Recently, work was published in This Journal on the observation of cathodic current saturation with respect to oxidant species concentration, on the wide‐gap, low mobility, n‐type semiconducting oxides Equation or symbol description not availableTiO2 and Equation or symbol description not availableSrTiO3. These results were interpreted in terms of a kinetic model involving electron transfer through surface states. In the present paper, an alternative explanation is put forward, as suggested by the title, and a detailed comparison made with the trapping kinetic model. The transport‐limited model is quantitatively developed, using the simple depletion‐region approximation, and to the extent the published data allow, comparison made with the experimental results. The relative strengths and weaknesses of the two competing theories are clearly shown. A quantitative test for distinguishing between the two mechanisms is suggested.