lower hybrid (LH) waves has been demonstrated in different H-mode scenarios in JET, at high triangularity (δ ∼ 0.4) and at large distance between the last closed flux surface and the LH launcher (up to 15 cm). Local gas injection of D2 in the region magnetically connected to the LH launcher is used for increasing the local density in the scrape-off layer (SOL). Reciprocating Langmuir probe measurements magnetically connected to the LH launcher indicate that the electron density profile flattens in the far SOL during gas injection and LH power application. Some degradation in normalized H-mode confinement, as given by the H98(y,2)-factor, could be observed at high gas injection rates in these scenarios, but this was rather due to total gas injection and not specifically to the local gas puffing used for LH coupling. Furthermore, experiments carried out in L-mode plasmas in order to evaluate the effect on the LH current drive efficiency, when using local gas injection to improve the coupling, indicate only a small degradation (ΔILH/ILH ∼ 15%). This effect is largely compensated by the improvement in coupling and thus increase in coupled power when using gas puffing.

  • 044002

    , , , , , , , , , et al

    Lower hybrid (LH) current drive experiments have been carried out on JET with an antenna–plasma separatrix distance varying between 0.09 and 0.15 m, and LH power in the range 0–3.2 MW. For different plasma configurations, the electron density ne of the scrape-off layer has been studied by the mean of a reciprocating Langmuir probe magnetically connected to the LH antenna. For pulses in the high confinement regime (H mode) characterized by strong particle bursts in the plasma edge, the edge localized modes (ELMs), profiles of the saturation current (Jsat) are obtained with a sufficient time resolution to distinguish ‘between ELMs’ and during the rise and decay of the ELMs.

    It is found that gas injection from a valve located near the LH launcher and magnetically connected to it allows one to raise the density and improve the LH coupling. The Jsat profiles indicate quite clearly that this density rise affects mainly the plasma layer in front of the antenna with a typical thickness of 5 cm. The resulting profile can be extremely flat in this region. The effect of the near-launcher gas injection but also of the LH power and the total gas injection on the density at the wall is quantitatively documented. It is shown in particular that with increasing LH power, the required gas injection for obtaining good LH coupling is decreasing, with no saturation obtained so far. Effect of the ELMs on the LH coupling is also discussed. Modelling with the EDGE2D code indicates that such flat profiles of Jsat/ne can be obtained when LH power dissipation is taken into account. Detailed analysis of the heat flux carried by electrons accelerated in the near-field of the antenna confirms the increase in density with gas puff during high LH power coupling.

  • 044003

    , , , , , , , , , et al

    Lower hybrid (LH) wave coupling is modified and usually degraded when the system is powered simultaneously with the ion cyclotron range of frequency (ICRF) antennas magnetically connected to the launcher. This has been attributed to scrape-off layer density modifications by the RF sheaths. LH reflection coefficients dependences on various parameters are investigated and shown to be consistent with RF sheath physics. Gas puffing near the launcher has been used to improve the coupling of LH waves.

  • 044004

    , , , , , , , , , et al

    Trace tritium experiments (TTE) on JET were analysed using Monte Carlo modelling of the neutron emission resulting from the neutral beam injection (NBI) of short (∼300 ms) tritium (T) beam blips into reversed shear, hybrid ELMy H-mode and L-mode deuterium plasmas for a wide range of plasma parameters. The calculated neutron fluxes from deuterium–tritium (DT) reactions could only be made consistent with all plasmas by applying an artificial reduction of the T beam power in the modelling of between 20% and 40%. A similar discrepancy has previously been observed in both JET (Gorini et al 2004 Proc. 31st EPS Conf. on Plasma Physics (London, UK) vol 28G (ECA)) and TFTR (Ruskov et al 1999 Phys. Rev. Lett.82 924), although no mechanism has yet been found that could explain such a difference in the measured T beam power. Applying this correction in the T beam power, good agreement between calculated and measured DT neutron emission profiles was obtained in low to moderate line averaged density Equation or symbol description not available ELMy H-Mode plasmas assuming that the fast beam ions experience no, or relatively small, anomalous diffusion (Dan ≪ 0.5 m2 s−1). However, the modelled neutron profiles do not agree with measurements in higher density plasmas using the same assumption and the disagreement between the measured and calculated shape of the neutron profile increases with plasma density. In this paper it is demonstrated that large anomalous losses of fast ions have to be assumed in the simulations to improve agreement between experimental and simulated neutron profiles, characterized by the goodness of fit. Various types of fast ion losses are modelled to explain aspects of the data, though further investigation will be required in order to gain a more detailed understanding of the nature of those anomalous losses.

  • 044005

    , , , , , , , , , et al

    Radio frequency heating of majority ions is of prime importance for understanding the basic role of auxiliary heating in the activated D–T phase of ITER. Majority deuterium ion cyclotron resonance heating (ICRH) experiments at the fundamental cyclotron frequency were performed in JET. In spite of the poor antenna coupling at 25 MHz, this heating scheme proved promising when adopted in combination with D neutral beam injection (NBI). The effect of fundamental ICRH of a D population was clearly demonstrated in these experiments: by adding ∼25% of heating power the fusion power was increased up to 30–50%, depending on the type of NBI adopted. At this power level, the ion and electron temperatures increased from Ti ∼ 4.0 keV and Te ∼ 4.5 keV (NBI-only phase) to Ti ∼ 5.5 keV and Te ∼ 5.2 keV (ICRH + NBI phase), respectively. The increase in the neutron yield was stronger when 80 keV rather than 130 keV deuterons were injected in the plasma. It is shown that the neutron rate, the diamagnetic energy and the electron as well as the ion temperature scale roughly linearly with the applied RF power. A synergistic effect of the combined use of ICRF and NBI heating was observed: (i) the number of neutron counts measured by the neutron camera during the combined ICRF + NBI phases of the discharges exceeded the sum of the individual counts of the NBI-only and ICRF-only phases; (ii) a substantial increase in the number of slowing-down beam ions was detected by the time of flight neutron spectrometer when ICRF power was switched on; (iii) a small D subpopulation with energies slightly above the NBI launch energy was detected by the neutral particle analyzer and γ-ray spectroscopy.

  • 044006

    , , , , and

    Recent experiments in JET have provided new information on majority ICRF heating schemes in large tokamak plasmas. Adopting a wide range of available diagnostics, the plasma behaviour in a fundamental D majority ICRF heating scenario was investigated. The main results of the experiments are that, due to the modest RF power available at the frequencies necessary for central D absorption in JET associated with the reduced RF electric field amplitude near the cold ion-cyclotron resonance layer of the D majority ions, ICRH alone is barely capable of heating the plasma. On the other hand, when preheating the plasma using neutral beam injection, the wave–plasma coupling is improved and considerable plasma heating followed by increased neutron yield was observed in several discharges. The enhancement of the ICRH efficiency in the presence of NBI is attributed not only to the lower collisionality of the pre-heated plasma but also to the Doppler-shifted ion-cyclotron resonance absorption of the fast beam ions. This effect has been observed with several diagnostics and was confirmed by numerical simulations. The numerical modelling was done adopting a coupled full wave/quasi-linear Fokker–Planck (QLFP) code that takes into account the non-Maxwellian distributions of the injected beam ions in the wave equation, and the actual local RF electric field structure obtained by the full-wave computations in the Fokker–Planck description. By studying the response of the plasma to sudden changes in the ICRF power level, the experimental RF power deposition profiles were estimated and compared with the theoretical predictions. Finally, a qualitative link between the RF-heated beam distributions obtained in the QLFP simulations and some of the experimental results is also presented.

  • 044007

    , , , , , , , , , et al

    Recent JET experiments have been devoted to the study of (3He)–D plasmas involving radio frequency (RF) heating. This paper starts by discussing the RF heating efficiency theoretically expected in such plasmas, covering both relevant aspects of wave and of particle dynamics. Then it gives a concise summary of the main conclusions drawn from recent experiments that were either focusing on studying RF heating physics aspects or that were adopting RF heating as a tool to study plasma behavior. Depending on the minority concentration chosen, different physical phenomena are observed. At very low concentration (X[3He] < 1%), energetic tails are formed which trigger MHD activity and result in loss of fast particles. Alfvén cascades were observed and gamma ray tomography indirectly shows the impact of sawtooth crashes on the fast particle orbits. Low concentration (X[3He] < 10%) favors minority heating while for X[3He] ≫ 10% electron mode conversion damping becomes dominant. Evidence for the Fuchs et al standing wave effect (Fuchs et al 1995 Phys. Plasmas2 1637–47) on the absorption is presented. RF induced deuterium tails were observed in mode conversion experiments with large X[3He] (≈18%). As tentative modeling shows, the formation of these tails can be explained as a consequence of wave power absorption by neutral beam particles that efficiently interact with the waves well away from the cold D cyclotron resonance position as a result of their substantial Doppler shift. As both ion and electron RF power deposition profiles in (3He)–D plasmas are fairly narrow—giving rise to localized heat sources—the RF heating method is an ideal tool for performing transport studies. Various of the experiments discussed here were done in plasmas with internal transport barriers (ITBs). ITBs are identified as regions with locally reduced diffusivity, where poloidal spinning up of the plasma is observed. The present know-how on the role of RF heating for impurity transport is also briefly summarized.

  • 044008

    , , , , , , , and

    Observations of bulk plasma rotation in radio frequency (RF) heated JET discharges are reported. This study is concentrated on RF heated L-mode plasmas. In particular, the toroidal rotation profiles in plasmas heated by ion cyclotron resonance frequency (ICRF) waves and lower hybrid (LH) waves have been analysed. It is the first time that rotation profiles in JET plasmas with LH waves have been measured in dedicated discharges. It is found that the toroidal plasma rotation in the outer region of the plasmas is in the co-current direction irrespective of the heating scenario. An interesting feature is that the toroidal rotation profile appears to be hollow in many discharges at low plasma current, but a low current in itself does not seem to be a sufficient condition for finding such profiles. Fast ion transport and finite orbit width effects are mechanisms that could explain hollow rotation profiles. This possibility has been investigated by numerical simulations of the torque on the bulk plasma due to fast ICRF accelerated ions. The obtained torque is used in a transport equation for the toroidal momentum density to estimate the effect on the thermal bulk plasma rotation profile.

  • REGULAR PAPERS

  • 045001

    , , , and

    An experimental study on hard x-ray production in a small plasma focus device operating in a few hundreds of Joule range is presented. A threshold in the voltage drop on the pinch was observed for x-ray emission. A comparison with Dreicer theory for electrons runaway in plasmas yields significant agreement. The study was performed at a constant pressure (1.8 mbar) of deuterium with three different anode lengths.

  • 045002

    and

    Recent observations of magnetic fluctuation activity in the Mega Ampere Spherical Tokamak (MAST) reveal the presence of plasmas with bands of both low and high frequency magnetic fluctuations. Such plasmas exhibit a spectrum of low frequency modes with adjacent toroidal mode numbers, for which the measured frequency is near the Doppler shifted rotation frequency of the plasma. These are thought to be tearing modes. Also present are a spectrum of high frequency modes (e.g. Alfvén, fishbone and/or ICE). The frequency and mode number of the tearing mode and its harmonics is identical to the frequency and mode number splitting of the high frequency MHD activity, strongly suggesting that the high frequency splitting is produced by modulation of the high and low frequency modes. We describe a strong modulation model, in which the nonlinear terms are fitted to produce the amplitude envelope profile of the tearing mode. A bispectral analysis proves that the low frequency modes are indeed in phase with the fundamental, while Fourier-SVD mode analysis confirms the mode numbers are toroidal harmonics. Employing this model, the sideband amplitude profile of the high frequency modes is predicted, and found to be in good agreement with experimental observations. Also, toroidal mode number splitting of the high frequency activity matches the mode number of the tearing mode. Weak evidence is found to indicate the Alfvénic sidebands are in phase with the Alfvén eigenmode fundamental. The findings support predictions of a strong modulation model, and suggest a need to further develop nonlinear MHD theory to predict the amplitude of coupled sidebands, and so corroborate the observed nonlinear plasma response.

  • 045003

    , , , and

    Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) theory of ideal instabilities in a high-β rotating cylindrical plasma with an azimuthal magnetic field and a radial gravitational field is developed (β is the ratio of the plasma and magnetic field pressures). The basis of this theory is a system of two first-order differential equations for the Frieman–Rotenberg variable (the sum of the perturbed plasma and magnetic field pressures) and the radial plasma displacement, which leads to the second-order differential equation for the displacement. The sausage instability criterion is derived which generalizes the earlier results for a plasma without gravitation. It is shown that this instability can occur for both the decreasing and increasing plasma pressures. The non-axisymmetric modes are also considered. This analysis is related to the MHD instability theory in a nonrotating plasma dealing with snake instabilities. A number of rotational and gravitational effects on both the m = 1 and m > 1 modes are revealed, where m is the azimuthal mode number. The eigenmode equation describing the Suydam modes in the presence of rotational and gravitational effects is derived. These modes can be responsible, in particular, for the Velikhov and rotational-convective instabilities.

  • 045004

    , , and

    The toroidal current driven by relaxation processes in a cylindrical spherical tokamak (ST) geometry with coaxial injected flux is estimated by use of the linear ideal stability boundary of equilibria with a high current on the open driven flux and a lower current on the closed flux. Instabilities with toroidal mode number n = 1 have been shown to play a vital role in the helicity injection current drive, being closely associated with the relaxation process which distributes current from a directly driven open flux to a closed flux. Previous results for spheromaks (1D and 2D equilibria) and STs (1D equilibria) have predicted stabilization, for a given open flux current, if the closed flux plasma current is sufficiently large, suggesting that the current drive mechanism is self-limiting. New results presented here for 2D ST equilibria are consistent with the 1D results, but new features appear in the stability maps as the axial length and toroidal field (TF) strength are varied in the equilibria. These include changes in the shape of stability boundaries and the estimated driven current, changes in the mode structure due to equilibrium changes and resonance effects which extend stability boundaries into the stable region. As the minimum and maximum of the safety factor q profile cross integer rational values, the resonant mode is destabilized, causing regions of enhanced instability in the current profile parameter space. The results show the effects on the stability of varying the geometric length ratio R/L and provide driven current estimates with varying imposed TF strengths; these results have implications both for existing STs and for the design of future devices.

  • 045005

    , , and

    The injection of energetic neutral atoms is a major component of plasma heating in fusion experiments. In order to fulfill the requirements of the ITER neutral beam injection (NBI), a RF-driven ion source for negative ions has been developed at the MPI für Plasma Physik (IPP Garching). Negative hydrogen ions are generated on a converter surface by impinging neutral particles and positive ions under the influence of magnetic fields and the plasma sheath potential. A 3D negative ion trajectory calculation including a Monte Carlo description of reactions and collisions with plasma particles was used to calculate the total and spatially resolved extraction probabilities for realistic field topologies and geometries of the large scale extraction system LAG. The experimentally observed increase in extracted ion current by the use of chamfered aperture collars agrees with the results of the ion transport simulation. Profiles of the extraction probability on the converter show that most of the extracted negative ions are created in the vicinity of the plasma grid apertures. These areas of intensified extraction probability are influenced by the magnetic field configuration. The ion extraction probability is affected by the long ranging magnetic filter field. The short ranging electron deflection field, however, which is generated by magnets near the converter surface, does not significantly influence the extraction probability.

  • 045006

    and

    The Hamiltonian representation of magnetic field lines enables one to study their confinement properties in tokamaks through the use of symplectic maps such as the symmetric tokamap and its bounded version, the latter being introduced here. In this time-independent purely magnetic framework, we observed the drastic improvement in the confinement of magnetic field lines produced by the local vanishing of the shear profile. This amounts to a non-twist condition that notably acts in the same way the safety profile being (non-strictly) monotonic or having a reversed shear. We single out the effect of the amount of flatness of the safety profile in the vicinity of its zero shear point. All other things being equal, the beneficial effect of the vanishing of the shear profile is shown to be increased if the radial extent of the low-shear region is increased. To be specific, the low-shear region induces the formation of a belt of robust KAM tori acting as an internal transport barrier whose width is all the larger as the extent of the low-shear region is broad.

  • 045007

    , , , , , and

    We present cross section experimental data required for modeling beam production, attenuation and energy loss in the heavy-ion beam probe technique, namely, electron-loss cross sections for anionic gold projectiles and Ar and N2 targets in the energy range from 30 keV to 1 MeV. The results agree well with low-energy measured values from the literature for the Ar target. The present results are also compared with literature results for the H− projectile and the Ar target, displaying similar velocity dependences. This similarity led to the use of a simple semi-classical model to calculate the projectile-electron-loss cross sections in a wide energy range. This model employs the total scattering cross sections for free electrons and the momentum distribution of the Au− electrons. The present experimental results are in good agreement with this model, allowing a reliable estimate of the cross section values up to 100 MeV. Our results indicate that previously calculated cross sections are overestimated by at least a factor of two. This previous overestimation of electron-loss cross sections leads to significant errors in the modeling of charge-state fractions of gold beams, with consequences in the optimization of beam energy resolution and intensity for HIBP with megaelectronvolts gold beams.

  • COMMENT

  • 048001

  • REPLY

  • 048002

    and

    In his comment to our recent work (Simakov et al2008 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion50 105010), Aydemir has asserted that poloidal plasma flow reversal is not a valid response to toroidal magnetic field reversal in an up–down symmetric tokamak, and that the toroidal plasma flow must reverse instead. We show that this assertion is wrong due to his misunderstanding of the corresponding symmetry transformation.