Table 2 Photospheric Abundances of Y453, M4, and the Sun Species Y453 M4 RGB M4 HB Sun FG SG FG/RHB SG/BHB Helium -1.08 +or- 0.04 cdots cdots cdots -0.99 +or- 0.02 -1.07 +or- 0.01 Carbon -4.76 +or- 0.10 -4.85 +or- 0.02 -5.01 +or- 0.02 cdots cdots -3.57 +or- 0.05 Nitrogen -4.07 +or- 0.02 -5.03 +or- 0.03 -4.39 +or- 0.02 cdots cdots -4.17 +or- 0.05 Oxygen -3.81 +or- 0.04 -3.89 +or- 0.03 -4.06 +or- 0.03 -3.79 +or- 0.01 -4.02 +or- 0.02 -3.31 +or- 0.05 Sodium cdots -6.83 +or- 0.02 -6.42 +or- 0.02 -6.81 +or- 0.03 -6.46 +or- 0.02 -5.76 +or- 0.04 Silicon -5.02 +or- 0.12 -5.10 +or- 0.02 -5.11 +or- 0.02 cdots cdots -4.49 +or- 0.03 Sulfur -5.63 +or- 0.13 -5.54 +or- 0.03 -5.54 +or- 0.03 cdots cdots -4.88 +or- 0.03 Titanium -5.00 +or- 0.36 -7.85 +or- 0.02 -7.89 +or- 0.01 cdots cdots -7.05 +or- 0.05 Chromium -6.99 +or- 0.23 -7.51 +or- 0.02 -7.50 +or- 0.03 cdots cdots -6.36 +or- 0.04 Iron -5.54 +or- 0.11 -5.64 +or- 0.01 -5.64 +or- 0.02 -5.64 +or- 0.02 -5.57 +or- 0.02 -4.50 +or- 0.04 Nickel -6.01 +or- 0.10 -6.88 +or- 0.01 -6.90 +or- 0.01 cdots cdots -5.78 +or- 0.04 Note. Abundances relative to hydrogen: log N(X)/N(H). M4 RGB values from Villanova & Geisler (2011); sulfur values from Kacharov et al. (2015). M4 HB values from Marino et al. (2011); helium value from Villanova et al. (2012). Solar values from Asplund et al. (2009). FG - first generation; SG - second generation.