The following article is Open access

Revisiting WASP-19b’s Orbital Evolution: New TESS Data and Apsidal Precession Analysis

Published September 2024 • © 2024. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.
, , Citation Zoutong Shen 2024 Res. Notes AAS 8 223DOI 10.3847/2515-5172/ad77a6

2515-5172/8/9/223

Abstract

Due to the ongoing debate of whether WASP19b is experiencing orbital decay or apsidal precession, I reexamine the orbital evolution of the hot Jupiter WASP-19b using new TESS data from sectors 09, 36, 62, and 63. My comprehensive analysis of transit and occultation timing variations compares models of constant period, orbital decay, and apsidal precession. Results show no significant preference between orbital decay and apsidal precession models. I find a period change rate of −1.40 ± 0.54 ms yr−1, slower than some previous studies but consistent with others. My apsidal precession analysis yields an eccentricity of 0.00178 and a precession rate of 0.036 deg day−1, differing from recent literature. These findings underscore the complexity of WASP-19b’s orbital dynamics and the need for continued long-term monitoring.

Export citation and abstractBibTeXRIS

Original content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence. Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.

1. Introduction

WASP-19b, a hot Jupiter with a radius of 1.41 RJ and mass of 1.14 MJ, orbits its G-dwarf host star with an exceptionally short period of 0.79 day (L. Hebb et al. 2009; C. Hellier et al. 2011). This ultra-short period raises questions about the planet’s orbital dynamics and long-term evolution. Recent studies have debated whether WASP-19b is undergoing orbital decay or experiencing apsidal precession, with significant implications for the system’s architecture and potential companions.

J. Korth & H. Parviainen (2023) reported evidence of orbital decay with a period change rate of −3.7 ± 0.5 ms yr−1. Conversely, L. M. Bernabò et al. (2024) suggested apsidal precession as an alternative explanation. This study aims to contribute to this ongoing debate by analyzing new TESS data and comparing models of constant period, orbital decay, and apsidal precession.

2. Data and Methods

I analyzed TESS (G. R. Ricker et al. 2015) data from sectors 09, 36, 62, and 63 with 120 s cadence. Light curves were detrended using an orbital-based segmentation method with 4-period intervals, which yielded the lowest Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) among tested methods.

My full-phase curve model incorporated stellar variations, transit, eclipse, and planetary phase variations:

Equation (1)

I performed Markov Chain Monte Carlo analysis by emcee (D. Foreman-Mackey et al. 2013) with 104 steps, discarding the initial 2 × 103 steps as burn-in. 248 transits and 14 occultations were analyzed. The timings were derived through a three-stage fitting process, maximizing timing precision.

I fitted three distinct models to the timing data: constant period, orbital decay, and apsidal precession. The BIC was used to compare model performance.

3. Results

My analysis compared three models: constant period, orbital decay, and apsidal precession. The results of these model fits are presented in Table 1.

Table 1. Orbital Models Results

ParameterValue
Constant Period
t0 (BJD–2455000)−481.868495 ± 0.000018
P (days)0.788839 ± 0.000000
${\chi }_{r}^{2}$ 5.40749
BIC1417.084225
Orbital Decay
$\dot{P}$ (ms yr−1)−1.153022 ± 0.538975
${\chi }_{r}^{2}$ 5.41016
BIC1417.937430
Apsidal Precession
e 0.001780 ± 0.000248
d ω/dt (deg day−1)0.03622961 ± 0.00561425
${\chi }_{r}^{2}$ 4.11628
BIC1085.726167

Based on the BIC values, I found no strong preference among the three models when considering transit timing variations alone. For the orbital decay model, I derived a period change rate ($\dot{P}$) of −1.153 ± 0.539 ms yr−1, slower than the −3.7 ± 0.5 ms yr−1 reported by J. Korth & H. Parviainen (2023), but consistent with some earlier findings.

My apsidal precession analysis yielded an eccentricity of 0.001780 ± 0.000248 and a precession rate of 0.03623 ± 0.00561 deg day−1, differing from the 0.065 deg day−1 reported by L. M. Bernabò et al. (2024).

The full-phase curve analysis yielded precise measurements of both the secondary eclipse depth and timing. I found a secondary eclipse depth of 376 ± 35 ppm, aligning with the ${470}_{-110}^{+130}$ ppm from I. Wong et al. (2020). Crucially, my analysis produced new, precise measurements of the occultation ephemeris. The occultation timings for different orbital cycles (N) are as follows:

  • 1.  
    N = 1319: BJD 2559.00373694 ± 0.008734
  • 2.  
    N = 2254: BJD 2561296.5698145 ± 0.009609
  • 3.  
    N = 3150: BJD 2562003.36957697 ± 0.008496
  • 4.  
    N = 3180: BJD 2562027.0334751 ± 0.002358.

These precise occultation timings play a crucial role in distinguishing between orbital decay and apsidal precession models, as discussed in the following section.

4. Discussion

The lack of significant preference between models based solely on transit timing variations underscores the complexity of WASP-19b’s orbital dynamics. However, the inclusion of precise occultation timing data provides a powerful tool for differentiating between orbital decay and apsidal precession scenarios.

In the case of pure orbital decay, both transit and occultation timings would show the same quadratic trend in their Observed minus Calculated (O − C) diagrams. Conversely, apsidal precession would cause the transit and occultation timings to vary in opposite directions, resulting in anti-correlated sinusoidal patterns in their respective O − C diagrams.

My precise occultation timings, when analyzed in conjunction with the transit data, reveal subtle differences that are not apparent when considering transit timings alone. This combined analysis provides stronger constraints on the system’s orbital evolution, highlighting the importance of comprehensive phase curve studies in understanding the dynamics of close-in exoplanets.

The discrepancy between our apsidal precession results and those of L. M. Bernabò et al. (2024) highlights the ongoing uncertainty in determining WASP-19b’s orbital evolution. My slower precession rate suggests a longer apsidal motion period, emphasizing the need for extended observational baselines.

5. Conclusion

My analysis of new TESS data for WASP-19b reveals the ongoing challenge in distinguishing between orbital decay and apsidal precession. While I find evidence for orbital variations, the exact nature and rate of these changes remain uncertain. This study highlights the need for continued, long-term observations of WASP-19b to resolve the debate about its orbital evolution and advance our understanding of hot Jupiter dynamics.

Acknowledgments

Facility: TESS - (G. R. Ricker et al. 2015).

Software: Batman (L. Kreidberg 2015), emcee (D. Foreman-Mackey et al. 2013).

Please wait… references are loading.
10.3847/2515-5172/ad77a6