Particle-in-cell (PIC) methods have a long history in the study of laser-plasma interactions. Early electromagnetic codes used the Yee staggered grid for field variables combined with a leapfrog EM-field update and the Boris algorithm for particle pushing. The general properties of such schemes are well documented. Modern PIC codes tend to add to these high-order shape functions for particles, Poisson preserving field updates, collisions, ionisation, a hybrid scheme for solid density and high-field QED effects. In addition to these physics packages, the increase in computing power now allows simulations with real mass ratios, full 3D dynamics and multi-speckle interaction. This paper presents a review of the core algorithms used in current laser-plasma specific PIC codes. Also reported are estimates of self-heating rates, convergence of collisional routines and test of ionisation models which are not readily available elsewhere. Having reviewed the status of PIC algorithms we present a summary of recent applications of such codes in laser-plasma physics, concentrating on SRS, short-pulse laser-solid interactions, fast-electron transport, and QED effects.
Purpose-led Publishing is a coalition of three not-for-profit publishers in the field of physical sciences: AIP Publishing, the American Physical Society and IOP Publishing.
Together, as publishers that will always put purpose above profit, we have defined a set of industry standards that underpin high-quality, ethical scholarly communications.
We are proudly declaring that science is our only shareholder.
ISSN: 1361-6587
Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion is a monthly publication dedicated to the dissemination of original results on all aspects of plasma physics and associated science and technology.
Most read
Open all abstracts, in this tab
T D Arber et al 2015 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 57 113001
R J Groebner and S Saarelma 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 073001
This paper reviews current understanding of key physics elements that control the H-mode pedestal structure, which exists at the boundary of magnetically confined plasmas. The structure of interest is the width, height and gradient of temperature, density and pressure profiles in the pedestal. Emphasis is placed on understanding obtained from combined experimental, theoretical and simulation work and on results observed on multiple machines. Pedestal profiles are determined by the self-consistent interaction of sources, transport and magnetohydrodynamic limits. The heat source is primarily from heat deposited in the core and flowing to the pedestal. This source is computed from modeling of experimental data and is generally well understood. Neutrals at the periphery of the plasma provide the dominant particle source in current machines. This source has a complex spatial structure, is very difficult to measure and is poorly understood. For typical H-mode operation, the achievable pedestal pressure is limited by repetitive, transient magnetohydrodynamic instabilities. First principles models of peeling–ballooning modes are generally able to explain the observed limits. In some regimes, instability occurs below the predicted limits and these remain unexplained. Several mechanisms have been identified as plausible sources of heat transport. These include neoclassical processes for ion heat transport and several turbulent processes, driven by the steep pedestal gradients, as sources of electron and ion heat transport. Reduced models have successfully predicted the pedestal or density at the pedestal top. Firming up understanding of heat and particle transport remains a primary challenge for developing more complete predictive pedestal models.
A Pavone et al 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 053001
This article reviews applications of Bayesian inference and machine learning (ML) in nuclear fusion research. Current and next-generation nuclear fusion experiments require analysis and modelling efforts that integrate different models consistently and exploit information found across heterogeneous data sources in an efficient manner. Model-based Bayesian inference provides a framework well suited for the interpretation of observed data given physics and probabilistic assumptions, also for very complex systems, thanks to its rigorous and straightforward treatment of uncertainties and modelling hypothesis. On the other hand, ML, in particular neural networks and deep learning models, are based on black-box statistical models and allow the handling of large volumes of data and computation very efficiently. For this reason, approaches which make use of ML and Bayesian inference separately and also in conjunction are of particular interest for today's experiments and are the main topic of this review. This article also presents an approach where physics-based Bayesian inference and black-box ML play along, mitigating each other's drawbacks: the former is made more efficient, the latter more interpretable.
M Giacomin et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 055010
In this work, we present first-of-their-kind nonlinear local gyrokinetic (GK) simulations of electromagnetic turbulence at mid-radius in the burning plasma phase of the conceptual high-β, reactor-scale, tight-aspect-ratio tokamak Spherical Tokamak for Energy Production (STEP). A prior linear analysis in Kennedy et al (2023 Nucl. Fusion63 126061) reveals the presence of unstable hybrid kinetic ballooning modes (KBMs), where inclusion of the compressional magnetic field fluctuation, , is crucial, and subdominant microtearing modes (MTMs) are found at binormal scales approaching the ion-Larmor radius. Local nonlinear GK simulations on the selected surface in the central core region suggest that hybrid KBMs can drive large turbulent transport, and that there is negligible turbulent transport from subdominant MTMs when hybrid KBMs are artificially suppressed (through the omission of ). Nonlinear simulations that include perpendicular equilibrium flow shear can saturate at lower fluxes that are more consistent with the available sources in STEP. This analysis suggests that hybrid KBMs could play an important role in setting the turbulent transport in STEP, and possible mechanisms to mitigate turbulent transport are discussed. Increasing the safety factor or the pressure gradient strongly reduces turbulent transport from hybrid KBMs in the cases considered here. Challenges of simulating electromagnetic turbulence in this high-β regime are highlighted. In particular the observation of radially extended turbulent structures in the absence of equilibrium flow shear motivates future advanced global GK simulations that include .
Y Andrew et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 055009
DIII-D plasmas are compared for two upper divertor configurations: with the outer strike point on the small angle slot (SAS) divertor target and with the outer strike point on the horizontal divertor target (HT). Scanning the vertical distance between the magnetic null point and the divertor target over a range 0.10–0.16 m is shown to increase the threshold power, , and edge plasma power, , for the low-to-high confinement (L–H) and H–L transitions respectively, by up to a factor of 1.4. The X-point height scans were performed at three L-mode core plasma line average electron densities, 1.2, 2.2 and 3.6 , to investigate the density dependence of divertor magnetic configuration influence on . The X-point height, , was further extended across the range 0.16–0.22 m with the more open HT divertor configuration, for which a clear decrease in with increasing is observed. The dependence of on divertor magnetic geometry is further investigated using a time-dependent probability density function (PDF) model and information geometry to elucidate the roles played by pedestal plasma turbulence and perpendicular velocity flows. The degree of stochasticity of the plasma turbulence is observed to be sensitive to the plasma heating rate. The calculated square of the information rate shows changes in the relative density fluctuations and perpendicular velocity PDFs begin 2–5 ms prior to the L–H transition for three plasmas; providing a crucial measurement of the dynamic timescale of external transport barrier formation. Additionally, both information length and rate provide potential predictors of the L–H transition for these plasmas.
Clemente Angioni 2021 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 63 073001
In this paper, the theory of collisional and turbulent transport of impurities in tokamak plasmas is reviewed. The results are presented with the aim of providing at the same time a historical reconstruction of the scientific progress and a complete description of the present theoretical knowledge, with a hopefully sufficiently complete reference to the works which have been published in the field in the last decades. After a general introduction on the physics challenges offered by the problem of impurity transport and their relevance for practical nuclear fusion energy, the theory of collisional transport is presented. Here a specific section is also dedicated to the transport parallel to the magnetic field lines. A complete review of the transport mechanisms produced by turbulence follows. The corresponding comparisons between theoretical predictions and experimental observations are also presented, highlighting the influence that the validation activities had in motivating further theoretical investigations. The paper is completed by a section on the direct interactions between collisional and turbulent transport and by a final specific review dedicated to the progress in the theory–based modelling activities. In the writing of this review paper, the main goal has been to combine readability with completeness and scientific rigour, providing a comprehensive list of references for deeper documentation on specific aspects.
Yinlong Guo et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 055012
The discrete and stochastic nature of the processes in the strong-field quantum electrodynamics (SF-QED) regime distinguishes them from classical ones. An important approach to identifying the SF-QED features is through the interaction of extremely intense lasers with plasma. Here, we investigate the seeded QED cascades driven by two counter-propagating laser pulses in the background of residual gases in a vacuum chamber via numerical simulations. We focus on the statistical distributions of positron yields from repeated simulations under various conditions. By increasing the gas density, the positron yields become more deterministic. Although the distribution stems from both the quantum stochastic effects and the fluctuations of the environment, the quantum stochastic effects can be identified via the width of the distribution and the exceptional yields, both of which are higher than the quantum-averaged results. The proposed method provides a statistical approach to identifying the quantum stochastic signatures in SFQED processes using high-power lasers and residual gases in the vacuum chamber.
G L Derks et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 055004
This paper extends a 1D dynamic physics-based model of the scrape-off layer (SOL) plasma, DIV1D, to include the core SOL and possibly a second target. The extended model is benchmarked on 1D mapped SOLPS-ITER simulations to find input settings for DIV1D that allow it to describe SOL plasmas from upstream to target—calibrating it on a scenario and device basis. The benchmark shows a quantitative match between DIV1D and 1D mapped SOLPS-ITER profiles for the heat flux, electron temperature, and electron density within roughly 50% on: (1) the Tokamak Configuration Variable (TCV) for a gas puff scan; (2) a single SOLPS-ITER simulation of the Upgraded Mega Ampere Spherical Tokamak; and (3) the Upgraded Axially Symmetric Divertor EXperiment in Garching Tokamak (AUG) for a simultaneous scan in heating power and gas puff. Once calibrated, DIV1D self-consistently describes dependencies of the SOL solution on core fluxes and external neutral gas densities for a density scan on TCV whereas a varying SOL width is used in DIV1D for AUG to match a simultaneous change in power and density. The ability to calibrate DIV1D on a scenario and device basis is enabled by accounting for cross field transport with an effective flux expansion factor and by allowing neutrals to be exchanged between SOL and adjacent domains.
M Podestà et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 045021
The SMall Aspect Ratio Tokamak (SMART) under commissioning at the University of Seville, Spain, aims to explore confinement properties and possible advantages in confinement for compact/spherical tokamaks operating at negative vs. positive triangularity. This work explores the benefits of auxiliary heating through Neutral Beam Injection (NBI) for SMART scenarios beyond the initial Ohmic phase of operations, in support of the device's mission. Expected values of electron and ion temperature achievable with NBI heating are first predicted for the current flat-top phase, including modeling to optimize the NBI injection geometry to maximize NBI absorption and minimize losses for a given equilibrium. Simulations are then extended for a selected case to cover the current ramp-up phase. Differences with results obtained for the flat-top phase indicate the importance of determining the plasma evolution over time, as well as self-consistently determining the edge plasma parameters for reliable time-dependent simulations. Initial simulation results indicate the advantage of auxiliary NBI heating to achieve nearly double values of pressure and stored energy compared to Ohmic discharges, thus significantly increasing the device's performance. The scenarios developed in this work will also contribute to diagnostic development and optimization for SMART, as well as providing test cases for initial predictions of macro- and micro-instabilities.
Félicie Albert and Alec G R Thomas 2016 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 58 103001
Laser-wakefield accelerators (LWFAs) were proposed more than three decades ago, and while they promise to deliver compact, high energy particle accelerators, they will also provide the scientific community with novel light sources. In a LWFA, where an intense laser pulse focused onto a plasma forms an electromagnetic wave in its wake, electrons can be trapped and are now routinely accelerated to GeV energies. From terahertz radiation to gamma-rays, this article reviews light sources from relativistic electrons produced by LWFAs, and discusses their potential applications. Betatron motion, Compton scattering and undulators respectively produce x-rays or gamma-rays by oscillating relativistic electrons in the wakefield behind the laser pulse, a counter-propagating laser field, or a magnetic undulator. Other LWFA-based light sources include bremsstrahlung and terahertz radiation. We first evaluate the performance of each of these light sources, and compare them with more conventional approaches, including radio frequency accelerators or other laser-driven sources. We have then identified applications, which we discuss in details, in a broad range of fields: medical and biological applications, military, defense and industrial applications, and condensed matter and high energy density science.
Latest articles
Open all abstracts, in this tab
Yang Li et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065008
The mission of negative ion-based neutral beam injection (NNBI) is to conduct experiments with pulses lasting thousands of seconds. It is crucial to develop a simplified physical calculation model for the long-pulse negative ion source in the current NNBI device. This model will be used to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of the selected parameters prior to the experiment, and to assist in adjusting and establishing the experimental parameters for the long-pulse ion source experiment. This paper presents the development of a static performance prediction model using a back propagation neural network. The model assesses the yield of negative hydrogen ions and the quantity of electrons in the ion source under specific parameter conditions, utilizing various experimental parameters as input. The experimental data used for this model are derived from historical data generated during the operation of the 2022 NNBI experiment. The test results indicate that under the current optimal hyperparameter condition, the prediction accuracy of H− ion current (I_H−) is 80.84%, and the prediction accuracy of extraction grid electronic current (I_EG) is 77.57%. This can effectively prevent invalid shots, accurately assess the advantages and disadvantages of the input parameters, and enhance the performance of the long-pulse NNBI device.
L M Pomârjanschi 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065007
The method of using neural networks (NNs) for turbulent transport prediction in a simplified model of tokamak plasmas is explored. The NNs are trained on a database obtained via test-particle simulations of a transport model in the slab-geometrical approximation. It consists of a five-dimensional input of transport model parameters, and the radial diffusion coefficient as output. The NNs display fast and efficient convergence, a validation error below 2, and predictions in excellent agreement with the real data, obtained orders of magnitude faster than test-particle simulations. In comparison to a spline interpolation, the NN outperforms, exhibiting better predicting and extrapolating capabilities. We demonstrate the preciseness and efficiency of this method as a proof-of-concept, establishing a promising approach for future, more comprehensive research on the use of NNs for transport predictions in tokamak plasmas.
O Février et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065005
In recent years, negative triangularity (NT) has emerged as a potential high-confinement L-mode reactor solution. In this work, detachment is investigated using core density ramps in lower single null Ohmic L-mode plasmas across a wide range of upper, lower, and average triangularity (the mean of upper and lower triangularity: δ) in the TCV tokamak. It is universally found that detachment is more difficult to access for NT shaping. The outer divertor leg of discharges with could not be cooled to below through core density ramps alone. The behavior of the upstream plasma and geometrical divertor effects (e.g. a reduced connection length with negative lower triangularity) do not fully explain the challenges in detaching NT plasmas. Langmuir probe measurements of the target heat flux widths (λq) were constant to within 30% across an upper triangularity scan, while the spreading factor S was lower by up to 50% for NT, indicating a generally lower integral scrape-off layer width, λint. The line-averaged core density was typically higher for NT discharges for a given fuelling rate, possibly linked to higher particle confinement in NT. Conversely, the divertor neutral pressure and integrated particle fluxes to the targets were typically lower for the same line-averaged density, indicating that NT configurations may be closer to the sheath-limited regime than their PT counterparts, which may explain why NT is more challenging to detach.
M Wiesenberger and M Held 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065003
A full-F, isothermal, electromagnetic, gyro-fluid model is used to simulate plasma turbulence in a COMPASS-sized, diverted tokamak. A parameter scan covering three orders of magnitude of plasma resistivity and two values for the ion to electron temperature ratio with otherwise fixed parameters is setup and analysed. Two transport regimes for high and low plasma resistivities are revealed. Beyond a critical resistivity the mass and energy confinement reduces with increasing resistivity. Further, for high plasma resistivity the direction of parallel acceleration is swapped compared to low resistivity.
Three-dimensional visualisations using ray tracing techniques are displayed and discussed. The field-alignment of turbulent fluctuations in density and parallel current becomes evident. Relative density fluctuation amplitudes increase from below 1% in the core to 15% in the edge and up to 40% in the scrape-off layer.
Finally, the integration of exact conservation laws over the closed field line region allows for an identification of numerical errors within the simulations. The electron force balance and energy conservation show relative errors on the order of 10−3 while the particle conservation and ion momentum balance show errors on the order of 10−2.
All simulations are performed with a new version of the FELTOR code, which is fully parallelized on GPUs. Each simulation covers a couple of milliseconds of turbulence.
E Tonello et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065006
L-mode negative triangularity (NT) operation is a promising alternative to the positive triangularity (PT) H-mode as a high-confinement edge localised mode-free operational regime. In this work, two TCV Ohmic L-mode core density ramps with opposite triangularity are investigated using SOLPS-ITER modelling. This numerical study aims to investigate the power exhaust differences between NT and PT focusing, in particular, on the geometrical effect of triangularity. To disentangle the latter from differences related to cross-field transport, anomalous diffusivities for particle () and energy () transport are fixed to the same values in PT and NT. The simulation results clearly show dissimilar transport and accumulation of neutral particles in the scrape-off layer for the two configurations. This gives rise to different ionization sources in the edge and divertor regions and produces differences in the poloidal and cross-field fluxes, ultimately leading to different power and particle divertor fluxes in the two configurations. Simulations recover the experimental feature of a hotter and attached outer target ( ) in the NT scenario compared to the PT counterpart.
Review articles
Open all abstracts, in this tab
R J Groebner and S Saarelma 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 073001
This paper reviews current understanding of key physics elements that control the H-mode pedestal structure, which exists at the boundary of magnetically confined plasmas. The structure of interest is the width, height and gradient of temperature, density and pressure profiles in the pedestal. Emphasis is placed on understanding obtained from combined experimental, theoretical and simulation work and on results observed on multiple machines. Pedestal profiles are determined by the self-consistent interaction of sources, transport and magnetohydrodynamic limits. The heat source is primarily from heat deposited in the core and flowing to the pedestal. This source is computed from modeling of experimental data and is generally well understood. Neutrals at the periphery of the plasma provide the dominant particle source in current machines. This source has a complex spatial structure, is very difficult to measure and is poorly understood. For typical H-mode operation, the achievable pedestal pressure is limited by repetitive, transient magnetohydrodynamic instabilities. First principles models of peeling–ballooning modes are generally able to explain the observed limits. In some regimes, instability occurs below the predicted limits and these remain unexplained. Several mechanisms have been identified as plausible sources of heat transport. These include neoclassical processes for ion heat transport and several turbulent processes, driven by the steep pedestal gradients, as sources of electron and ion heat transport. Reduced models have successfully predicted the pedestal or density at the pedestal top. Firming up understanding of heat and particle transport remains a primary challenge for developing more complete predictive pedestal models.
A Pavone et al 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 053001
This article reviews applications of Bayesian inference and machine learning (ML) in nuclear fusion research. Current and next-generation nuclear fusion experiments require analysis and modelling efforts that integrate different models consistently and exploit information found across heterogeneous data sources in an efficient manner. Model-based Bayesian inference provides a framework well suited for the interpretation of observed data given physics and probabilistic assumptions, also for very complex systems, thanks to its rigorous and straightforward treatment of uncertainties and modelling hypothesis. On the other hand, ML, in particular neural networks and deep learning models, are based on black-box statistical models and allow the handling of large volumes of data and computation very efficiently. For this reason, approaches which make use of ML and Bayesian inference separately and also in conjunction are of particular interest for today's experiments and are the main topic of this review. This article also presents an approach where physics-based Bayesian inference and black-box ML play along, mitigating each other's drawbacks: the former is made more efficient, the latter more interpretable.
Annick Pouquet 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 033002
Nonlinear phenomena and turbulence are central to our understanding and modeling of the dynamics of fluids and plasmas, and yet they still resist analytical resolution in many instances. However, progress has been made recently, displaying a richness of phenomena, which was somewhat unexpected a few years back, such as double constant-flux cascades of the same invariant for both large and small scales, or the presence of non-Gaussian wings in large-scale fields, for fluids and plasmas. Here, I will concentrate on the direct measurement of the magnitude of dissipation and the evaluation of intermittency in a turbulent plasma using exact laws stemming from invariance principles and involving cross-correlation tensors with both the velocity and the magnetic fields. I will illustrate these points through scaling laws, together with data analysis from existing experiments, observations and numerical simulations. Finally, I will also briefly explore the possible implications for the validity and use of several modeling strategies.
J Citrin and P Mantica 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 033001
In recent years tokamak experiments and modelling have increasingly indicated that the interaction between suprathermal (fast) ions and thermal plasma can lead to a reduction of turbulence and an improvement of confinement. The regimes in which this stabilization occurs are relevant to burning plasmas, and their understanding will inform reactor scenario optimization. This review summarizes observations, simulations, theoretical understanding, and open questions on this emerging topic.
S M Kaye et al 2021 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 63 123001
In this paper, we review the thermal plasma confinement and transport properties observed and predicted in low aspect ratio tokamaks, or spherical tokamaks (STs), which can depart significantly from those observed at higher aspect ratio. In particular, thermal energy confinement scalings show a strong, near linear dependence of energy confinement time on toroidal magnetic field, while the dependence on plasma current is more modest, the opposite of what is seen at higher aspect ratio. STs have revealed a very strong improvement in normalized confinement with decreasing collisionality, much stronger than at higher aspect ratio, which bodes well for an ST-based fusion pilot plant should this trend continue at an even lower collisionality than has already been accessed. These differences arise because of fundamental differences in transport in STs due to the more extreme toroidicity (i.e. reduced region of bad curvature), and to the relatively larger shearing rates, both of which can suppress electrostatic drift wave instabilities at both ion and electron gyroradius scales. In addition, electromagnetic effects are much stronger in STs because they operate at high βT. Gyrokinetic (GK) studies, coupled with low- and high-k turbulence measurements, have shed light on the underlying physics controlling transport. At lower βT, both ion- and electron-scale electrostatic drift turbulence may be responsible for transport. At higher βT, microtearing, kinetic ballooning, and hybrid trapped electron/kinetic ballooning modes increasingly play a role, and they have a much stronger impact in the core of ST plasmas than at higher aspect ratio. Flow shear affects the balance between ion- and electron-scale modes. Non-linear GK simulations find regimes where the electron heat flux decreases with decreasing collisionality, consistent with the experimental global normalized confinement scaling. The ST is unique in that the relatively low toroidal magnetic field allows for localized measurements of electron-scale turbulence, and this coupled with turbulence measurements at ion-scales has facilitated detailed comparisons with GK simulations. These data have provided compelling evidence for the presence of ion temperature gradient and electron temperature gradient turbulence in some plasmas, and direct experimental support for the impact of experimental actuators like rotation shear, density gradient and magnetic shear on turbulence and transport.
Accepted manuscripts
Open all abstracts, in this tab
Kaltsas et al
We derive axisymmetric equilibrium equations in the context of the hybrid Vlasov model with kinetic ions and massless fluid electrons, assuming isothermal electrons and deformed Maxwellian distribution functions for the kinetic ions. The equilibrium system comprises a Grad-Shafranov partial differential equation and an integral equation. These equations can be utilized to calculate the equilibrium magnetic field and ion distribution function, respectively, for given particle density or given ion and electron toroidal current density profiles. The resulting solutions describe states characterized by toroidal plasma rotation and toroidal electric current density. Additionally, due to the presence of fluid electrons, these equilibria also exhibit a poloidal current density component. This is in contrast to the fully kinetic Vlasov model, where axisymmetric Jeans equilibria can only accommodate toroidal currents and flows, given the absence of a third integral of the microscopic motion.
Guizzo et al
Negative triangularity (NT) tokamak configurations may be more susceptible to magneto-hydrodynamic instability, posing challenges for recent reactor designs centered around their favorable properties, such as improved confinement and operation free of edge-localized modes. In this work, we assess the vertical stability of plasmas with NT shaping and develop potential reactor solutions. When coupled with a conformal wall, NT equilibria are confirmed to be less vertically stable than equivalent positive triangularity (PT) configurations. Unlike PT, their vertical stability is degraded at higher poloidal beta. Furthermore, improvements in vertical stability at low aspect ratio do not translate to the NT geometry. NT equilibria are stabilized in PT vacuum vessels due to the increased proximity of the plasma and the wall on the outboard side, but this scenario is found to be undesirable due to reduced vertical gaps which give less spatial margin for control recovery. Instead, we demonstrate that informed positioning of passively conducting plates can lead to improved vertical stability in NT configurations on par with stability metrics expected in PT scenarios. An optimal setup for passive plates in highly elongated NT devices is presented, where plates on the outboard side of the device reduce vertical instability growth rates to 16% of their baseline value. For lower target elongations, integration of passive stabilizers with divertor concepts can lead to significant improvements in vertical stability. Plates on the inboard side of the device are also uniquely enabled in NT geometries, providing opportunity for spatial separation of vertical stability coils and passive stabilizers.
Choi et al
The self-organization is one of the most interesting phenomena in the non-equilibrium complex system, generating ordered structures of different sizes and durations. In tokamak plasmas, various self-organized phenomena have been reported, and two of them, coexisting in the near-marginal (interaction dominant) regime, are avalanches and the E × B staircase. Avalanches mean the ballistic flux propagation event through successive interactions as it propagates, and the E × B staircase means a globally ordered pattern of self-organized zonal flow layers. Various models have been suggested to understand their characteristics and relation, but experimental researches have been mostly limited to the demonstration of their existence. Here we report detailed analyses of their dynamics and statistics and explain their relation. Avalanches influence the formation and the width distribution of the E × B staircase, while the E × B staircase confines avalanches within its mesoscopic width until dissipated or penetrated. Our perspective to consider them the self-organization phenomena enhances our fundamental understanding of them as well as links our findings with the self-organization of mesoscopic structures in various complex systems.
Giudicotti et al
The perturbation of the interferometric phase is a corrective term of the measured phase shift that should be taken into account in the measurement of the electron line density in a combined interferometer-polarimeter for the diagnostics of the electron density and the magnetic field in a fusion plasma. In this paper we first review in detail the theory of this effect and present a new and complete derivation of it, which also accounts for some errors published in a previous paper. Then we consider this effect in the interferometer-polarimeter of three different plasma devices: RTP, JET and DTT and for each machine we calculate the expected phase perturbation for a typical plasma profile, especially with reference to the use of the popular three-wave technique for the polarization modulation of the input probing beam.
Bierwage et al
It was recently shown that there exists a narrow parameter window where benign sawtooth crashes cause only mixing of bulk plasma and slowed-down alpha particle "ash", while leaving MeV-class fast alphas largely unperturbed [Bierwage et al. Nat. Commun. 13 (2022) 3941]. Here, we revisit the underlying physical picture and reframe it in a manner that may be suitable for systematic analyses of this phenomenon in modeling, simulation and experimental studies. In particular, we propose a graph that we call "time-helicity de-resonation diagram" (short: T-H diagram) that captures the physical essence of energy-selectivity of sawtooth-particle interactions and visualizes it in a compact, intuitive way. Moreover, the regimes of good confinement and strong mixing during a sawtooth crash can be discerned via a single figure of merit: the T-H radius. The concept is introduced here on the basis of simulation results and would eventually benefit from further validation when applied to suitable empirical data.
Open access
Open all abstracts, in this tab
O Février et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065005
In recent years, negative triangularity (NT) has emerged as a potential high-confinement L-mode reactor solution. In this work, detachment is investigated using core density ramps in lower single null Ohmic L-mode plasmas across a wide range of upper, lower, and average triangularity (the mean of upper and lower triangularity: δ) in the TCV tokamak. It is universally found that detachment is more difficult to access for NT shaping. The outer divertor leg of discharges with could not be cooled to below through core density ramps alone. The behavior of the upstream plasma and geometrical divertor effects (e.g. a reduced connection length with negative lower triangularity) do not fully explain the challenges in detaching NT plasmas. Langmuir probe measurements of the target heat flux widths (λq) were constant to within 30% across an upper triangularity scan, while the spreading factor S was lower by up to 50% for NT, indicating a generally lower integral scrape-off layer width, λint. The line-averaged core density was typically higher for NT discharges for a given fuelling rate, possibly linked to higher particle confinement in NT. Conversely, the divertor neutral pressure and integrated particle fluxes to the targets were typically lower for the same line-averaged density, indicating that NT configurations may be closer to the sheath-limited regime than their PT counterparts, which may explain why NT is more challenging to detach.
Dimitrios A Kaltsas et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion
We derive axisymmetric equilibrium equations in the context of the hybrid Vlasov model with kinetic ions and massless fluid electrons, assuming isothermal electrons and deformed Maxwellian distribution functions for the kinetic ions. The equilibrium system comprises a Grad-Shafranov partial differential equation and an integral equation. These equations can be utilized to calculate the equilibrium magnetic field and ion distribution function, respectively, for given particle density or given ion and electron toroidal current density profiles. The resulting solutions describe states characterized by toroidal plasma rotation and toroidal electric current density. Additionally, due to the presence of fluid electrons, these equilibria also exhibit a poloidal current density component. This is in contrast to the fully kinetic Vlasov model, where axisymmetric Jeans equilibria can only accommodate toroidal currents and flows, given the absence of a third integral of the microscopic motion.
Sophia Guizzo et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion
Negative triangularity (NT) tokamak configurations may be more susceptible to magneto-hydrodynamic instability, posing challenges for recent reactor designs centered around their favorable properties, such as improved confinement and operation free of edge-localized modes. In this work, we assess the vertical stability of plasmas with NT shaping and develop potential reactor solutions. When coupled with a conformal wall, NT equilibria are confirmed to be less vertically stable than equivalent positive triangularity (PT) configurations. Unlike PT, their vertical stability is degraded at higher poloidal beta. Furthermore, improvements in vertical stability at low aspect ratio do not translate to the NT geometry. NT equilibria are stabilized in PT vacuum vessels due to the increased proximity of the plasma and the wall on the outboard side, but this scenario is found to be undesirable due to reduced vertical gaps which give less spatial margin for control recovery. Instead, we demonstrate that informed positioning of passively conducting plates can lead to improved vertical stability in NT configurations on par with stability metrics expected in PT scenarios. An optimal setup for passive plates in highly elongated NT devices is presented, where plates on the outboard side of the device reduce vertical instability growth rates to 16% of their baseline value. For lower target elongations, integration of passive stabilizers with divertor concepts can lead to significant improvements in vertical stability. Plates on the inboard side of the device are also uniquely enabled in NT geometries, providing opportunity for spatial separation of vertical stability coils and passive stabilizers.
M Wiesenberger and M Held 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065003
A full-F, isothermal, electromagnetic, gyro-fluid model is used to simulate plasma turbulence in a COMPASS-sized, diverted tokamak. A parameter scan covering three orders of magnitude of plasma resistivity and two values for the ion to electron temperature ratio with otherwise fixed parameters is setup and analysed. Two transport regimes for high and low plasma resistivities are revealed. Beyond a critical resistivity the mass and energy confinement reduces with increasing resistivity. Further, for high plasma resistivity the direction of parallel acceleration is swapped compared to low resistivity.
Three-dimensional visualisations using ray tracing techniques are displayed and discussed. The field-alignment of turbulent fluctuations in density and parallel current becomes evident. Relative density fluctuation amplitudes increase from below 1% in the core to 15% in the edge and up to 40% in the scrape-off layer.
Finally, the integration of exact conservation laws over the closed field line region allows for an identification of numerical errors within the simulations. The electron force balance and energy conservation show relative errors on the order of 10−3 while the particle conservation and ion momentum balance show errors on the order of 10−2.
All simulations are performed with a new version of the FELTOR code, which is fully parallelized on GPUs. Each simulation covers a couple of milliseconds of turbulence.
E Tonello et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065006
L-mode negative triangularity (NT) operation is a promising alternative to the positive triangularity (PT) H-mode as a high-confinement edge localised mode-free operational regime. In this work, two TCV Ohmic L-mode core density ramps with opposite triangularity are investigated using SOLPS-ITER modelling. This numerical study aims to investigate the power exhaust differences between NT and PT focusing, in particular, on the geometrical effect of triangularity. To disentangle the latter from differences related to cross-field transport, anomalous diffusivities for particle () and energy () transport are fixed to the same values in PT and NT. The simulation results clearly show dissimilar transport and accumulation of neutral particles in the scrape-off layer for the two configurations. This gives rise to different ionization sources in the edge and divertor regions and produces differences in the poloidal and cross-field fluxes, ultimately leading to different power and particle divertor fluxes in the two configurations. Simulations recover the experimental feature of a hotter and attached outer target ( ) in the NT scenario compared to the PT counterpart.
Z H Wang et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065002
Plasma confinement and transport in tokamaks play a crucial role in the development of high poloidal beta steady-state operation scenarios. Therefore, it is very important to study the relevant mechanism of internal transport barriers (ITBs), which can help plasmas to obtain better confinement in order to achieve higher fusion gain. This paper mainly introduces the analysis of the characteristics of electron heat transport of discharges with ITB in high operation regime in Experimental Advanced Superconducting Tokamak (EAST). Based on the statistical analysis of stable discharges with > 1.5, it is found that there is an obvious bifurcation of the normalised electron temperature gradient (ETG) () in the range of = 2–2.2. Then the discharges of lower ( < 2, where the value of is below the bifurcation threshold) and of higher ( > 2.2, where the value of is above the threshold) were selected for analysis. The diagnostic data provided by Thomson scattering, x-ray crystal spectrometry and charge exchange recombination spectroscopy are used to provide reliable parameter profiles and then combined with the data of external magnetic probe measurements and the polarisation interferometer diagnosis system to fully reconstruct the balance. A relevant plasma current calculation model is used to calculate and analyse the current density profiles and power deposition, and then the transport analysis is carried out. Interestingly, in the higher discharges, it is found that the turbulence intensity provided by the CO2 laser collective scattering system gradually decreases and the normalised ETG gradually increases. It is also found that the electron heat transport coefficient decreases in the discharge with higher and the growth rate of the electron-scale turbulence calculated by transport gyro-Landau fluid (TGLF) is significantly reduced. Meanwhile, similar conclusions are also obtained in the discharges when the is further increased.
S Bannmann et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 065001
By employing Bayesian inference techniques, the full electron density profile from the plasma core to the edge of Wendelstein 7-X (W7-X) is inferred solely from neutral hydrogen beam and halo Balmer-α (Hα) emission data. The halo is a cloud of neutrals forming in the vicinity of the injected neutral beam due to multiple charge exchange reactions. W7-X is equipped with several neutral hydrogen beam heating sources and an Hα spectroscopy system that views these sources from different angles and penetration depths in the plasma. As the beam and halo emission form complex spectra for each spatial point that are non-linearly dependent on the plasma density profile and other parameters, a complete model from the neutral beam injection and halo formation through to the spectroscopic measurements is required. The model is used here to infer electron density profiles for a range of common W7-X plasma scenarios. The inferred profiles show good agreement with profiles determined by the Thomson scattering and interferometry diagnostics across a broad range of absolute densities without any changes to the input or fitting parameters. The time evolution of the density profile in a discharge with continuous core density peaking is successfully reconstructed, demonstrating sufficient spatial resolution to infer strongly shaped profiles. Furthermore, it is shown as a proof of concept that the model is also able to infer the main ion temperature profile using the same data set.
Andreas Bierwage et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion
It was recently shown that there exists a narrow parameter window where benign sawtooth crashes cause only mixing of bulk plasma and slowed-down alpha particle "ash", while leaving MeV-class fast alphas largely unperturbed [Bierwage et al. Nat. Commun. 13 (2022) 3941]. Here, we revisit the underlying physical picture and reframe it in a manner that may be suitable for systematic analyses of this phenomenon in modeling, simulation and experimental studies. In particular, we propose a graph that we call "time-helicity de-resonation diagram" (short: T-H diagram) that captures the physical essence of energy-selectivity of sawtooth-particle interactions and visualizes it in a compact, intuitive way. Moreover, the regimes of good confinement and strong mixing during a sawtooth crash can be discerned via a single figure of merit: the T-H radius. The concept is introduced here on the basis of simulation results and would eventually benefit from further validation when applied to suitable empirical data.
James R Harrison et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion
The integration of good core and edge/pedestal confinement with strong dissipation of heat and particles in the divertors is a significant challenge for the development of fusion energy. Alternative divertor configurations offer potential advantages by broadening the operational space where a device can operate with detached divertors and acceptible power exhaust. First results from MAST Upgrade are presented from high confinement mode experiments with outer divertors in the Super-X divertor configuration, showing that the outer divertors naturally detach when the Super-X is formed with no discernible impact on the plasma core and pedestal. These initial findings confirm predicted benefits of the Super-X configuration in terms of facilitating scenario integration.
Nathan Mackey et al 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 055018
In curved magnetic geometries, field-aligned regions of enhanced plasma pressure and density, termed 'blobs,' move as coherent filaments across the magnetic field lines. Coherent blobs account for a significant fraction of transport at the edges of magnetic fusion experiments and arise in naturally-occurring space plasmas. This work examines the dynamics of blobs with a fully kinetic electromagnetic particle-in-cell code and with a drift-reduced fluid code. In low-beta regimes with moderate blob speeds, good agreement is found in the maximum blob velocity between the two simulation schemes and simple analytical estimates. The fully kinetic code demonstrates that blob speeds saturate near the initial sound speed, which is a regime outside the validity of the reduced fluid model.