Table of contents

Volume 26

Number 7, July 2010

Previous issue Next issue

Special issue on electromagnetic inverse problems: emerging methods and novel applications

Buy this issue in print

Editorial

070201

and

Inverse problems in electromagnetics have a long history and have stimulated exciting research over many decades. New applications and solution methods are still emerging, providing a rich source of challenging topics for further investigation. The purpose of this special issue is to combine descriptions of several such developments that are expected to have the potential to fundamentally fuel new research, and to provide an overview of novel methods and applications for electromagnetic inverse problems.

There have been several special sections published in Inverse Problems over the last decade addressing fully, or partly, electromagnetic inverse problems. Examples are:

  • Electromagnetic imaging and inversion of the Earth's subsurface (Guest Editors: D Lesselier and T Habashy) October 2000

  • Testing inversion algorithms against experimental data (Guest Editors: K Belkebir and M Saillard) December 2001

  • Electromagnetic and ultrasonic nondestructive evaluation (Guest Editors: D Lesselier and J Bowler) December 2002

  • Electromagnetic characterization of buried obstacles (Guest Editors: D Lesselier and W C Chew) December 2004

  • Testing inversion algorithms against experimental data: inhomogeneous targets (Guest Editors: K Belkebir and M Saillard) December 2005

  • Testing inversion algorithms against experimental data: 3D targets (Guest Editors: A Litman and L Crocco) February 2009

In a certain sense, the current issue can be understood as a continuation of this series of special sections on electromagnetic inverse problems. On the other hand, its focus is intended to be more general than previous ones. Instead of trying to cover a well-defined, somewhat specialized research topic as completely as possible, this issue aims to show the broad range of techniques and applications that are relevant to electromagnetic imaging nowadays, which may serve as a source of inspiration and encouragement for all those entering this active and rapidly developing research area.

Also, the construction of this special issue is likely to have been different from preceding ones. In addition to the invitations sent to specific research groups involved in electromagnetic inverse problems, the Guest Editors also solicited recommendations, from a large number of experts, of potential authors who were thereupon encouraged to contribute. Moreover, an open call for contributions was published on the homepage of Inverse Problems in order to attract as wide a scope of contributions as possible.

This special issue's attempt at generality might also define its limitations: by no means could this collection of papers be exhaustive or complete, and as Guest Editors we are well aware that many exciting topics and potential contributions will be missing. This, however, also determines its very special flavor: besides addressing electromagnetic inverse problems in a broad sense, there were only a few restrictions on the contributions considered for this section. One requirement was plausible evidence of either novelty or the emergent nature of the technique or application described, judged mainly by the referees, and in some cases by the Guest Editors. The technical quality of the contributions always remained a stringent condition of acceptance, final adjudication (possibly questionable either way, not always positive) being made in most cases once a thorough revision process had been carried out. Therefore, we hope that the final result presented here constitutes an interesting collection of novel ideas and applications, properly refereed and edited, which will find its own readership and which can stimulate significant new research in the topics represented.

Overall, as Guest Editors, we feel quite fortunate to have obtained such a strong response to the call for this issue and to have a really wide-ranging collection of high-quality contributions which, indeed, can be read from the first to the last page with sustained enthusiasm. A large number of applications and techniques is represented, overall via 16 contributions with 45 authors in total. This shows, in our opinion, that electromagnetic imaging and inversion remain amongst the most challenging and active research areas in applied inverse problems today. Below, we give a brief overview of the contributions included in this issue, ordered alphabetically by the surname of the leading author.

1. The complexity of handling potential randomness of the source in an inverse scattering problem is not minor, and the literature is far from being replete in this configuration. The contribution by G Bao, S N Chow, P Li and H Zhou, `Numerical solution of an inverse medium scattering problem with a stochastic source', exemplifies how to hybridize Wiener chaos expansion with a recursive linearization method in order to solve the stochastic problem as a set of decoupled deterministic ones. 2. In cases where the forward problem is expensive to evaluate, database methods might become a reliable method of choice, while enabling one to deliver more information on the inversion itself. The contribution by S Bilicz, M Lambert and Sz Gyimóthy, `Kriging-based generation of optimal databases as forward and inverse surrogate models', describes such a technique which uses kriging for constructing an efficient database with the goal of achieving an equidistant distribution of points in the measurement space. 3. Anisotropy remains a considerable challenge in electromagnetic imaging, which is tackled in the contribution by F Cakoni, D Colton, P Monk and J Sun, `The inverse electromagnetic scattering problem for anisotropic media', via the fact that transmission eigenvalues can be retrieved from a far-field scattering pattern, yielding, in particular, lower and upper bounds of the index of refraction of the unknown (dielectric anisotropic) scatterer. 4. So-called subspace optimization methods (SOM) have attracted a lot of interest recently in many fields. The contribution by X Chen, `Subspace-based optimization method for inverse scattering problems with an inhomogeneous background medium', illustrates how to address a realistic situation in which the medium containing the unknown obstacles is not homogeneous, via blending a properly developed SOM with a finite-element approach to the required Green's functions. 5. H Egger, M Hanke, C Schneider, J Schöberl and S Zaglmayr, in their contribution `Adjoint-based sampling methods for electromagnetic scattering', show how to efficiently develop sampling methods without explicit knowledge of the dyadic Green's function once an adjoint problem has been solved at much lower computational cost. This is demonstrated by examples in demanding propagative and diffusive situations. 6. Passive sensor arrays can be employed to image reflectors from ambient noise via proper migration of cross-correlation matrices into their embedding medium. This is investigated, and resolution, in particular, is considered in detail, as a function of the characteristics of the sensor array and those of the noise, in the contribution by J Garnier and G Papanicolaou, `Resolution analysis for imaging with noise'. 7. A direct reconstruction technique based on the conformal mapping theorem is proposed and investigated in depth in the contribution by H Haddar and R Kress, `Conformal mapping and impedance tomography'. This paper expands on previous work, with inclusions in homogeneous media, convergence results, and numerical illustrations. 8. The contribution by T Hohage and S Langer, `Acceleration techniques for regularized Newton methods applied to electromagnetic inverse medium scattering problems', focuses on a spectral preconditioner intended to accelerate regularized Newton methods as employed for the retrieval of a local inhomogeneity in a three-dimensional vector electromagnetic case, while also illustrating the implementation of a Lepskiĭ-type stopping rule outsmarting a traditional discrepancy principle. 9. Geophysical applications are a rich source of practically relevant inverse problems. The contribution by M Li, A Abubakar and T Habashy, `Application of a two-and-a-half dimensional model-based algorithm to crosswell electromagnetic data inversion', deals with a model-based inversion technique for electromagnetic imaging which addresses novel challenges such as multi-physics inversion, and incorporation of prior knowledge, such as in hydrocarbon recovery. 10. Non-stationary inverse problems, considered as a special class of Bayesian inverse problems, are framed via an orthogonal decomposition representation in the contribution by A Lipponen, A Seppänen and J P Kaipio, `Reduced order estimation of nonstationary flows with electrical impedance tomography'. The goal is to simultaneously estimate, from electrical impedance tomography data, certain characteristics of the Navier--Stokes fluid flow model together with time-varying concentration distribution. 11. Non-iterative imaging methods of thin, penetrable cracks, based on asymptotic expansion of the scattering amplitude and analysis of the multi-static response matrix, are discussed in the contribution by W-K Park, `On the imaging of thin dielectric inclusions buried within a half-space', completing, for a shallow burial case at multiple frequencies, the direct imaging of small obstacles (here, along their transverse dimension), MUSIC and non-MUSIC type indicator functions being used for that purpose. 12. The contribution by R Potthast, `A study on orthogonality sampling' envisages quick localization and shaping of obstacles from (portions of) far-field scattering patterns collected at one or more time-harmonic frequencies, via the simple calculation (and summation) of scalar products between those patterns and a test function. This is numerically exemplified for Neumann/Dirichlet boundary conditions and homogeneous/heterogeneous embedding media. 13. The contribution by J D Shea, P Kosmas, B D Van Veen and S C Hagness, `Contrast-enhanced microwave imaging of breast tumors: a computational study using 3D realistic numerical phantoms', aims at microwave medical imaging, namely the early detection of breast cancer. The use of contrast enhancing agents is discussed in detail and a number of reconstructions in three-dimensional geometry of realistic numerical breast phantoms are presented. 14. The contribution by D A Subbarayappa and V Isakov, `Increasing stability of the continuation for the Maxwell system', discusses enhanced log-type stability results for continuation of solutions of the time-harmonic Maxwell system, adding a fresh chapter to the interesting story of the study of the Cauchy problem for PDE. 15. In their contribution, `Recent developments of a monotonicity imaging method for magnetic induction tomography in the small skin-depth regime', A Tamburrino, S Ventre and G Rubinacci extend the recently developed monotonicity method toward the application of magnetic induction tomography in order to map surface-breaking defects affecting a damaged metal component. 16. The contribution by F Viani, P Rocca, M Benedetti, G Oliveri and A Massa, `Electromagnetic passive localization and tracking of moving targets in a WSN-infrastructured environment', contributes to what could still be seen as a niche problem, yet both useful in terms of applications, e.g., security, and challenging in terms of methodologies and experiments, in particular, in view of the complexity of environments in which this endeavor is to take place and the variability of the wireless sensor networks employed.

To conclude, we would like to thank the able and tireless work of Kate Watt and Zoë Crossman, as past and present Publishers of the Journal, on what was definitely a long and exciting journey (sometimes a little discouraging when reports were not arriving, or authors were late, or Guest Editors overwhelmed) that started from a thorough discussion at the `Manchester workshop on electromagnetic inverse problems' held mid-June 2009, between Kate Watt and the Guest Editors. We gratefully acknowledge the fact that W W Symes gave us his full backing to carry out this special issue and that A K Louis completed it successfully. Last, but not least, the staff of Inverse Problems should be thanked, since they work together to make it a premier journal.

Papers

074001

and

We analyze the resolution of imaging functionals that migrate the cross-correlation matrices of passive sensor arrays. These matrices are obtained by cross-correlating signals emitted by ambient noise sources and recorded by the passive sensor array. They contain information about reflectors in the surrounding medium. Therefore, travel time or Kirchhoff migration of the cross-correlations can, under favorable circumstances, produce images of such reflectors. However, migration should be carried out appropriately depending on the type of illumination provided by the ambient noise sources. We present here a detailed resolution analysis of these functionals in a homogeneous medium. Resolution depends on the sensor array diameter, the distance from the array to the reflector and the central frequency, as is the case in active array imaging. When imaging with passive sensor arrays and ambient noise, resolution also depends on the space and time coherence of the noise sources because it determines an effective noise bandwidth.

074002

and

Akduman and Kress (2002 Inverse Problems18 1659–1672), Haddar and Kress (2005 Inverse Problems21 935–953), and Kress (2004 Math. Comput. Simul.66 255–265) have employed a conformal mapping technique for the inverse problem to recover a perfectly conducting or a non-conducting inclusion in a homogeneous background medium from the Cauchy data on the accessible exterior boundary. We propose an extension of this approach to two-dimensional inverse electrical impedance tomography with piecewise constant conductivities. A main ingredient of our method is the incorporation of the transmission condition on the unknown interior boundary via a nonlocal boundary condition in terms of an integral equation. We present the foundations of the method, a local convergence result and exhibit the feasibility of the method via numerical examples.

074003

, , , and

In this paper, an innovative strategy for the passive localization of transceiver-free objects is presented. The localization is yielded by processing the received signal strength data measured in an infrastructured environment. The problem is reformulated in terms of an inverse source one, where the probability map of the presence of an equivalent source modeling the moving target is looked for. Toward this end, a customized classification procedure based on a support vector machine is exploited. Selected, but representative, experimental results are reported to assess the feasibility of the proposed approach and to show the potentialities and applicability of this passive and unsupervised technique.

074004

, , and

The inverse electromagnetic scattering problem for anisotropic media plays a special role in inverse scattering theory due to the fact that the (matrix) index of refraction is not uniquely determined from the far field pattern of the scattered field even if multi-frequency data are available. In this paper, we describe how transmission eigenvalues can be determined from the far field pattern and be used to obtain upper and lower bounds on the norm of the index of refraction. Numerical examples will be given for the case when the scattering object is an infinite cylinder and the inhomogeneous medium is orthotropic.

074005

and

In this paper, we obtain bounds showing increasing stability of the continuation for solutions of the stationary Maxwell system when the wave number k is growing. We reduce this system to a new system with the Helmholtz operator in the principal part and use hyperbolic energy and Carleman estimates with k-independent constants in the Cauchy problem for this new system. We consider the continuation onto the convex hull of the surface with the Cauchy data. Hyperbolic energy estimates suggest an existence of increasing (with k) subspaces, where the solution of the Cauchy problem is Lipschitz stable disregard of any (pseudo) convexity assumptions.

074006

, , , and

In this paper we investigate the efficient realization of sampling methods based on solutions of certain adjoint problems. This adjoint approach does not require the explicit knowledge of the Green's function for the background medium, and allows us to sample for all points and all dipole directions simultaneously; thus, several limitations of standard sampling methods are relieved. A detailed derivation of the adjoint approach is presented for two electromagnetic model problems, but the framework can be applied to a much wider class of problems. We also discuss a relation of the adjoint sampling method to standard backprojection algorithms, and present numerical tests that illustrate the efficiency of the adjoint approach.

074007

This paper proposes a version of the subspace-based optimization method to solve the inverse scattering problem with an inhomogeneous background medium where the known inhomogeneities are bounded in a finite domain. Although the background Green's function at each discrete point in the computational domain is not directly available in an inhomogeneous background scenario, the paper uses the finite element method to simultaneously obtain the Green's function at all discrete points. The essence of the subspace-based optimization method is that part of the contrast source is determined from the spectrum analysis without using any optimization, whereas the orthogonally complementary part is determined by solving a lower dimension optimization problem. This feature significantly speeds up the convergence of the algorithm and at the same time makes it robust against noise. Numerical simulations illustrate the efficacy of the proposed algorithm. The algorithm presented in this paper finds wide applications in nondestructive evaluation, such as through-wall imaging.

074008

Motivated from the application area of imaging of anti-personnel mines completely embedded in the homogeneous medium, the problem of non-iterative imaging of thin dielectric inclusions buried within a dielectric half-space is considered. For that purpose, an imaging algorithm operated at several frequencies is proposed. It is based on the asymptotic expansion formula of the scattering amplitude in the presence of the inclusions. Various numerical examples illustrate how the method behaves.

074009

, , and

The detection of early-stage tumors in the breast by microwave imaging is challenged by both the moderate endogenous dielectric contrast between healthy and malignant glandular tissues and the spatial resolution available from illumination at microwave frequencies. The high endogenous dielectric contrast between adipose and fibroglandular tissue structures increases the difficulty of tumor detection due to the high dynamic range of the contrast function to be imaged and the low level of signal scattered from a tumor relative to the clutter scattered by normal tissue structures. Microwave inverse scattering techniques, used to estimate the complete spatial profile of the dielectric properties within the breast, have the potential to reconstruct both normal and cancerous tissue structures. However, the ill-posedness of the associated inverse problem often limits the frequency of microwave illumination to the UHF band within which early-stage cancers have sub-wavelength dimensions. In this computational study, we examine the reconstruction of small, compact tumors in three-dimensional numerical breast phantoms by a multiple-frequency inverse scattering solution. Computer models are also employed to investigate the use of exogenous contrast agents for enhancing tumor detection. Simulated array measurements are acquired before and after the introduction of the assumed contrast effects for two specific agents currently under consideration for breast imaging: microbubbles and carbon nanotubes. Differential images of the applied contrast demonstrate the potential of the approach for detecting the preferential uptake of contrast agents by malignant tissues.

074010

, and

In this paper, we consider the simultaneous reconstruction of a nonstationary concentration distribution and the underlying nonstationary flow field. As the observation modality, we employ electrical impedance tomography. Earlier studies have shown that such an estimation scheme is in principle possible since the evolution of an inhomogeneous concentration carries information also on the velocity field. These results have, however, been restricted to either stationary velocity fields or simplified non-physical models. In the general case, the estimation of the velocity field up to the fine details of the flow with diffuse tomography is impossible. In this paper we show, however, that it is possible to estimate a reduced-order representation of a physical fluid dynamics model, here the Navier–Stokes model, simultaneously with the concentration. This is accomplished by considering a proper orthogonal decomposition representation for the velocity field, and careful modelling of the uncertainties of the models, in particular, the subspace of the velocity field that is not estimated. We assess the approach with two numerical examples in which a projection of a vortex flow is reconstructed.

074011

and

We study the construction and updating of spectral preconditioners for regularized Newton methods and their application to electromagnetic inverse medium scattering problems. Moreover, we show how a Lepski-type stopping rule can be implemented efficiently for these methods. In numerical examples, the proposed method compares favorably with other iterative regularization method in terms of work-precision diagrams for exact data. For data perturbed by random noise, the Lepski-type stopping rule performs considerably better than the commonly used discrepancy principle.

074012

, and

Numerical methods are used to simulate mathematical models for a wide range of engineering problems. The precision provided by such simulators is usually fine, but at the price of computational cost. In some applications this cost might be crucial. This leads us to consider cheap surrogate models in order to reduce the computation time still meeting the precision requirements. Among all available surrogate models, we deal herein with the generation of an 'optimal' database of pre-calculated results combined with a simple interpolator. A database generation approach is investigated which is intended to achieve an optimal sampling. Such databases can be used for the approximate solution of both forward and inverse problems. Their structure carries some meta-information about the involved physical problem. In the case of the inverse problem, an approach for predicting the uncertainty of the solution (due to the applied surrogate model and/or the uncertainty of the measured data) is presented. All methods are based on kriging—a stochastic tool for function approximation. Illustrative examples are drawn from eddy current non-destructive evaluation.

074013

, and

In this paper, we apply a model-based inversion scheme for the interpretation of the crosswell electromagnetic data. In this approach, we use open and closed polygons to parameterize the unknown configuration. The parameters that define these polygons are then inverted for by minimizing the data misfit cost function. Compared with the pixel-based inversion approach, the model-based inversion uses only a few number of parameters; hence, it is more efficient. Furthermore, with sufficient sensitivity in the data, the model-based approach can provide quantitative estimates of the inverted parameters such as the conductivity. The model-based inversion also provides a convenient way to incorporate a priori information from other independent measurements such as seismic, gravity and well logs.

074014

, , and

This paper is concerned with the inverse medium scattering problem with a stochastic source, the reconstruction of the refractive index of an inhomogeneous medium from the boundary measurements of the scattered field. As an inverse problem, there are two major difficulties in addition to being highly nonlinear: the ill-posedness and the presence of many local minima. To overcome these difficulties, a stable and efficient recursive linearization method has been recently developed for solving the inverse medium scattering problem with a deterministic source. Compared to classical inverse problems, stochastic inverse problems, referred to as inverse problems involving uncertainties, have substantially more difficulties due to randomness and uncertainties. Based on the Wiener chaos expansion, the stochastic problem is converted into a set of decoupled deterministic problems. The strategy developed is a new hybrid method combining the WCE with the recursive linearization method for solving the inverse medium problem with a stochastic source. Numerical experiments are reported to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.

074015

The goal of this paper is to study and further develop the orthogonality sampling or stationary waves algorithm for the detection of the location and shape of objects from the far field pattern of scattered waves in electromagnetics or acoustics. Orthogonality sampling can be seen as a special beam forming algorithm with some links to the point source method and to the linear sampling method. The basic idea of orthogonality sampling is to sample the space under consideration by calculating scalar products of the measured far field pattern , with a test function for all y in a subset Q of the space , m = 2, 3. The way in which this is carried out is important to extract the information which the scattered fields contain. The theoretical foundation of orthogonality sampling is only partly resolved, and the goal of this work is to initiate further research by numerical demonstration of the high potential of the approach. We implement the method for a two-dimensional setting for the Helmholtz equation, which represents electromagnetic scattering when the setup is independent of the third coordinate. We show reconstructions of the location and shape of objects from measurements of the scattered field for one or several directions of incidence and one or many frequencies or wave numbers, respectively. In particular, we visualize the indicator function both with the Dirichlet and Neumann boundary condition and for complicated inhomogeneous media.

074016

, and

This paper is focused on the non-iterative (direct) imaging of conductive materials from magnetic induction tomography data. Specifically, the interest is on the imaging of surface-breaking defects in the so-called small skin-depth regime where (i) the skin depth is smaller than the relevant geometrical size of the problem and (ii) the displacement current is still negligible. Under these conditions the problem can be modeled by means of an elliptic PDE. Therefore, the inverse problem can be solved by means of the 'monotonicity imaging method', a fast non-iterative algorithm recently developed by the authors for solving inverse problems arising from elliptic PDEs as in the case of electrical resistance tomography, electrical capacitance tomography and low-frequency magnetic induction tomography (in the large skin-depth regime). Major contributions of this work are (i) an advancement of the inversion method and (ii) a methodology to systematically design the probe. Numerical examples prove the effectiveness of this near real-time imaging method.