The pitting probability of 2S aluminum was determined in Kingston tap water as a function of area, for areas ranging in size from 0.06 cm2 to 243 cm2. The pitting probability was found to vary uniformly with area, from 0.001 to 1 as the area increased from 0.06 cm2 to 60 cm2; extrapolation indicated that the pitting probability becomes zero at an exposed area of about 0.055 cm2. This work supports the contention that pitting sites in aluminum are not specific macrodefects in the metal surface, but rather arise in a random fashion through the interaction of myriads of anodic and cathodic elements on the metal surface.