PREFACE
E01
The following article is Free article
F.C. Schüller
It has been suggested by diagnosticians that alongside the series of Nuclear Fusion special issues dedicated to the physics and technology of heating subsystems for large tokamaks, it would also be worthwhile to publish special issues concentrating on diagnostic systems. Since the field of tokamak diagnostics is very large, it is the intention of the journal to have, every year, one special issue focusing on one specific branch of diagnostics. For this first diagnostics special issue we selected the branch of reflectometry. This method has evolved from a mere auxiliary method to reconstruct density profiles to a sophisticated tool with many applications. These applications range from plasma control to the intricate physics of turbulence. The issue in front of you contains a very interesting mixture of articles on experimental techniques and a wealth of physics observations. They stem from the 7th International Reflectometry Workshop organized by IPP-Garching in May 2005. The workshop gave us a welcome motive to start with this first special issue on diagnostics. I am grateful that we could leave the guest editorship of this issue in the expert hands of Garrard Conway. As an introduction to the subject he has written a summary which appears as the first article of this issue.
INTRODUCTION
S665
G.D. Conway
PAPERS
S670
T. Tokuzawa, K. Kawahata, K. Tanaka and the LHD Experimental Group
We have installed a ten channel Ka-band ultrashort pulsed radar reflectometer system in the Large Helical Device. The main objective of this diagnostic is to provide reliable information about the edge electron density profile. The time-of-flight measurement technique is used for the delay time measurement of the reflected pulses from each cut-off layer in the plasma, in order to avoid a mixture of spurious radiation such as electron cyclotron emission and undesired reflection such as another polarization wave mode. As for the signal detection section, a filter bank system is applied; the reflected pulse shape is affected by the bandwidth of band pass filter; thus, the optimum bandwidth must be found experimentally. The reconstructed electron density profile is obtained using an Abel inversion method from the profile of the delay time as a function of the probing frequency. In density modulation experiments, the static island width can be estimated from the temporal change of the density profile.
S677
L. Zeng, G. Wang, E.J. Doyle, T.L. Rhodes, W.A. Peebles and Q. Peng
High temporal (⩾10 µs) and spatial (⩾4 mm) resolution electron density profiles can now be automatically obtained on a between-shot basis from profile reflectometry data on the DIII-D tokamak. Fast, automated analysis is made possible by a new between-shot analysis package, details of which are presented. Analysis of X-mode data covering ∼0–3 × 1019 m−3 with 1 ms duration data bursts every 5 ms for 5–6 s, for a total of ∼1000 profiles, takes 4–5 min, allowing the profiles to be viewed and used between shots. Additional details are provided of how the system density coverage at the above temporal and spatial resolution was recently expanded to (0–6.4) × 1019 m−3 using a novel simultaneous, dual-polarization (O- and X- mode) measurement technique. Automatic (but not between-shot) analysis for the complete O- and X-mode data set (1.5 GB for each discharge, about 100 000 profiles at 25 µs temporal resolution) is available after the experiment. The improved capabilities of the system are illustrated using new results from a variety of areas such as edge localized mode dynamics, L–H transition and pedestal physics, impurity deposition and ITB studies, and direct comparisons with Thomson data are presented.
S685
R. Sabot, A. Sirinelli, J.-M. Chareau and J.-C. Giaccalone
The stepped fixed frequency X-mode reflectometer operating between 105 and 155 GHz first designed for density fluctuation measurement has been upgraded to also measure the density profile. It runs now with two sources in parallel: a fast swept source and a frequency synthesizer to measure during the same shot the density profile and density fluctuations. The accuracy of the density profile from reflectometry reduces uncertainties on fluctuation profile measurement. This double operating mode also offers two ways to probe MHD modes and the micro-turbulence.
S693
P. Varela, M.E. Manso, A. Silva, the CFN Team and the ASDEX Upgrade Team
Broadband FM-CW reflectometry is foreseen to be used on ITER to measure the electron density profile, both in the main and divertor plasmas. These measurements should provide crucial information for machine control and operation, in complement to magnetic diagnostics, and require the automatic evaluation of the density profile in all relevant plasma scenarios. This is a complex task due to the effects of plasma turbulence on the probing microwaves. A major and continued effort both on hardware development and data processing has been made in the ASDEX Upgrade broadband reflectometry diagnostic since 1991, which has led to noticeable improvements of density profile measurements. Here we review the evolution of the data processing techniques for profile evaluation. We first describe the standard methods that have been applied in ASDEX Upgrade (as well as in other machines) and discuss their advantages and limitations. Secondly, the novel techniques implemented in ASDEX Upgrade are presented and the resulting improvements on profile evaluation are discussed. It is shown that these are due to the ability to use both the a priori knowledge about profile measurements and the advanced features of the ASDEX Upgrade reflectometry diagnostic.
S708
G. Wang, W.A. Peebles, T.L. Rhodes, G.J. Kramer, E.J. Doyle, G.R. McKee, R. Nazikian, N.A. Crocker, X. Nguyen, L. Zeng et al
Fixed-frequency reflectometers utilizing quadrature phase detection are employed on DIII-D to study both coherent and turbulent density fluctuations. For coherent fluctuations, the reconstructed phase information successfully identifies MHD/coherent mode activity, e.g. tearing modes, compressional Alfvén eigenmodes, etc. For an m = 3/n = 2 tearing mode, a basic 1D phase screen model is applied to infer fluctuation levels, and the result is consistent with the beam emission spectroscopy (BES) measurement. For turbulent fluctuation studies, a 2D full-wave code (Valeo E.J., Kramer G.J. and Nazikian R. 2002 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion44 L1) is applied to interpret reflectometry data obtained in the H-mode edge pedestal region to deduce density fluctuation levels. The measurement is simulated using realistic geometry, plasma conditions and antenna patterns. Comparison of the fluctuation level deduced from the 2D code with BES measurement shows reasonable agreement.
S714
S. Hacquin, B. Alper, S. Sharapov, D. Borba, C. Boswell, J. Fessey, L. Meneses, M. Walsh and JET EFDA contributors
A multi-channel reflectometer diagnostic probing the mid-plane plasma in the O-mode polarization is routinely used for detection of Alfvén eigenmodes (AEs) on the JET tokamak. The AEs are observed on the spectrogram of the homodyne signal reflected by the inner wall when the probing frequency is higher than the maximum of the plasma frequency (interferometry regime). In particular the time and frequency resolution of the Alfvén cascades (ACs) is better from this technique than from any other diagnostic. We show here that knowing the shape of the density fluctuations induced by an AC, the level of these density fluctuations can also be inferred from the phase fluctuations of the reflectometry signal.
S722
A.G. Elfimov, L.F. Ruchko, R.M.O. Galvão, J.I. Elizondo, E. Sanada, Yu.K. Kuznetsov, A.N. Fagundes, W.P. de Sá, C.A.F. Varandas, M.E.C. Manso et al
Local Alfvén wave (LAW) resonances are excited in tokamaks by an externally driven electro-magnetic field, below the ion cyclotron frequency. Based on TCABR (Tokamak Chauffage Alfvén Brésilien) experiments and numerical calculations, it is shown that a combination of small power deposition in LAW resonances, swept by plasma density variation or scanned by varying generator frequencies, in combination with detection of the density fluctuations in the LAW resonances by reflectometry, can serve as a diagnostic tool for identification of the effective ion mass number Aef and q-profile in tokamaks. The idea is based on the simultaneous detection of the position of m = ±1 LAW resonances, which are excited by M/N = ±1/±2 antenna modes and m = 0 generated by the poloidal mode coupling effect in tokamaks. The m = 0 resonance depends only on the effective ion mass number and not on the q-profile, so that the mass number can be determined unambiguously. Then, we can determine q-factor at the position of m = ±1 LAW resonances. Using the multifluid ALTOK code, we identify mass number in TCABR experiments and demonstrate the possibility of applying this method in the Joint European Torus.
S730
A. Krämer–Flecken, S. Soldatov, C. Busch, Y. Liang, M. von Hellermann, R. Wolf, O. Zimmermann and the TEXTOR–Team
The O-mode correlation reflectometer at TEXTOR is used for the investigation of the propagation and the properties of the turbulence at the plasma edge. The multi-horn antenna set-up allows the investigation of the correlation properties of the turbulence and its rotation. Turbulence and plasma rotation for different plasma conditions are found to be in agreement and based on this comparison the radial electric field is estimated. In addition the density fluctuation level is estimated from the standard deviation of the phase of the reflected signal.
The influence of a magnetic perturbation field, generated by the dynamic ergodic divertor (DED), on the turbulence and transport properties is studied and compared with plasmas without such a field perturbation. The strength and radial range of the perturbation field can be widely varied. Together with tangential neutral beam injection in co- and counter-current directions, the turbulent transport is investigated. The combination of neutral beam injection and the DED enables the modification of the plasma rotation profile. It can lead either to the generation of a locked mode or the formation of a transport barrier.
S743
L. Vermare, S. Heuraux, F. Clairet, G. Leclert and F. da Silva
The knowledge of the turbulence characteristics is a key point to build models able to predict the confinement time in a fusion reactor. A method to extract the radial profile of the density fluctuations from the fast swept reflectometry phase signal is proposed and tested on Tore Supra (TS). The relationship between the wavenumber spectrum of the set of phase perturbations obtained during a frequency sweep and the wavenumber spectrum of the turbulence itself is the aim of the method. This relationship can be derived analytically for the O-mode. For the X-mode it is established by full wave simulations. As a result, the radial profile of density fluctuations can be obtained from a mere integration of the wavenumber spectrum of the phase fluctuations. The assumptions used to establish this diagnostics and its limitations are discussed by using simulations. Then the method is applied to recover the radial profile of the density fluctuations in the cases of the TS fast swept reflectometer data. With this method, the expected density profile evolution as a function of the plasma current is clearly shown.
S760
M. Ignatenko, A. Mase, L.G. Bruskin, Y. Kogi and H. Hojo
In this paper, numerical experiment is used to study the imaging properties of microwave imaging reflectometry for the case of tandem mirror device geometry. First of all, the alignment of the experimental setup is performed and then the imaging system is applied for density fluctuations measurements. Fluctuations employed in this study have a nonshifted Gaussian wavenumber spectrum with equal poloidal and radial widths. The size of the optics is shown to be a main parameter limiting the performance of the imaging system. Space-imaging and time-imaging modes are considered. In the latter case, for model conditions imaging and conventional (without optics) reflectometers demonstrate comparable performance in general. When root-mean-squared amplitude of the density fluctuations is large (σn = 0.06 and 0.09) the imaging system shows a wider range of measurable parameters.
S771
P. Hennequin, C. Honoré, A. Truc, A. Quéméneur, C. Fenzi-Bonizec, C. Bourdelle, X. Garbet, G.T. Hoang and the Tore Supra team
Backscattering of a microwave beam close to the cut-off allows for measurement of density fluctuations
at a specified wave-number, selected by the scattering geometry
, where ki is the beam wave-number at the reflection layer. On the Doppler reflectometry system installed on Tore Supra, both the scattering wave-number k⊥ and the scattering localization (r/a) can be changed during the shot owing to the steppable probing frequency and the motorized antenna. Operating in O mode, the spatial and wave-number ranges depend essentially on density profile, typically probing 0.5 < r/a < 0.95 and 2 < k < 15 cm−1. Wave number spectra are similar to those obtained with conventional scattering systems. The perpendicular fluctuation velocity in the laboratory frame is obtained from the Doppler shift of the frequency spectrum Δω = k⊥v⊥. It is dominated by the plasma Er × B velocity. In the core, the latter is mainly due to the projection of the toroidal velocity, as this is shown by comparison with measurements by charge exchange recombination spectroscopy. In the set of analysed Tore Supra ohmic and ICRH plasmas, the observed rotation is consistent with a poloidal velocity in the electron diamagnetic direction and/or a toroidal velocity in the counter current direction. The detailed structure of the velocity profile, at the edge and in different plasma regimes, allows us then to get information on the radial electric field distribution. The dynamics of the fluctuation velocity can be studied from the time frequency analysis of the signal, for investigating intermittent behaviour and transient regimes.
S780
J. Schirmer, G.D. Conway, H. Zohm, W. Suttrop and the ASDEX Upgrade Team
The radial electric field (Er) and its shear (∂Er/∂r) are believed to be fundamental for turbulence suppression in magnetically confined plasmas. Doppler reflectometry offers a direct method of obtaining Er and ∂Er/∂r measurements. It is a type of microwave radar technique which uses the back-scatter of microwaves from a radial position in the plasma where the refractive index equals zero. In this paper, the use of Doppler reflectometry for Er measurements is investigated. The technique is extended for ∂Er/∂r measurements by simultaneously probing the plasma with two microwave beams at different frequencies. Er and ∂Er/∂r measurements are presented for a wide variety of plasma conditions. The measurements show that Er and its associated shear are linked to plasma confinement. Their absolute values increase with confinement at the plasma edge. Furthermore, the measurements show dependence on the applied plasma auxiliary heating and the plasma shape. The Er shear results suggest that negative shear is more influential than positive shear, in contradiction to several theoretical models.
S792
T. Estrada, E. Blanco, L. Cupido, M.E. Manso and J. Sánchez
A broadband fast frequency hopping reflectometer designed for measuring plasma turbulence is in operation at TJ-II. The main feature of the reflectometer is its possibility to be tuned to any selected frequency within a fraction of a millisecond. This property enables us to probe several plasma layers within a short time interval during the discharge, permitting the characterization of the radial distribution of plasma fluctuations. The system uses a standard antennas arrangement designed to probe the plasma perpendicularly. Although the present reflectometer arrangement was not meant to measure the perpendicular rotation velocity, the system allows us to extract important information about the velocity shear layer, namely its spatial localization. Reflectometry measurements showing the so-called phase run-away have permitted the spatial localization of the velocity shear layer that develops spontaneously in TJ-II plasmas at a certain critical density. A comparison with results obtained using Langmuir probes helps in interpretation of the results. Besides, the interpretation of the experimental results has been crosschecked with results obtained using a two-dimensional full-wave code.
S799
G.D. Conway, C. Angioni, R. Dux, F. Ryter, A.G. Peeters, J. Schirmer, C. Troester, CFN Reflectometry Group and the ASDEX Upgrade team
In Doppler reflectometry the antenna tilt angle θt induces a Doppler frequency shift fD = u⊥ 2 sin θt/λo in the measured spectrum which is directly proportional to the rotation velocity u⊥ = vE × B + vph of the turbulence moving in the plasma. Measurements in ohmic ASDEX Upgrade core plasmas show u⊥ of the order of 1–2 km s−1 and reversing direction with increasing collisionality. Numerical simulations of the turbulence phase velocity vph using the GS2 linear gyrokinetic code reveal a change in the dominant core turbulence from ion temperature gradient (ITG) to trapped electron mode (TEM) with decreasing collisionality. The transition coincides with the u⊥ reversal. Extracting the E × B velocity from the measured u⊥ and the simulation vph indicates that the core radial electric field reverses sign with the turbulence. Using the radial force balance equation vE × B = v⊥ − v* and measured diamagnetic velocities v* gives a perpendicular fluid velocity v⊥ i reversing from ∼ 5 to 7.5 km s−1 (ion direction) at low collisionality to −0.7 km s−1 (electron direction) at high collisionality. Neoclassical predictions using the NEOART and NCLASS codes give poloidal Deuterium fluid velocities too small by factor of ten. Toroidal ion fluid velocities would need to be significant (> 30 km s−1) at low ν* to account for the difference. A clear ITG to TEM transition in the core turbulence has also been demonstrated using on-axis electron cyclotron heating to perturb the collisionality.
S809
C. Honoré, P. Hennequin, A. Truc and A. Quéméneur
Microwave beam backscattering near the cut-off layer appears to be the most interesting diagnostic to observe density fluctuation time evolution for a given localization in the plasma and at a defined wave vector. It also provides perpendicular plasma velocity. Scattering only occurs when the Bragg selection rule is fulfilled, i.e. when the scattering wave vector is almost perpendicular to the magnetic field. In order to evaluate these scattering conditions, ray tracing is required. 3D geometry is necessary to evaluate the angle between the magnetic field and the wave vector at the reflection. The ripple effect on the iso-index layer curve cannot be neglected. Scattering localization and wave vector resolution can be approached if single ray tracing is replaced with quasi-optical beam tracing. Optical propagation is still considered in the WKB approximation but the beam is described as multiple connected rays. The beam radial expansion due to diffraction is well described. This approach allows one to compute beam parameters for all data acquisitions (50 triggers per shot) and all shots (40 shots per day) during the following night on a recent personal computer with MatLab©.
S816
F. da Silva, S. Heuraux and M. Manso
Simulations of spectra generated in thin velocity shear layers having homogeneous turbulence with realistic wavenumber spectra and radial distribution were made with a 2D full-wave O-mode code. With a Doppler setup good localization of the velocity layer can be reached by changing the frequency at fixed oblique incidence. The poloidal velocity range existing in the shear layer is also accessed. Advantages and limitations of simulations are also discussed.
S824
E. Holzhauer and E. Blanco
In the presence of density gradients the propagation of electromagnetic waves in a magnetized plasma is modified with respect to the homogeneous case. The local dispersion relation depends on the sign of the angle of propagation and the polarity of the stationary magnetic field. The consequences for x-mode reflectometry are investigated with special emphasis on Doppler reflectometry. The results from full-wave 2D simulations are shown for the TJ-II stellarator and a small-scale laboratory experiment. Noticeable asymmetry effects are seen if the right-hand cut-off lies close to the upper-hybrid resonance.
S829
E.Z. Gusakov and A.Yu. Popov
In the present paper the localization of poloidal correlation reflectometry (PCR) is treated analytically for arbitrary density and turbulence profiles. The 3D WKB approach is used to calculate the fluctuation reflectometry signal and the PCR cross correlation function produced by long-scale turbulence. The study is performed in cylindrical geometry correctly accounting for the plasma curvature effects. The probing wave propagation is described in paraxial approximation accounting for the refraction and diffraction effects. The obtained explicit expressions for the PCR characteristics can be used for determination of the turbulence level and the velocity distribution from the experimental data for arbitrary density profiles.
S836
G. Vayakis, C.I. Walker, F. Clairet, R. Sabot, V. Tribaldos, T. Estrada, E. Blanco, J. Sánchez, G.G. Denisov, V.I. Belousov et al
Reflectometry with wavelengths in the centimetre to millimetre-wave range will be used in ITER to measure the density profile in the main plasma and divertor regions and to measure the plasma position and shape in order to provide a reference for the magnetic diagnostics in long pulses. In addition, it is expected to provide key information for the measurement of density fluctuations. A set of reflectometers to meet the relevant ITER measurement requirements has been included in its present outline as part of the ITER design since 2001 and is being adapted to the present ITER baseline and to accommodate progress with reflectometry techniques and measurement capabilities. It comprises low and high field side (HFS and LFS, respectively) ordinary (O-) mode systems for the measurement of the density profile in the gradient regions, a LFS extraordinary (X-) mode system for the detailed study of the edge profile, an HFS X-mode system operating in the left hand cutoff to measure the core profile, a dedicated O-mode system for plasma-wall gap measurement and a multi-band, multiple line of sight O-mode system to measure divertor density profiles. This paper describes the evolution of the design, in particular some recent improvements in the engineering implementation and improvements aimed at enhancing the measurement capability. It concludes with a brief assessment of the likely measurement performance against the ITER measurement requirements for the parameters of interest and the overall confidence that the technique will be implanted on ITER.
S846
G.J. Kramer, R. Nazikian, E.J. Valeo, R.V. Budny, C. Kessel and D. Johnson
The response of a low-field side X-mode reflectometer system for ITER is simulated with a 2D reflectometer code using a realistic plasma equilibrium. Relativistic corrections to the plasma permitivity due to the high electron temperature were included. It is found that the reflected beam will often miss its launch point by as much as 40 cm and that a vertical array of receiving antennas is essential in order to observe a reflection on the low-field side of ITER. Relativistic absorption effects were studied with a 1D full wave code and found to be insignificant for reflections from the low-field side up to the plasma centre.
S853
M. Hirsch, E. Holzhauer and H.-J. Hartfuss
Diagnostic equipment for the fully optimized stellarator Wendelstein 7-X involves a reflectometry system dedicated to measuring edge density profiles and characterizing density perturbations and their poloidal propagation velocity. Preparatory work such as design activities and the installation of a first antenna pair belongs to the so-called start-up diagnostics. For start-up a high-directivity broadband dual antenna arrangement is proposed where the optimization of the beam waists can be decoupled from the variable sightlines, which offers flexibility for the different modes of reflectometer operation. It is shown that for large devices such as W7-X the critical value for an optimum antenna arrangement is the aperture of the first plasma facing optical element, usually a first mirror, rather than the limitations arising from the finite plasma curvature.