For Klein–Gordon and Dirac waves representing massive quantum particles, the local group velocity v (weak value of the velocity operator) can exceed c. If the waves consist of superpositions of many plane waves, with different (but subluminal) group velocities u, the superluminal probability Psuper, i.e. that |v| > c for a randomly selected state, can be calculated explicitly. Psuper depends on two parameters describing the distribution (power spectrum) of u in the superpositions, and lies between 0 and 1/2 for Klein–Gordon waves and 1–1/ and 1/2 for Dirac waves. Numerical simulations display the superluminal intervals in space and regions in spacetime, and support the theoretical predictions for Psuper.